Přehled
Rozhodnutí
FIFTH SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 43733/08
Dzerassa Feliksovna TSKHOVREBOVA against Georgia
and 369 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Fifth Section), sitting on 3 March 2022 as a Committee composed of:
Stéphanie Mourou-Vikström, President,
Lətif Hüseynov,
Kateřina Šimáčková, judges,
and Martina Keller, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the applications against Georgia lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) on the dates and by the individuals, who are all Russian nationals, listed in the appended table;
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE
1. The applications listed in the appendix concern an international armed conflict (“the IAC”) that occurred between Georgia and the Russian Federation in August 2008, the chronology of which was described in the Court’s judgment in the inter-State case of Georgia v. Russia (II) ([GC] (merits), no. 38263/08, §§ 32-44, 21 January 2021). Relying on Articles 2, 3, 5, 8, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, the applicants complained that the military actions undertaken by the Georgian armed forces in South Ossetia[1] in the period ranging from the night of 7 to 8 August until and including 12 August 2008, that is during the active phase of the IAC, had put their lives, as well as those of their family members, under real and immediate danger, obliged them to spend several days in anxiety and fear, restricted their physical liberty and damaged their properties.
THE COURT’S ASSESSMENT
2. Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.
3. The Court recalls that the legal issues raised under the Convention in the context of the above-mentioned IAC were comprehensively examined by the Court in the inter-State case of Georgia v. Russia (II) (cited above) as well as in the two leading individual applications of Bekoyeva and Others v. Georgia ((dec.), no. 43733/08, §§ 32-40, 5 October 2021) and Shavlokhova and Others v. Georgia ((dec.), no. 45431/08, §§ 27-35). In particular, as the Court ruled in the latter individual cases, the events that unfolded in South Ossetia and other areas of Georgia, where the massive fighting between the armed forces of the Russian Federation and the respondent State took place during the active phase of the IAC, were “acts of war”, in a context of chaos and confusion, effectively preventing Georgia from exercising its authority over the areas in question for the duration of the active phase of the hostilities. Since the inability to exercise State authority was only a temporal limitation of the normal exercise of the respondent State’s territorial jurisdiction over its war‑stricken territories, Georgia was, as a matter of principle, expected under the Convention to take diplomatic, economic, judicial or other positive measures. However, given the ongoing massive armed conflict, positive measures of a public order nature were, on the one hand, impossible to implement and, on the other, of no real value, as they could not have meaningfully contributed to the protection of the applicants’ rights in times of war. Consequently, the respondent State’s responsibility could not be engaged for the acts that took place in South Ossetia during the active phase of the relevant hostilities (see Bekoyeva and Others, §§ 36-39 and Shavlokhova and Others, §§ 31-34, both decisions cited above).
4. After a careful examination of all the applications listed in the appendix, the Court notes that they are identical to the above-mentioned leading cases of Bekoyeva and Others and Shavlokhova and Others, and that there are no reasons to depart from its previous findings on the matter. It follows that these applications, which stem from the “acts of war” that took place on the territory of Georgia during the active phase of the IAC, must be declared inadmissible in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Done in English and notified in writing on 24 March 2022.
Martina Keller Stéphanie Mourou-Vikström
Deputy Registrar President
Appendix
No. | Application no. | Case name | Lodged on | Applicant |
1. | 43733/08 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Dzerassa TSKHOVREBOVA |
2. | 43734/08 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Elmira TSKHOVREBOVA |
3. | 44377/08 | Alborova v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Olga ALBOROVA |
4. | 44382/08 | Khosroyeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Fatima KHOSROYEVA |
5. | 44383/08 | Koroyeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Izolda KOROYEVA |
6. | 45423/08 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Luiza TSKHOVREBOVA |
7. | 45427/08 | Khubulova v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Fatima KHUBULOVA |
8. | 45433/08 | Tokmayeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Rada TOKMAYEVA |
9. | 45440/08 | Gobozova v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Tina GOBOZOVA |
10. | 45442/08 | Kokoyeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Violetta KOKOYEVA |
11. | 45443/08 | Tasoyeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Inga TASOYEVA |
12. | 45444/08 | Gigolayeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Zalina GIGOLAYEVA |
13. | 45448/08 | Sanakoyeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Alena SANAKOYEVA |
14. | 46282/08 | Khabalova v. Georgia | 01/09/2008 | Ms Ella KHABALOVA |
15. | 46284/08 | Dzhioyeva v. Georgia | 01/09/2008 | Ms Madina DZHIOYEVA |
16. | 46287/08 | Tadtayeva v. Georgia | 01/09/2008 | Ms Leyla TADTAYEVA |
17. | 46288/08 | Bekoyeva v. Georgia | 01/09/2008 | Ms Zarina BEKOYEVA |
18. | 46296/08 | Gagiyeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Polina GAGIYEVA |
19. | 46298/08 | Bikoyeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Tamara BIKOYEVA |
20. | 46300/08 | Tokmayeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Elvira TOKMAYEVA |
21. | 46636/08 | Gergaulova v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Tsiala GERGAULOVA |
22. | 46640/08 | Khabalova v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Emma KHABALOVA |
23. | 46642/08 | Kachmazov v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Suliko KACHMAZOV |
24. | 46646/08 | Dzhagayeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Svetlana DZHAGAYEVA |
25. | 46648/08 | Kumaritova v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Eteri KUMARITOVA |
26. | 46650/08 | Khudzhiyeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Venera KHUDZHIYEVA |
27. | 46651/08 | Bestayeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Ira BESTAYEVA |
28. | 46653/08 | Gazayeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Fatima GAZAYEVA |
29. | 46654/08 | Pukhayeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Kseniya PUKHAYEVA |
30. | 46655/08 | Gagiyeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Roza GAGIYEVA |
31. | 48372/08 | Dzhioyeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Larisa DZHIOYEVA |
32. | 50652/08 | Kokayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Rusudan KOKAYEVA |
33. | 50653/08 | Doguzova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Nina DOGUZOVA |
34. | 50660/08 | Tasoyeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Svetlana TASOYEVA |
35. | 50662/08 | Taniya v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Dzhulyetta TANIYA |
36. | 50671/08 | Bolotayev v. Georgia | 01/09/2008 | Mr Dmitriy BOLOTAYEV |
37. | 50679/08 | Kulumbegov v. Georgia | 01/09/2008 | Mr Fedor KULUMBEGOV |
38. | 50681/08 | Tadtayeva v. Georgia | 01/09/2008 | Ms Emma TADTAYEVA |
39. | 50683/08 | Doguzova v. Georgia | 01/09/2008 | Ms Zema DOGUZOVA |
40. | 50711/08 | Kasradze v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Mr Georgiy KASRADZE |
41. | 50721/08 | Kochiyeva v. Georgia | 08/09/2008 | Ms Tsiala KOCHIYEVA |
42. | 52173/08 | Byazrova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Klavdiya BYAZROVA |
43. | 52174/08 | Gagloyeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Sonya GAGLOYEVA |
44. | 52175/08 | Smelova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Yekaterina SMELOVA |
45. | 52180/08 | Dzagoyeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Dzhulyetta DZAGOYEVA |
46. | 52184/08 | Muzayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Zaminet MUZAYEVA |
47. | 52186/08 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Khadizat TEDEYEVA |
48. | 52189/08 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Alena TSKHOVREBOVA |
49. | 52258/08 | Pliyeva v. Georgia | 08/09/2008 | Ms Lolita PLIYEVA |
50. | 52264/08 | Bestayev v. Georgia | 08/09/2008 | Mr Kavkaz BESTAYEV |
51. | 53473/08 | Kulumbegova v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Zarina KULUMBEGOVA |
52. | 53510/08 | Valiyeva v. Georgia | 08/09/2008 | Ms Alena VALIYEVA |
53. | 53513/08 | Dochiyeva v. Georgia | 08/09/2008 | Ms Dzhulyeta DOCHIYEVA |
54. | 53855/08 | Kokoyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Alla KOKOYEVA |
55. | 53857/08 | Bestayev v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Mr Kazimir BESTAYEV |
56. | 53861/08 | Bestayeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Alla BESTAYEVA |
57. | 53869/08 | Bestayev v. Georgia | 08/09/2008 | Mr Vasiliy BESTAYEV |
58. | 53898/08 | Kokoyev v. Georgia | 08/09/2008 | Mr Aleksey KOKOYEV |
59. | 53906/08 | Dzhioyev v. Georgia | 08/09/2008 | Mr Igor DZHIOYEV |
60. | 53910/08 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Fatima TEDEYEVA |
61. | 55263/08 | Gabarayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Dzhulyetta GABARAYEVA |
62. | 55279/08 | Bitiyeva v. Georgia | 01/09/2008 | Ms Yuza BITIYEVA |
63. | 55282/08 | Arsoyeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Alla ARSOYEVA |
64. | 55283/08 | Khubayev v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Mr Vasiliy KHUBAYEV |
65. | 55287/08 | Servetnik v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Valeriya SERVETNIK |
66. | 55289/08 | Bitsoyeva v. Georgia | 02/09/2008 | Ms Maka BITSOYEVA |
67. | 56953/08 | Bosikova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Kristina BOSIKOVA |
68. | 56956/08 | Tomayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Nona TOMAYEVA |
69. | 56963/08 | Dzhioyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Svetlana DZHIOYEVA |
70. | 57195/08 | Kharebova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Aza KHAREBOVA |
71. | 57211/08 | Alborova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Yelena ALBOROVA |
72. | 57247/08 | Alborov v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Mr Albert ALBOROV |
73. | 57260/08 | Bestayeva v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Ms Natalya BESTAYEVA |
74. | 58632/08 | Dzhagayeva v. Georgia | 17/09/2008 | Ms Aleksandra DZHAGAYEVA |
75. | 58635/08 | Dzagoyeva v. Georgia | 17/09/2008 | Ms Yuzya DZAGOYEVA |
76. | 58643/08 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 17/09/2008 | Ms Larisa TSKHOVREBOVA |
77. | 58645/08 | Pliyeva v. Georgia | 17/09/2008 | Ms Yelena PLIYEVA |
78. | 59655/08 | Dyakonova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Fatima DYAKONOVA |
79. | 59661/08 | Dzhigkayeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Eleonora DZHIGKAYEVA |
80. | 59684/08 | Khachirova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Zhenya KHACHIROVA |
81. | 90/09 | Dzhabiyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Marina DZHABIYEVA |
82. | 93/09 | Tasoyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Diana TASOYEVA |
83. | 94/09 | Kotayeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Svetlana KOTAYEVA |
84. | 97/09 | Kabanova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Zalina KABANOVA |
85. | 107/09 | Bosikova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Fatima BOSIKOVA |
86. | 117/09 | Loloyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Manana LOLOYEVA |
87. | 119/09 | Gagiyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Zareta GAGIYEVA |
88. | 120/09 | Dochiyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Asiat DOCHIYEVA |
89. | 121/09 | Khabalov v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Mr Vladimir KHABALOV |
90. | 123/09 | Chekhoyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Lidiya CHEKHOYEVA |
91. | 125/09 | Galavanova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Alma GALAVANOVA |
92. | 126/09 | Dzhabiyev v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Mr Khasan DZHABIYEV |
93. | 132/09 | Valiyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Izolda VALIYEVA |
94. | 135/09 | Kudukhova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Alla KUDUKHOVA |
95. | 139/09 | Khubulova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Inga KHUBULOVA |
96. | 148/09 | Gigolayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Larisa GIGOLAYEVA |
97. | 149/09 | Guchmazova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Svetlana GUCHMAZOVA |
98. | 152/09 | Dzhagayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Lyudmila DZHAGAYEVA |
99. | 154/09 | Kelekhsayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Rimma KELEKHSAYEVA |
100. | 160/09 | Tandelova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Rita TANDELOVA |
101. | 162/09 | Chibirova v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Svetlana CHIBIROVA |
102. | 163/09 | Pliyeva v. Georgia | 17/09/2008 | Ms Mayya PLIYEVA |
103. | 165/09 | Sanakoyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Marina SANAKOYEVA |
104. | 173/09 | Bestayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Laura BESTAYEVA |
105. | 183/09 | Gagloyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Revmira GAGLOYEVA |
106. | 186/09 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Lena TSKHOVREBOVA |
107. | 2177/09 | Tadtayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Roza TADTAYEVA |
108. | 2189/09 | Sinelnikov v. Georgia | 18/09/2008 | Mr Aleksandr SINELNIKOV |
109. | 2196/09 | Namshuradze v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Genriyetta NAMSHURADZE |
110. | 2199/09 | Kachmazova v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Luiza KACHMAZOVA |
111. | 2202/09 | Gatikoyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Madina GATIKOYEVA |
112. | 2206/09 | Bestauty v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Shushana BESTAUTY |
113. | 2208/09 | Doguzova v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Giuli DOGUZOVA |
114. | 2211/09 | Dzhigkayeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Zemulya DZHIGKAYEVA |
115. | 2215/09 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Lyuba TSKHOVREBOVA |
116. | 2219/09 | Khugayeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Zhenya KHUGAYEVA |
117. | 2229/09 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Violetta TEDEYEVA |
118. | 2231/09 | Kusrayeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Galina KUSRAYEVA |
119. | 2234/09 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Galina TSKHOVREBOVA |
120. | 2237/09 | Israelyan v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Mr Valiko ISRAELYAN |
121. | 2239/09 | Avakyan v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Mr Frunzik AVAKYAN |
122. | 2240/09 | Kudukhova v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Nino KUDUKHOVA |
123. | 2242/09 | Tuayev v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Mr Georgi TUAYEV |
124. | 2248/09 | Muldarova v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Dzerassa MULDAROVA |
125. | 2250/09 | Kozayeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Arina KOZAYEVA |
126. | 2252/09 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Zamira TEDEYEVA |
127. | 2254/09 | Tigiyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Aza TIGIYEVA |
128. | 2255/09 | Valiyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Yelizaveta VALIYEVA |
129. | 2263/09 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Ms Alena TEDEYEVA |
130. | 2264/09 | Alborova v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Ms Irma ALBOROVA |
131. | 2268/09 | Oganov v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Mr Leri OGANOV |
132. | 2270/09 | Gutsayeva v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Ms Nelli GUTSAYEVA |
133. | 2271/09 | Kachmazova v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Ms Dzhulyetta KACHMAZOVA |
134. | 2274/09 | Ostayeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Fatima OSTAYEVA |
135. | 2276/09 | Kochiyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Zaira KOCHIYEVA |
136. | 5293/09 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Ms Lali TEDEYEVA |
137. | 5294/09 | Tadtayeva v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Ms Svetlana TADTAYEVA |
138. | 5302/09 | Dochiyeva v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Ms Zalina DOCHIYEVA |
139. | 5313/09 | Tokmayeva v. Georgia | 08/09/2008 | Ms Rita TOKMAYEVA |
140. | 5314/09 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Zaira TEDEYEVA |
141. | 5325/09 | Gabaraty v. Georgia | 08/09/2008 | Mr Kadzakh GABARATY |
142. | 5329/09 | Kochiyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Liana KOCHIYEVA |
143. | 5331/09 | Gigolayev v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Mr Georgiy GIGOLAYEV |
144. | 5335/09 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Marina TSKHOVREBOVA |
145. | 5341/09 | Totoyeva v. Georgia | 05/09/2008 | Ms Bella TOTOYEVA |
146. | 5344/09 | Kochiyeva v. Georgia | 05/09/2008 | Ms Madina KOCHIYEVA |
147. | 5349/09 | Dzhioyeva v. Georgia | 05/09/2008 | Ms Ira DZHIOYEVA |
148. | 5351/09 | Tuayeva v. Georgia | 05/09/2008 | Ms Inga TUAYEVA |
149. | 5354/09 | Galavanova v. Georgia | 05/09/2008 | Ms Fatima GALAVANOVA |
150. | 5356/09 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 05/09/2008 | Ms Lena TSKHOVREBOVA |
151. | 5360/09 | Bekoyeva v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Ms Yuza BEKOYEVA |
152. | 5363/09 | Satkoyeva v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Ms Yelina SATKOYEVA |
153. | 5364/09 | Tedeyev v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Mr Yuriy TEDEYEV |
154. | 5365/09 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Ms Oksana TEDEYEVA |
155. | 5370/09 | Gigolayeva v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Ms Nelli GIGOLAYEVA |
156. | 5375/09 | Kokoyeva v. Georgia | 15/09/2008 | Ms Aza KOKOYEVA |
157. | 5379/09 | Vaneyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Ilona VANEYEVA |
158. | 5380/09 | Byazrova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Alla BYAZROVA |
159. | 5381/09 | Kokoyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Lyuda KOKOYEVA |
160. | 5382/09 | Vaneyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Rita VANEYEVA |
161. | 5385/09 | Parastayeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Manana PARASTAYEVA |
162. | 5387/09 | Dzhussoyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Dzerassa DZHUSSOYEVA |
163. | 6930/09 | Khugayeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Zarina KHUGAYEVA |
164. | 6937/09 | Galavanova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Aza GALAVANOVA |
165. | 6963/09 | Bolatayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Mariya BOLATAYEVA |
166. | 6964/09 | Bolatayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Fatima BOLATAYEVA |
167. | 6968/09 | Bolatayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Fedosiya BOLATAYEVA |
168. | 6984/09 | Kochiyeva v. Georgia | 06/09/2008 | Ms Fatima KOCHIYEVA |
169. | 6986/09 | Tibilov v. Georgia | 06/09/2008 | Mr Vyacheslav TIBILOV |
170. | 6988/09 | Valiyeva v. Georgia | 06/09/2008 | Ms Zoya VALIYEVA |
171. | 6989/09 | Valiyeva v. Georgia | 06/09/2008 | Ms Tina VALIYEVA |
172. | 6991/09 | Tasoyev v. Georgia | 06/09/2008 | Mr Ibragim TASOYEV |
173. | 6994/09 | Doguzova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Dali DOGUZOVA |
174. | 7001/09 | Doguzov v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Mr Vadim DOGUZOV |
175. | 7002/09 | Margiyeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Marina MARGIYEVA |
176. | 7008/09 | Dudayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Madina DUDAYEVA |
177. | 7009/09 | Dudayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Luiza DUDAYEVA |
178. | 7014/09 | Smelov v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Mr Ivan SMELOV |
179. | 7015/09 | Dzebisashvili v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Khatuna DZEBISASHVILI |
180. | 7016/09 | Smelova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Ella SMELOVA |
181. | 7020/09 | Dzhioyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Zaida DZHIOYEVA |
182. | 7024/09 | Kelekhsayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Dina KELEKHSAYEVA |
183. | 8295/09 | Gubiyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Felina GUBIYEVA |
184. | 8296/09 | Siukayev v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Mr Soslan SIUKAYEV |
185. | 8303/09 | Kumaritova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Anzhela KUMARITOVA |
186. | 8313/09 | Tokmayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Nelli TOKMAYEVA |
187. | 8319/09 | Laliyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Albina LALIYEVA |
188. | 8333/09 | Dzhioyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Liana DZHIOYEVA |
189. | 8334/09 | Sanakoyev v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Mr Guliyermo SANAKOYEV |
190. | 8335/09 | Dzhabiyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Vera DZHABIYEVA |
191. | 8342/09 | Mamiyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Larisa MAMIYEVA |
192. | 8343/09 | Vasina v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Olga VASINA |
193. | 8345/09 | Bestayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Marina BESTAYEVA |
194. | 8348/09 | Lapachi v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Nona LAPACHI |
195. | 8349/09 | Kotayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Irina KOTAYEVA |
196. | 8362/09 | Kabisova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Roksana KABISOVA |
197. | 11344/09 | Kotayeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Mariya KOTAYEVA |
198. | 11345/09 | Kotayeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Anna KOTAYEVA |
199. | 11348/09 | Ichkiti v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Mr Shalva ICHKITI |
200. | 11349/09 | Bekoyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Rita BEKOYEVA |
201. | 11357/09 | Zasseyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Irina ZASSEYEVA |
202. | 11358/09 | Tadtayeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Elvira TADTAYEVA |
203. | 11360/09 | Gabarayeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Lyudmila GABARAYEVA |
204. | 11361/09 | Dzhioyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Irina DZHIOYEVA |
205. | 11363/09 | Dzhidchoyeva v. Georgia | 09/09/2008 | Ms Polina DZHIDCHOYEVA |
206. | 11371/09 | Gabuyeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Medeya GABUYEVA |
207. | 11376/09 | Gazzayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Madina GAZZAYEVA |
208. | 11377/09 | Galavanova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Tamara GALAVANOVA |
209. | 11378/09 | Gigolayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Madina GIGOLAYEVA |
210. | 11392/09 | Gabarayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Roza GABARAYEVA |
211. | 11396/09 | Dzhagayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Aina DZHAGAYEVA |
212. | 11397/09 | Dzhagayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Tasya DZHAGAYEVA |
213. | 11411/09 | Dzukayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Inga DZUKAYEVA |
214. | 11413/09 | Pukhayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Marusya PUKHAYEVA |
215. | 11420/09 | Kozayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Dinara KOZAYEVA |
216. | 11423/09 | Kokoyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Albina KOKOYEVA |
217. | 11428/09 | Pukhayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Zarina PUKHAYEVA |
218. | 12318/09 | Bagayev v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Mr Valeriy BAGAYEV |
219. | 12326/09 | Beteyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Valentina BETEYEVA |
220. | 12332/09 | Bagiyayev v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Mr Anatoliy BAGIYAYEV |
221. | 12350/09 | Orlova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Lyudmila ORLOVA |
222. | 12352/09 | Tekhova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Natela TEKHOVA |
223. | 12361/09 | Tekhova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Zhanna TEKHOVA |
224. | 12373/09 | Kochiyeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Izolda KOCHIYEVA |
225. | 12374/09 | Kochiyeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Marina KOCHIYEVA |
226. | 12384/09 | Dudayeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Valya DUDAYEVA |
227. | 12388/09 | Kozayeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Evelina KOZAYEVA |
228. | 12390/09 | Kudukhova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Zalina KUDUKHOVA |
229. | 12393/09 | Loloyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Rita LOLOYEVA |
230. | 12394/09 | Dzhioyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Sofiya DZHIOYEVA |
231. | 12398/09 | Dzhioyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Anzhela DZHIOYEVA |
232. | 12400/09 | Valiyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Zaira VALIYEVA |
233. | 12401/09 | Bekoshvili v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Eteri BEKOSHVILI |
234. | 13471/09 | Dzhioyev v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Mr Vadim DZHIOYEV |
235. | 13486/09 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Gulnara TSKHOVREBOVA |
236. | 13489/09 | Tabatadze v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Daredzhan TABATADZE |
237. | 13491/09 | Tekhova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Olga TEKHOVA |
238. | 13499/09 | Kudukhova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Larisa KUDUKHOVA |
239. | 13505/09 | Bestayeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Anzhela BESTAYEVA |
240. | 13521/09 | Gagloyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Yeva GAGLOYEVA |
241. | 13527/09 | Gagloyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Viktoriya GAGLOYEVA |
242. | 13531/09 | Kabisova v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Zalina KABISOVA |
243. | 13540/09 | Beruashvili v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Fatima BERUASHVILI |
244. | 13541/09 | Khetaturova v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Irina KHETATUROVA |
245. | 13548/09 | Parastayeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Yermoniya PARASTAYEVA |
246. | 13549/09 | Koliyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Varya KOLIYEVA |
247. | 13550/09 | Vaneyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Luiza VANEYEVA |
248. | 15200/09 | Pliyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Lyudmila PLIYEVA |
249. | 15203/09 | Makiyev v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Mr Sardion MAKIYEV |
250. | 15206/09 | Khugayeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Salimat KHUGAYEVA |
251. | 15220/09 | Chekhoyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Aza CHEKHOYEVA |
252. | 15226/09 | Tekhova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Zhanna TEKHOVA |
253. | 15228/09 | Ikoyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Indira IKOYEVA |
254. | 15230/09 | Kisiyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Dinara KISIYEVA |
255. | 15233/09 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Alla TEDEYEVA |
256. | 15240/09 | Alborova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Galina ALBOROVA |
257. | 15250/09 | Kasabiyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Lyudmila KASABIYEVA |
258. | 15252/09 | Valiyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Natela VALIYEVA |
259. | 15256/09 | Laliyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Lali LALIYEVA |
260. | 15257/09 | Guchmazova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Radmila GUCHMAZOVA |
261. | 15265/09 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Zamira TEDEYEVA |
262. | 15267/09 | Valiyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Maya VALIYEVA |
263. | 15268/09 | Mamedov v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Mr Adyl MAMEDOV |
264. | 15269/09 | Dzhioyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Ilona DZHIOYEVA |
265. | 15270/09 | Kobesova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Valentina KOBESOVA |
266. | 15271/09 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Arina TEDEYEVA |
267. | 15274/09 | Gubiyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Marina GUBIYEVA |
268. | 15275/09 | Valiyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Madina VALIYEVA |
269. | 15277/09 | Chekhoyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Zalina CHEKHOYEVA |
270. | 15289/09 | Gagloyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Yana GAGLOYEVA |
271. | 17594/09 | Tibilova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Elvira TIBILOVA |
272. | 17609/09 | Baratova v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Irina BARATOVA |
273. | 17613/09 | Bagayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Zoya BAGAYEVA |
274. | 17625/09 | Kokoyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Zalina KOKOYEVA |
275. | 17629/09 | Dzhioyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Madina DZHIOYEVA |
276. | 17641/09 | Gobozova v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Tamila GOBOZOVA |
277. | 17649/09 | Gagloyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Bella GAGLOYEVA |
278. | 17655/09 | Kozayeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Lyuba KOZAYEVA |
279. | 17657/09 | Bolatayeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Nusha BOLATAYEVA |
280. | 17658/09 | Gigolayeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Alda GIGOLAYEVA |
281. | 17659/09 | Mamiyeva v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Alesya MAMIYEVA |
282. | 17660/09 | Dzudtsova v. Georgia | 13/09/2008 | Ms Galina DZUDTSOVA |
283. | 20470/09 | Sanakoyeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Liana SANAKOYEVA |
284. | 20477/09 | Tasoyev v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Mr Georgiy TASOYEV |
285. | 20479/09 | Gabarayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Elvira GABARAYEVA |
286. | 20480/09 | Bigulayeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Tamara BIGULAYEVA |
287. | 20481/09 | Asayev v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Mr Ivan ASAYEV |
288. | 20486/09 | Valiyeva v. Georgia | 11/09/2008 | Ms Angelina VALIYEVA |
289. | 20515/09 | Guchmazova v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Zhenya GUCHMAZOVA |
290. | 20518/09 | Tasoyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Margo TASOYEVA |
291. | 20519/09 | Gergaulova v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Klavdiya GERGAULOVA |
292. | 20544/09 | Kochiyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Manya KOCHIYEVA |
293. | 20546/09 | Bazzayeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Aksana BAZZAYEVA |
294. | 20552/09 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Madina TSKHOVREBOVA |
295. | 22463/09 | Guchmazova v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Yelizaveta GUCHMAZOVA |
296. | 24877/09 | Petrakov v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Viktor PETRAKOV |
297. | 24878/09 | Mustafin v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Farid MUSTAFIN |
298. | 24879/09 | Nurgaliyev v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Nail NURGALIYEV |
299. | 24880/09 | Krupchatnikov v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Aleksandr KRUPCHATNIKOV |
300. | 24881/09 | Yunusov v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Rustam YUNUSOV |
301. | 24882/09 | Shents v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Sergey SHENTS |
302. | 24883/09 | Suvorov v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Dmitriy SUVOROV |
303. | 24884/09 | Balkarov v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Akhmed BALKAROV |
304. | 24885/09 | Pavlov v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Nikolay PAVLOV |
305. | 24886/09 | Kelokhsayev v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Atsamaz KELOKHSAYEV |
306. | 24887/09 | Polushkin v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Sergey POLUSHKIN |
307. | 24888/09 | Valiyev v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Robert VALIYEV |
308. | 24889/09 | Valiyeva v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Ms Lyudmila VALIYEVA |
309. | 24890/09 | Pliyev v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Teymuraz PLIYEV |
310. | 24891/09 | Kozayev v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Aleksandr KOZAYEV |
311. | 24892/09 | Kozayev v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Dmitriy KOZAYEV |
312. | 24893/09 | Dzhioyev v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Yuriy DZHIOYEV |
313. | 24896/09 | Korenev v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Aleksey KORENEV |
314. | 24905/09 | Kudukhova v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Kristina KUDUKHOVA |
315. | 24909/09 | Vaneyev v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Mr Andrey VANEYEV |
316. | 24916/09 | Kudziyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Venera KUDZIYEVA |
317. | 24919/09 | Sanakoyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Fatima SANAKOYEVA |
318. | 24928/09 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Khadizat TEDEYEVA |
319. | 24939/09 | Gabarayeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Nelli GABARAYEVA |
320. | 24948/09 | Gabarayev v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Mr Anatoliy GABARAYEV |
321. | 24954/09 | Kulumbegova v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Ms Manya KULUMBEGOVA |
322. | 24957/09 | Tuayeva v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Ms Albina TUAYEVA |
323. | 24958/09 | Gigolayeva v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Ms Mziya GIGOLAYEVA |
324. | 24967/09 | Ostayeva v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Ms Marina OSTAYEVA |
325. | 26502/09 | Mamiyeva v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Ms Inga MAMIYEVA |
326. | 27940/09 | Konyukov v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Aleksandr KONYUKOV |
327. | 27941/09 | Guseynov v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Tinamagomed GUSEYNOV |
328. | 27942/09 | Zhivykh v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Igor ZHIVYKH |
329. | 27943/09 | Gasanov v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Rasul GASANOV |
330. | 31744/09 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Irma TSKHOVREBOVA |
331. | 31745/09 | Tskhovrebova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Lyana TSKHOVREBOVA |
332. | 31749/09 | Mgebrov v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Mr Malkhaz MGEBROV |
333. | 31754/09 | Kumaritova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Aida KUMARITOVA |
334. | 31757/09 | Ostayeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Valentina OSTAYEVA |
335. | 31758/09 | Naniyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Alla NANIYEVA |
336. | 31759/09 | Muldarova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Zareta MULDAROVA |
337. | 31763/09 | Mironov v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Mr Yuriy MIRONOV |
338. | 31769/09 | Gagloyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Lidiya GAGLOYEVA |
339. | 31770/09 | Gabarayeva v. Georgia | 27/12/2008 | Ms Vanda GABARAYEVA |
340. | 31771/09 | Kozayeva v. Georgia | 27/12/2008 | Ms Marusya KOZAYEVA |
341. | 31776/09 | Pliyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Minat PLIYEVA |
342. | 31780/09 | Valiyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Liana VALIYEVA |
343. | 31783/09 | Demeyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Tatyana DEMEYEVA |
344. | 31784/09 | Kulumbekova v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Lyuba KULUMBEKOVA |
345. | 31787/09 | Gobozova v. Georgia | 18/09/2008 | Ms Roza GOBOZOVA |
346. | 31789/09 | Dudayeva v. Georgia | 18/09/2008 | Ms Ulyana DUDAYEVA |
347. | 33083/09 | Kokoyeva v. Georgia | 18/09/2008 | Ms Gulnazi KOKOYEVA |
348. | 33085/09 | Pliyeva v. Georgia | 18/09/2008 | Ms Inga PLIYEVA |
349. | 33086/09 | Yelbakiyev v. Georgia | 18/09/2008 | Mr Vadik YELBAKIYEV |
350. | 33089/09 | Kharebov v. Georgia | 18/09/2008 | Mr Gela KHAREBOV |
351. | 33091/09 | Manasherov v. Georgia | 27/11/2008 | Mr Gertsen MANASHEROV |
352. | 34922/09 | Bibilova v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Tanya BIBILOVA |
353. | 34923/09 | Pliyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Landa PLIYEVA |
354. | 34924/09 | Pliyeva v. Georgia | 12/09/2008 | Ms Aza PLIYEVA |
355. | 34934/09 | Guchmazova v. Georgia | 21/09/2008 | Ms Tatyana GUCHMAZOVA |
356. | 34938/09 | Marchenko v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Ms Marina MARCHENKO |
357. | 34940/09 | Adushkin v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Sergey ADUSHKIN |
358. | 34941/09 | Kononov v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Vitaliy KONONOV |
359. | 34942/09 | Shevelevy v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Yuriy SHEVELEV |
360. | 34944/09 | Bobrov v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Aleksandr BOBROV |
361. | 34946/09 | Kulushev v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Eduard KULUSHEV |
362. | 34950/09 | Tedeyeva v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Ms Aida TEDEYEVA |
363. | 34952/09 | Tekhova v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Ms Evelina TEKHOVA |
364. | 34957/09 | Dzhioyeva v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Ms Diana DZHIOYEVA |
365. | 34958/09 | Kudziyev v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Mr Aleksandr KUDZIYEV |
366. | 34962/09 | Parastayeva v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Ms Yekaterina PARASTAYEVA |
367. | 34963/09 | Anayev v. Georgia | 09/10/2008 | Mr Eduard ANAYEV |
368. | 36100/09 | Kelekhsayeva v. Georgia | 22/09/2008 | Ms Natela KELEKHSAYEVA |
369. | 36107/09 | Arsoyeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Inga ARSOYEVA |
370. | 36109/09 | Tarayeva v. Georgia | 27/09/2008 | Ms Lena TARAYEVA |
[1] The term “South Ossetia” refers to a region of Georgia which is currently outside the de facto control of the Georgian Government.