KOSTIĆ A OSTATNÍ proti Srbsku

Přehled

Text rozhodnutí

Datum rozhodnutí

23.3.2023

Rozhodovací formace

výbor

Významnost

Číslo stížnosti / sp. zn.

14203/22

Rozhodnutí

FOURTH SECTION

DECISION

Application no. 14203/22
Zoran KOSTIĆ against Serbia
and 178 other applications

(see appended table)

The European Court of Human Rights (Fourth Section), sitting on 23 March 2023 as a Committee composed of:

Tim Eicke, President,
Branko Lubarda,
Ana Maria Guerra Martins, judges,

and Viktoriya Maradudina, Acting Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table,

Having regard to the formal declarations accepting a friendly settlement of the cases,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

FACTS AND PROCEDURE

The list of applicants is set out in the appended table.

The applicants were represented by M S. Aleksić, a lawyer practising in Niš.

The applicants’ complaints under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 concerning the non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic decisions given against socially/State-owned companies were communicated to the Serbian Government (“the Government”).

The Court received the friendly-settlement declarations, signed by the parties, under which the applicants agreed to waive any further claims against Serbia in respect of the facts giving rise to these applications, subject to an undertaking by the Government to pay them the amounts detailed in the appended table. These amounts will be converted into the currency of the respondent State at the rate applicable on the date of payment, and will be payable within three months from the date of notification of the Court’s decision. In the event of failure to pay these amounts within the above‑mentioned three-month period, the Government undertake to pay simple interest on them, from the expiry of that period until settlement, at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points. The Government also undertake to ensure the enforcement of the domestic decisions under consideration in the cases concerned (see appended table) within the same three-month period, and to pay any costs of the domestic enforcement proceedings.

The payment and the enforcement of the domestic decisions in the cases concerned will constitute the final resolution of the cases.

THE LAW

Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.

The Court takes note of the friendly settlement reached between the parties. It is satisfied that the settlement is based on respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto and finds no reasons to justify a continued examination of the applications.

In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the cases out of the list.

For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,

Decides to join the applications;

Decides to strike the applications out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 39 of the Convention.

Done in English and notified in writing on 13 April 2023.

Viktoriya Maradudina Tim Eicke
Acting Deputy Registrar President

APPENDIX

List of applications raising complaints under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1

(non-enforcement of domestic decisions given against socially/State-owned companies)

No.	Application no. Date of introduction	Applicant’s name Year of birth	Date of receipt of Government’s declaration	Date of receipt of Applicant’s declaration	Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage per applicant (in euros) [1] [2]	Amount awarded for costs and expenses per application (in euros) [3]
	14203/22 09/03/2022	Zoran KOSTIĆ 1961	14/12/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14206/22 09/03/2022	Emina DABIĆ 1985	30/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14299/22 09/03/2022	Miodrag RISTIĆ 1958	14/12/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14433/22 09/03/2022	Miroljub STANOJEVIĆ 1952	14/12/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14593/22 09/03/2022	Zoran RADOJKOVIĆ 1964	30/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14595/22 09/03/2022	Dejan PAVLOVIĆ 1969	14/12/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14600/22 09/03/2022	Branko MILOSAVLJEVIĆ 1952	14/12/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14606/22 09/03/2022	Nebojša JOVANOVIĆ 1977	30/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14611/22 09/03/2022	Aleksandar STOŠIĆ 1969	30/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14617/22 09/03/2022	Darko MARINKOVIĆ 1971	14/12/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14623/22 09/03/2022	Paulina MLADENOVIĆ 1938	30/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14635/22 09/03/2022	Dobrila STANIĆ 1957	22/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14636/22 09/03/2022	Goran GRUJIĆ 1967	30/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14644/22 09/03/2022	Željko MIHAJLOVIĆ 1971	14/12/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14666/22 09/03/2022	Zoran MILOSAVLJEVIĆ 1969	14/12/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	14677/22 09/03/2022	Novica MANČIĆ 1965	30/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	16170/22 22/03/2022	Slađana ZLATKOVIĆ 1972	22/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	18366/22 01/04/2022	Dragan MAKSIMOVIĆ 1958	30/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	18368/22 01/04/2022	Biljana MUTAVDŽIĆ 1968	16/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18371/22 01/04/2022	Vesko KOCIĆ 1958	30/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	18396/22 01/04/2022	Saša RANKOVIĆ 1975	16/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18406/22 01/04/2022	Ivana FARA 1979	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18413/22 01/04/2022	Miloš NIKOLIĆ 1982	30/11/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18425/22 01/04/2022	Vladica NIKOLIĆ 1963	30/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	18670/22 01/04/2022	Biljana KRISTIĆ 1973	16/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18680/22 01/04/2022	Dalibor IVKOVIĆ 1987	16/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18702/22 01/04/2022	Novica RISTIĆ 1953	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18720/22 01/04/2022	Goran PETROVIĆ 1967	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18721/22 01/04/2022	Gordana ANĐELKOVIĆ 1971	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18726/22 01/04/2022	Dragan JOVANOVIĆ 1965	16/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18730/22 01/04/2022	Dobrivoje RISTIĆ 1958	30/11/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18736/22 01/04/2022	Radivoje FILIPOVIĆ 1961	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18742/22 01/04/2022	Dejan ILIĆ 1981	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18744/22 01/04/2022	Dragan SIMIĆ 1969	30/11/2022	12/12/2022	1,000	250
	18749/22 11/04/2022	Saša DONČEV 1983	16/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18753/22 01/04/2022	Slaviša JOVANOVIĆ 1949	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18760/22 01/04/2022	Dragana STANKOVIĆ 1972	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	18772/22 01/04/2022	Radomir JOVANOVIĆ 1967	30/11/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18774/22 01/04/2022	Dragoslavka PANTIĆ 1964	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	18778/22 01/04/2022	Marko TASIĆ 1945	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	18791/22 01/04/2022	Jelica RAKIĆ 1980	16/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18799/22 01/04/2022	Mirko PETROVIĆ 1971	30/11/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18800/22 01/04/2022	Zoran SIMIĆ 1960	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	18801/22 11/04/2022	Nikola ALEKSIĆ 1967	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	18803/22 01/04/2022	Toni MILADINOVIĆ 1973	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	18804/22 01/04/2022	Vesna ZLATANOVIĆ 1968	16/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18806/22 01/04/2022	Milorad PETROVIĆ 1947	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	18809/22 01/04/2022	Biljana ZDRAVKOVIĆ 1969	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	18823/22 01/04/2022	Miloš MILENKOVIĆ 1955	30/11/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18836/22 01/04/2022	Jovan KUKIĆ 1967	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	18842/22 01/04/2022	Dragana JOVIČIĆ 1970	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	18846/22 01/04/2022	Dragan JOVANOVIĆ 1971	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18848/22 01/04/2022	Dragovan RAKIĆ 1951	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	18856/22 01/04/2022	Jasna TUFEGDŽIĆ 1965	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18859/22 01/04/2022	Radisav VOJINOVIĆ 1958	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	18860/22 01/04/2022	Mališa NOVAKOVIĆ 1968	16/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18865/22 01/04/2022	Darko STANIĆ 1976	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18939/22 01/04/2022	Rada ĐORĐEVIĆ 1969	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18942/22 01/04/2022	Dragana ANTIĆ 1960	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18968/22 01/04/2022	Vojkan PETROVIĆ 1973	16/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18980/22 01/04/2022	Svetlana JOVANOVIĆ 1966	30/11/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18981/22 01/04/2022	Dragan RADULOVIĆ 1963	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18987/22 01/04/2022	Milan ŠIPKA 1958	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18993/22 01/04/2022	Srbislav ILIĆ 1959	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	18998/22 01/04/2022	Zoran MARINKOVIĆ 1963	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	19000/22 01/04/2022	Borivoje PROVČIN 1965	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	19001/22 01/04/2022	Miodrag SIMIĆ 1966	14/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	19013/22 01/04/2022	Nebojša PEŠIĆ 1966	16/12/2022	13/12/2022	1,000	250
	19014/22 01/04/2022	Stojan TERENTIĆ 1953	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	19916/22 11/04/2022	Dragomir MILADINOVIĆ 1965	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20288/22 11/04/2022	Ioana Mihaela LASKOVIĆ 1978	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20290/22 11/04/2022	Gordana JOVANOVIĆ 1972	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20295/22 11/04/2022	Predrag MILENTIJEVIĆ 1962	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20299/22 11/04/2022	Snežana KOSTIĆ 1978	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20301/22 11/04/2022	Desanka PANTOVIĆ 1959	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20311/22 11/04/2022	Tamara ĐURIĆ 1972	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20318/22 11/04/2022	Slobodan RISTIĆ 1951	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20349/22 11/04/2022	Svetislav VLAJKOVIĆ 1965	16/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20456/22 11/04/2022	Dragan MILOŠEVIĆ 1965	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20460/22 11/04/2022	Olgica SPASIĆ 1976	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20463/22 11/04/2022	Aleksandar IVKOVIĆ 1977	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20468/22 11/04/2022	Dragan GRBIĆ 1976	16/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20502/22 11/04/2022	Biljana RADANOVIĆ 1974	16/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20503/22 11/04/2022	Vera ŠPANOVIĆ 1955	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20554/22 11/04/2022	Bojan PETROVIĆ 1963	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20566/22 11/04/2022	Boban JEREMIĆ 1975	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20595/22 11/04/2022	Slaviša JOVIĆ 1971	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20604/22 11/04/2022	Ljiljana SAVIĆ 1966	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20610/22 11/04/2022	Ivana MARKOVIĆ 1978	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20612/22 11/04/2022	Zoran DRAGIČEVIĆ 1951	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20613/22 11/04/2022	Mirjana CESLICKI 1957	16/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20614/22 11/04/2022	Marina LAZAREVIĆ 1967	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20762/22 11/04/2022	Rade MILOŠEVIĆ 1955	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20774/22 11/04/2022	Dušan BUNDALO 1957	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20782/22 11/04/2022	Danijela KOJIĆ 1978	16/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20801/22 11/04/2022	Branko GRUJIĆ 1953	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20817/22 11/04/2022	Dragan BAJIĆ 1957	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20840/22 11/04/2022	Buda GLIGORIJEVIĆ 1948	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20842/22 11/04/2022	Srećko ILIĆ 1970	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20843/22 11/04/2022	Predrag SUPUROVIĆ 1954	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20844/22 11/04/2022	Ružica JOVANOVIĆ 1961	16/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	20845/22 11/04/2022	Branko SIMIĆ 1966	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	21029/22 11/04/2022	Ljubica RIBIĆ 1960	16/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	21031/22 11/04/2022	Nataša STEVANOVIĆ 1990	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	21285/22 11/04/2022	Milorad LAZIČIĆ 1959	14/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	22929/22 29/04/2022	Sava ILIĆ 1958	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23158/22 29/04/2022	Miloš ANTIĆ 1987	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23159/22 29/04/2022	Dejan MARKOVIĆ 1971	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23160/22 29/04/2022	Radomir LJUBENOVIĆ 1967	20/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	23161/22 29/04/2022	Predrag ARSIĆ 1966	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23162/22 29/04/2022	Jovica LAZIĆ 1965	20/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	23164/22 29/04/2022	Olga JOSIMOVIĆ 1955	20/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	23165/22 29/04/2022	Branimir MILOSAVLJEVIĆ 1960	20/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	23167/22 29/04/2022	Dragan SAMARDŽIJA 1966	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23430/22 29/04/2022	Predrag ANTIĆ 1960	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23434/22 29/04/2022	Mladen MILENKOVIĆ 1976	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23437/22 29/04/2022	Radica JANKOVIĆ 1967	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23441/22 29/04/2022	Srđan DOBRIĆ 1971	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23445/22 29/04/2022	Dragan LUPŠIĆ 1970	20/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	23476/22 29/04/2022	Miloslav DOBRILOVIĆ 1954	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23497/22 29/04/2022	Nadežda MARKOVIĆ 1951	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23502/22 29/04/2022	Vladislav ROGOŽARSKI 1956	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23506/22 29/04/2022	Desimir STOJANOVIĆ 1960	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23509/22 29/04/2022	Adnan IBRAHIMI 1980	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23510/22 29/04/2022	Nikola IVKOVIĆ 1991	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23514/22 29/04/2022	Biljana ĐORĐEVIĆ 1959	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23516/22 29/04/2022	Vesna BOŽIĆ 1962	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23594/22 29/04/2022	Živko MILOŠEVIĆ 1966	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23631/22 29/04/2022	Zoran RISTIĆ 1965	20/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	23634/22 29/04/2022	Ivan ILIĆ 1985	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23636/22 29/04/2022	Predrag JAŠOVIĆ 1956	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23637/22 29/04/2022	Tomislav VASIĆ 1961	20/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	23641/22 29/04/2022	Šerife VESELI 1964	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23723/22 29/04/2022	Ana VASIĆ 1975	20/12/2022	13/01/2023	1,000	250
	23730/22 29/04/2022	Goran MILETIĆ 1970	20/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	23735/22 29/04/2022	Marina MILENKOVIĆ 1982	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23737/22 29/04/2022	Živorad PANTIĆ 1957	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	23740/22 29/04/2022	Sanja STOJANOVIĆ 1972	20/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29375/22 07/06/2022	Goran JANOJLIĆ 1974	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29377/22 07/06/2022	Milica MITIĆ 1969	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29378/22 07/06/2022	Bojan BANKOVIĆ 1983	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29380/22 07/06/2022	Goran BARJAKTAREVIĆ 1979	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29391/22 07/06/2022	Radojka KOSTIĆ 1983	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29393/22 07/06/2022	Dejan DOBRIĆ 1976	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29399/22 07/06/2022	Bojan TREBOVIĆ 1973	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29401/22 07/06/2022	Miloš VUKELIĆ 1970	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29624/22 07/06/2022	Bojan PAUNOVIĆ 1979	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29625/22 07/06/2022	Danijel MIKIĆ 1983	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29628/22 07/06/2022	Goran ŽIVKOVIĆ 1967	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29632/22 07/06/2022	Sava PANIĆ 1954	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29633/22 07/06/2022	Radomir ANTIĆ 1954	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29637/22 07/06/2022	Mirjana BIRTAŠEVIĆ 1961	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29640/22 07/06/2022	Goran MEGIĆ 1973	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29648/22 07/06/2022	Ljubomir RAJČIĆ 1953	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29651/22 07/06/2022	Ljubiša STAMENKOVIĆ 1972	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29654/22 07/06/2022	Vidosav STOŠIĆ 1959	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29658/22 07/06/2022	Stojan DONČEV 1987	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29660/22 07/06/2022	Blagoje JOVANOVIĆ 1960	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29661/22 07/06/2022	Dejan PETROVIĆ 1968	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29665/22 07/06/2022	Vinka MILEVIĆ 1972	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29678/22 07/06/2022	Nenad MARKOVIĆ 1976	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29684/22 07/06/2022	Milenka KORČOK 1975	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29929/22 07/06/2022	Snežana ALEKSIĆ ŽIKIĆ 1956	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29937/22 07/06/2022	Snežana GOLUBOVIĆ 1958	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250
	29966/22 07/06/2022	Dušan DAJIĆ 1960	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30097/22 07/06/2022	Dejan JOSIĆ 1980	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30102/22 07/06/2022	Srećko SIMIĆ 1956	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30105/22 07/06/2022	Dragana LUKIĆ 1959	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30113/22 07/06/2022	Saša RUŽIĆ 1976	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30117/22 07/06/2022	Dragan MITROVIĆ 1975	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30130/22 07/06/2022	Goran ĆIRKOVIĆ 1966	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30205/22 07/06/2022	Verica PAVLOVIĆ 1952	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30207/22 07/06/2022	Milijana DENKIĆ 1962	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30210/22 07/06/2022	Negovan FILIPOVIĆ 1963	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30213/22 07/06/2022	Randel BAKIĆ 1965	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30237/22 07/06/2022	Saša PANTIĆ 1969	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30243/22 07/06/2022	Radiša MILENKOVIĆ 1960	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30244/22 07/06/2022	Bojan SAVIĆ 1979	22/12/2022	16/01/2023	1,000	250
	30247/22 07/06/2022	Goran STAVRIĆ 1963	22/12/2022	14/12/2022	1,000	250

[1] Plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants.

[2] Less any amounts which may have already been paid in that regard at the domestic level.

[3] Plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants.