Přehled
Rozhodnutí
FIRST SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 35139/14
Temur Damyrovych YULDASHEV and Violeta Viktorivna YULDASHEVA against Ukraine and Russia
and 326 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 5 May 2020 as a Committee composed of:
Aleš Pejchal, President,
Tim Eicke,
Jovan Ilievski, judges,
and Renata Degener, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix. They were represented before the Court by Ms N.Y. Tselovalnichenko, a lawyer practising in Kyiv.
The circumstances of the case
- Incidents giving rise to the applications
2. The facts of the cases, as submitted by the applicants, may be summarised as follows.
3. The applicants argued that from the beginning of April 2014 onwards armed separatist groups had started to seize official buildings and territory in the east of Ukraine and announced the creation of two so-called “People’s Republics”; namely the “Donetsk People’s Republic” and the “Lugansk People’s Republic”. In response, on 14 April 2014 the Ukrainian Government had begun what they termed an “anti-terrorist operation”, involving the use of armed military force.
4. Some of the applicants also argued that Crimea had been “occupied” and “annexed” by the Russian Federation in February and March 2014.
5. The incidents which, according to the applicants, had taken place in the course of and subsequent to the developments in the preceding paragraphs and which formed the basis of their applications, can be summarised as follows:
-a number of houses belonging to some of the applicants in Eastern Ukraine had been damaged and, in some cases, completely destroyed during “shelling by pro-Russian militants or by Russian or Ukrainian armed forces”. As a result, some of the applicants had been forced to live in destitute conditions without running water, gas, electricity, heating, food supplies or medication. The constant shelling by heavy weapons had also endangered their lives. Some applicants had had to abandon their villages, towns and cities and fled to other parts of Ukraine. The applicants had also been unable to have access to Ukrainian courts to claim compensation for the damage caused to their properties because the jurisdictions of the courts in the areas in Eastern Ukraine which were not under the control of the Ukrainian Government had been transferred to the relevant courts in the neighbouring regions that were controlled by the Ukrainian Government;
-some applicants and their relatives had been injured during the shelling and some of their relatives had been killed;
-some applicants and their relatives had been arrested and detained unlawfully by members of armed separatist groups who also carried out a number of abductions, robberies, and perpetrated ill-treatment and killings;
-some of the applicants’ pension payments had been stopped by the Ukrainian Government;
-some applicants who lived in areas of Eastern Ukraine which were not controlled by the Ukrainian Government had been unable to vote during the Presidential and Parliamentary elections. They had also been afraid to speak the Ukrainian language and to express pro-Ukrainian views for fear of recriminations from the militants;
-there had existed no effective remedies within the meaning of Article 13 of the Convention for their complaints summarised above. Moreover, since the beginning of April 2014 official buildings in some parts of Eastern Ukraine had been seized and the activities carried out therein suspended and it had therefore been impossible for the applicants to have their Convention rights guaranteed effectively;
-a number of applicants, who are Crimean Tatars, had been forced to flee Crimea;
-some of the applicants who were living in various parts of Ukraine had been unable to freely reside and move through the territory of Crimea; and, finally,
-the applicants in fifty-seven of the applications directed their applications against the United Kingdom and alleged that, as well as the Russian Federation and Ukraine, the United Kingdom had also been responsible for their grievances. In that connection they alleged that the United Kingdom, by signing the Memorandum on security assurances in connection with Ukraine’s accession to the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons in Budapest on 5 December 1994, had become a guarantor of Ukrainian independence and security and had thus become duty-bound to take effective measures against the Russian Federation for “its military intervention in Ukraine”. As the United Kingdom had not taken any such measures, it bore partial responsibility for the above-summarised incidents.
- The Court’s decision to bar Ms N. Tselovalnichenko
6. On 4 December 2018, in its examination of a number of applications in which the applicants – like the applicants in the present applications – were represented by Ms Tselovalnichenko, the Court decided, under Rule 36 § 4 (b) of the Rules of Court, that in view of her fraudulent and abusive behaviour in a number of cases lodged with the Court Ms Tselovalnichenko should be permanently barred from representing or otherwise assisting applicants in both pending and future applications.
7. In order to inform all applicants represented by her, notably those residing in areas that could not be reached by post, the Court issued a press release on 12 December 2018 (ECHR 433 (2018)) and invited the media to inform the public about its decision to bar Ms Tselovalnichenko (see Chepelenko and Others v. Ukraine (dec.), nos. 15117/17, 18635/17, 18655/17, 251/18 and 3633/18, §§ 17-18, 28 January 2020).
- Attempts made to contact the applicants in the present applications
8. According to the information contained in the application forms submitted to the Court by the applicants in the present applications, the vast majority of them were living in the Donetsk and Luhansk regions of Eastern Ukraine at the time of the introduction of their applications. After issuing the above-mentioned press release on 12 December 2018, the Court sent letters to the applicants on 17 December 2018 with a view to notifying them that Ms Tselovalnichenko could no longer act as their representative. The letters also stated that it was open to the applicants to appoint new representatives to replace her at any time. Almost all of those letters were returned to the Court undelivered.
9. On 30 September 2019 a second attempt was made to contact the applicants and letters were sent to them once more. In those letters the applicants were asked to inform the Court by 25 October 2019 whether they wished to maintain their applications and, if so, to provide information about any important factual developments that might have taken place since their last correspondence to the Court. The applicants were warned that failure to reply to the Court’s letter by the above-mentioned deadline could lead the Court to conclude that they were no longer interested in pursuing their applications and to strike them out of its list of cases. Replies were received in a small number of cases only – in some of which the applicants informed the Court that they had appointed new legal representatives – and the Court will continue to examine those cases. The letters sent to the applicants in the present 327 applications were either returned to the Court undelivered or no replies were received from the applicants.
COMPLAINTS
10. In respect of their allegations summarised in paragraph 5 above, the applicants relied on, inter alia, Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1.
THE LAW
11. Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.
12. The Court notes that, at the time of the introduction of their applications, the vast majority of applicants were living in the territories of the Donetsk and Luhansk regions which were outside the control of the Ukrainian Government and in which the Ukrainian postal service Ukrposhta had suspended its operations because of frequent attacks on its vehicles and employees by armed groups (see Chepelenko and Others, cited above, §§ 21 and 23; see also Tsezar and Others v. Ukraine, nos. 73590/14 and 6 others, § 9, 13 February 2018). As detailed above, in addition to issuing the press release on 12 December 2018, the Court also made two attempts to establish direct contact with the applicants by sending them letters, but those attempts were unsuccessful.
13. As the application forms provided by the applicants did not indicate any other contact details ̶ such as alternative postal addresses, e-mails, telephone numbers etc. ̶ the Court was also unable to contact the applicants by such means.
14. Moreover, the Court has not received any correspondence directly from the applicants since the introduction of the applications. It must be stressed in this connection that Rule 47 § 7 of the Rules of Court requires applicants to keep the Court informed of any change of their addresses and of all circumstances relevant to their application. The Court considers that the fluid nature of the situation surrounding the applicants’ cases makes it all the more important for the Court to receive regular information and updates from the applicants.
15. The Court also reiterates that, on account of the independence of the legal profession from the State, the conduct of the legal representation is essentially a matter between the applicants and their lawyer (see Chepelenko and Others, cited above, § 33 and the case cited therein). Therefore, following the Court’s decision to bar the applicants’ representative, it was for that representative to inform her clients of such a pertinent development in their cases.
16. The Court is thus faced with a situation in which it is not being provided with any information by the applicants nor is it in a position to contact them, which makes it impossible for the Court to continue to examine these applications.
17. The Court considers that, in these circumstances, the applicants may be regarded as no longer wishing to pursue their applications, within the meaning of Article 37 § 1 (a) of the Convention. Furthermore, in accordance with Article 37 § 1 in fine, the Court finds no special circumstances regarding respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols which require the continued examination of the case.
18. Finally, the Court reiterates that under Article 37 § 2 of the Convention it may decide to restore an application to its list of cases if it considers that the circumstances justify such a course.
19. In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the cases out of the list.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Decides to strike the application out of its list of cases.
Renata Degener Aleš Pejchal
Deputy Registrar President
Appendix
No. | Application no. | Case name | Lodged on | Applicant Year of Birth Place of Residence Nationality |
1. | 35139/14 | Yuldashev and Yuldasheva v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/05/2014 | Temur Damyrovych YULDASHEV 1969 Lugansk Ukrainian Violeta Viktorivna YULDASHEVA 1976 Lugansk Ukrainian |
2. | 43147/14 | Yefremova and Yefremov v. Russia and Ukraine | 04/06/2014 | Iryna Mykolayivna YEFREMOVA 1984 Oleksandrivsk Ukrainian Illya Ivanovych YEFREMOV 1978 Oleksandrivsk Ukrainian |
3. | 43160/14 | Budyk v. Russia and Ukraine | 04/06/2014 | Natalya Volodymyrivna BUDYK 1974 Gorlivka Georgian Vasyl Volodymyrovych BUDYK 1972 Gorlivka Georgian |
4. | 43225/14 | Demko v. Russia and Ukraine | 04/06/2014 | Oleksiy Petrovych DEMKO 1969 Makiyivka Ukrainian Maryna Viktorivna DEMKO 1969 Makiyivka Ukrainian |
5. | 45295/14 | Tantashova v. Russia and Ukraine | 11/06/2014 | Elvira Suleymanivna TANTASHOVA 1983 Ivano-Frankivsk Ukrainian |
6. | 45336/14 | Kravchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 11/06/2014 | Valeriy Mykolayovych KRAVCHENKO 1970 Ivano-Frankivsk Ukrainian |
7. | 50330/14 | Vasin v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/07/2014 | Yuriy Anatoliyovych VASIN 1967 Lugansk Ukrainian |
8. | 50336/14 | Davlyatshyn v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/07/2014 | Yuriy Mantsufovych DAVLYATSHYN 1965 Lugansk Ukrainian |
9. | 50345/14 | Kichurka v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/07/2014 | Oleg Yosypovych KICHURKA 1965 Steenokkerzeel Ukrainian |
10. | 50352/14 | Reshetnyak v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/07/2014 | Oleksandr Vitaliyovych RESHETNYAK 1964 Veselenke Ukrainian Andriy Oleksandrovych RESHETNYAK 1988 Veselenke Ukrainian Larysa Grygorivna RESHETNYAK 1966 Veselenke Ukrainian |
11. | 51256/14 | Semystyaga v. Russia and Ukraine | 01/07/2014 | Volodymyr Fedorovych SEMYSTYAGA 1949 Lugansk Ukrainian |
12. | 51880/14 | Pargyelyan v. Russia and Ukraine | 07/07/2014 | Artur Vrzhevych PARGYELYAN 1962 Shchastya Ukrainian |
13. | 51895/14 | Malyy and Malaya v. Russia and Ukraine | 07/07/2014 | Oleksandr Oleksandrovych MALYY 1991 Synelnikove Ukrainian Tetyana Volodymyrivna MALAYA 1971 Synelnikove Ukrainian |
14. | 51905/14 | Nazarov and Nazarova v. Russia and Ukraine | 07/07/2014 | Ruslan Sergiyovych NAZAROV 1990 Synelnykove Ukrainian Zukhra Safar-Aliyevna NAZAROVA 1970 Synelnikove Ukrainian |
15. | 51911/14 | Zayika and Reznik v. Russia and Ukraine | 07/07/2014 | Volodymyr Volodymyrovych ZAYIKA 1985 Synelnikove Ukrainian Nina Oleksandrivna REZNIK 1962 Synelnikove Ukrainian |
16. | 51917/14 | Tkachenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 07/07/2014 | Sergiy Viktorovych TKACHENKO 1971 Shchastya Ukrainian |
17. | 52720/14 | Nesterenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/07/2014 | Vasyl Petrovych NESTERENKO 2014 Kramatorsk Ukrainian Iryna Anatoliyivna NESTERENKO 1977 Kramatorsk Ukrainian |
18. | 52725/14 | Grebenichenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/07/2014 | Pavlo Oleksandrovych GREBENICHENKO 1983 Lugansk Ukrainian |
19. | 53482/14 | Tatun v. Russia and Ukraine | 07/07/2014 | Taras Volodymyrovych TATUN 1981 Shchastya Ukrainian |
20. | 54669/14 | Nesterova and Nesterov v. Russia | 26/07/2014 | Svitlana Ivanivna NESTEROVA 1966 Kyiv Ukrainian Andriy Stanislavovych NESTEROV 1963 Kyiv Ukrainian |
21. | 54684/14 | Vasyushchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/07/2014 | Oksana Valeriyivna VASYUSHCHENKO 1976 Yenakiyeve Ukrainian Oleksandr Anatoliyovych VASYUSHCHENKO 1972 Yenakiyeve Ukrainian |
22. | 55591/14 | Medvedyeva and Medvedyev v. Russia and Ukraine | 30/07/2014 | Kateryna Ivanivna MEDVEDYEVA 1952 Boryspil Ukrainian Volodymyr Anatoliyovych MEDVEDYEV 1979 Boryspil Ukrainian |
23. | 55608/14 | Sokolenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 30/07/2014 | Sergiy Viktorovych SOKOLENKO 1983 Kyiv Ukrainian |
24. | 55619/14 | Andrushchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 30/07/2014 | Valentyna Ivanivna ANDRUSHCHENKO 1979 Kagarlyk Ukrainian Oleksandr Oleksiyovych ANDRUSHCHENKO 1981 Kagarlyk Ukrainian |
25. | 55632/14 | Dovnich v. Russia and Ukraine | 30/07/2014 | Kateryna Volodymyrivna DOVNICH 1955 Sytnyaky Ukrainian Oleg Viktorovych DOVNICH 1984 Makariv Ukrainian |
26. | 55648/14 | Novikova and Novikov v. Russia and Ukraine | 30/07/2014 | Lesya Sergiyivna NOVIKOVA 1979 Busheve Ukrainian Ruslan Oleksandrovych NOVIKOV 1974 Olshanytsya Ukrainian |
27. | 57237/14 | Ishchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/08/2014 | Viktoriya Valeriyivna ISHCHENKO 1987 Kyiv Ukrainian Iryna Anatoliyivna ISHCHENKO 1964 Kyiv Ukrainian Valeriy Andriyovych ISHCHENKO 1965 Kyiv Ukrainian |
28. | 58508/14 | Khanin and Khanina v. Russia and Ukraine | 25/08/2014 | Yevgeniy Viktorovich KHANIN 1975 Zimogorye Ukrainian Viktor Nikolayevich KHANIN 1952 Rodakove Ukrainian Olga Ivanovna KHANINA 1953 Rodakove Ukrainian Artem Viktorovich KHANIN 1981 Rodakove Ukrainian |
29. | 58781/14 | Mamay v. Russia and Ukraine | 16/08/2014 | Pavlo Mykhaylovych MAMAY 1960 Donetsk Ukrainian Lev Pavlovych MAMAY 1985 Donetsk Ukrainian |
30. | 58837/14 | Malakhova v. Russia and Ukraine | 16/08/2014 | Olga Petrivna MALAKHOVA 1966 Slovyansk Ukrainian |
31. | 58868/14 | Orel v. Russia and Ukraine | 16/08/2014 | Oleksandr Sergiyovych OREL 1989 Sukha Kamyanka Ukrainian |
32. | 61031/14 | Lyesnov v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/08/2014 | Yuriy Volodymyrovych LYESNOV 1996 Lugansk Ukrainian |
33. | 61037/14 | Mangush v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/08/2014 | Oleksandr Oleksandrovych MANGUSH 1995 Lugansk Ukrainian |
34. | 61040/14 | Samarskyy v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/08/2014 | Sergiy Viktorovych SAMARSKYY 1962 Syevyerodonetsk Ukrainian |
35. | 61048/14 | Kryvenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/08/2014 | Ivan Oleksandrovych KRYVENKO 1957 Odesa Ukrainian |
36. | 61054/14 | Kravtsov v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/08/2014 | Oleg Grygorovych KRAVTSOV 1971 Slovyansk Ukrainian |
37. | 61056/14 | Khomenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/08/2014 | Volodymyr Mykolayovych KHOMENKO 1975 Myrolyubivka Ukrainian |
38. | 64258/14 | Yugosh v. Russia | 20/09/2014 | Kateryna Volodymyrivna YUGOSH 1985 Kyiv Ukrainian |
39. | 64293/14 | Yugosh v. Russia | 20/09/2014 | Ruslan Mykolayovych YUGOSH 1976 Kyiv Ukrainian |
40. | 2875/15 | Bukhonko v. Russia and Ukraine | 29/12/2014 | Denys Oleksandrovych BUKHONKO 1979 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
41. | 2877/15 | Gerasymchuk v. Russia and Ukraine | 29/12/2014 | Ganna Oleksandrivna GERASYMCHUK 1978 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
42. | 4471/15 | Sitnikov v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/12/2014 | Oleg Dmytrovych SITNIKOV 1996 Lugansk Ukrainian |
43. | 4522/15 | Mezentseva v. Russia and Ukraine | 12/01/2015 | Iryna Anatoliyivna MEZENTSEVA 1984 Amvrosiyivka Ukrainian |
44. | 4531/15 | Mezentsev v. Russia and Ukraine | 12/01/2015 | Dmytro Viktorovych MEZENTSEV 1968 Amvrosiyivka Ukrainian |
45. | 4544/15 | Kovalenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 12/01/2015 | Anatoliy Ivanovych KOVALENKO 1952 Amvrosiyivka Ukrainian |
46. | 4962/15 | Kovalenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 12/01/2015 | Zinayida Mykhaylivna KOVALENKO 1954 Amvrosiyivka Ukrainian |
47. | 5221/15 | Kovalyov v. Russia and Ukraine | 01/10/2014 | Oleksandr Volodymyrovych KOVALYOV 1958 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
48. | 5304/15 | Orel v. Russia and Ukraine | 04/01/2015 | Igor Yevgenovych OREL 1961 Stakhanov Ukrainian |
49. | 5363/15 | Lisnyy v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/12/2014 | Vasyl Mykolayovych LISNYY 1954 Yasynuvata Ukrainian |
50. | 5372/15 | Lisna v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/12/2014 | Tetyana Volodymyrivna LISNA 1958 Yasynuvata Ukrainian |
51. | 5466/15 | Kovalyova v. Russia and Ukraine | 12/01/2015 | Lyubov Mytrofanivna KOVALYOVA 1955 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
52. | 5598/15 | Ryabchynska v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/12/2014 | Olena Sergiyivna RYABCHYNSKA 1986 Lugansk Ukrainian |
53. | 5618/15 | Kovalyov v. Russia and Ukraine | 12/01/2015 | Andriy Oleksandrovych KOVALYOV 1986 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
54. | 5619/15 | Mishyn v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/12/2014 | Artem Gennadiyovych MISHYN 1986 Valuyske Ukrainian |
55. | 5632/15 | Prokopenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 04/01/2015 | Kateryna Stanislavivna PROKOPENKO 1975 Lugansk Ukrainian |
56. | 8957/15 | Vakulenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/02/2015 | Viktor Volodymyrovych VAKULENKO 1957 Metalist Ukrainian |
57. | 9055/15 | Motinov v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/02/2015 | Oleksiy Stanislavovych MOTINOV 1989 Krasnyy Luch Ukrainian |
58. | 9057/15 | Vakulenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/02/2015 | Ganna Vasylivna VAKULENKO 1931 Metalist Ukrainian |
59. | 9060/15 | Kravchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/02/2015 | Olga Volodymyrivna KRAVCHENKO 1976 Lugansk Ukrainian |
60. | 9076/15 | Zolotukhina v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/02/2015 | Olena Viktorivna ZOLOTUKHINA 1970 Antratsyt Ukrainian |
61. | 9082/15 | Nosachova v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/02/2015 | Galyna Ivanivna NOSACHOVA 1971 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
62. | 12986/15 | Ratnikov v. Russia and Ukraine | 26/02/2015 | Sergiy Viktorovych RATNIKOV 1955 Syeverodonetsk Ukrainian |
63. | 18165/15 | Sydorenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 30/03/2015 | Ganna Vikrorivna SYDORENKO 1961 Donetsk Ukrainian |
64. | 19479/15 | Ovcharova v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/04/2015 | Galyna Stepanivna OVCHAROVA 1959 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
65. | 19487/15 | Ovcharova v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/04/2015 | Svitlana Vladyslavivna OVCHAROVA 1963 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
66. | 19573/15 | Drogalo v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/04/2015 | Nataliya Oleksandrivna DROGALO 1958 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
67. | 19582/15 | Shevchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/04/2015 | Viktoriya Oleksandrivna SHEVCHENKO 1969 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
68. | 19588/15 | Zenzer v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/04/2015 | Oksana Yuryivna ZENZER 1970 Lugansk Ukrainian |
69. | 19589/15 | Irkliyevska v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/04/2015 | Olga Volodymyrivna IRKLIYEVSKA 1960 Donetsk Ukrainian |
70. | 19597/15 | Zenzer v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/04/2015 | Yuriy Ivanovych ZENZER 1963 Lugansk Ukrainian |
71. | 19601/15 | Stepanenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 06/04/2015 | Yuriy Petrovych STEPANENKO 1969 Donetsk Ukrainian |
72. | 20127/15 | Irkliyevskyy v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/04/2015 | Sergiy Oleksandrovych IRKLIYEVSKYY 1982 Donetsk Ukrainian |
73. | 20151/15 | Shmidt v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/04/2015 | Iryna Oleksandrivna SHMIDT 1968 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
74. | 20165/15 | Rylshchikova v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/04/2015 | Ganna Mykhaylivna RYLSHCHIKOVA 1964 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
75. | 20166/15 | Rylshchikova v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/04/2015 | Olena Mykhaylivna RYLSHCHIKOVA 1964 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
76. | 20167/15 | Buchylina v. Russia and Ukraine | 14/04/2015 | Yuliya Volodymyrivna BUCHYLINA 1976 Lugansk Ukrainian |
77. | 22213/15 | Klymenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/04/2015 | Oleksandr Oleksiyovych KLYMENKO 1972 Lugansk Ukrainian |
78. | 22242/15 | Kornilova v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/04/2015 | Olena Ivanivna KORNILOVA 1927 Lugansk Ukrainian |
79. | 22517/15 | Zinovyeva v. Russia | 23/04/2015 | Zhanna Ivanivna ZINOVYEVA 1975 Kyiv Ukrainian |
80. | 22526/15 | Panova v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/04/2015 | Polyna Mykhaylivna PANOVA 1957 Zolote Ukrainian |
81. | 22531/15 | Yakymov v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/04/2015 | Anatoliy Andriyovych YAKYMOV 1955 Zolote Ukrainian |
82. | 22732/15 | Panova v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/04/2015 | Maryna Mykolayivna PANOVA 1983 Zolote Ukrainian |
83. | 22734/15 | Dobrovolskyy v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/04/2015 | Viktor Vasylyovych DOBROVOLSKYY 1949 Zolote Ukrainian |
84. | 22737/15 | Dobrovolska v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/04/2015 | Svitlana Grygorivna DOBROVOLSKA 1954 Zolote Ukrainian |
85. | 22747/15 | Panov v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/04/2015 | Volodymyr Viktorovych PANOV 1979 Zolote Ukrainian |
86. | 22756/15 | Yakymova v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/04/2015 | Tamara Yukhymivna YAKYMOVA 1957 Zolote Ukrainian |
87. | 22763/15 | Manuylenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/04/2015 | Vitaliy Yegorovych MANUYLENKO 1953 Zolote Ukrainian |
88. | 22776/15 | Manuylenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/04/2015 | Iryna Viktorivna MANUYLENKO 1955 Zolote Ukrainian |
89. | 22783/15 | Mykhaylova v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/04/2015 | Galyna Leonidivna MYKHAYLOVA 1949 Zolote Ukrainian |
90. | 22967/15 | Klimenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/03/2015 | Oleksiy Oleksiyovych KLIMENKO 1937 Lugansk Ukrainian |
91. | 25685/15 | Gubska v. Russia and Ukraine | 04/05/2015 | Tetyana Oleksandrivna GUBSKA 1960 Lugansk Ukrainian |
92. | 25734/15 | Golovina v. Russia and Ukraine | 04/05/2015 | Lidiya Vasylivna GOLOVINA 1930 Slovyansk Ukrainian |
93. | 25737/15 | Spiridonova v. Russia | 04/05/2015 | Svitlana Vladyslavivna SPIRIDONOVA 1960 Donetsk Ukrainian |
94. | 25738/15 | Myronenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 04/05/2015 | Oleksandra Yakovlivna MYRONENKO 1929 Lugansk Ukrainian |
95. | 30951/15 | Bondarenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/06/2015 | Bogdan Vitaliyovych BONDARENKO 1983 Lugansk Ukrainian |
96. | 30954/15 | Ilchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/06/2015 | Kostyantyn Grygoriyovych ILCHENKO 1959 Lugansk Ukrainian |
97. | 30989/15 | Andriyenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Yuriy Petrovych ANDRIYENKO 1958 Lugansk Ukrainian |
98. | 30993/15 | Artemenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Valentyna Oleksandrivna ARTEMENKO 1933 Lugansk Ukrainian |
99. | 31003/15 | Artemenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Volen Mykhaylovych ARTEMENKO 1933 Lugansk Ukrainian |
100. | 31005/15 | Artemenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Tetyana Volenivna ARTEMENKO 1978 Lugansk Ukrainian |
101. | 31008/15 | Borysov v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Gennadiy Volodymyrovych BORYSOV 1959 Lugansk Ukrainian |
102. | 31009/15 | Gulyayev v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Viktor Pavlovych GULYAYEV 1940 Lugansk Ukrainian |
103. | 31011/15 | Gulyayeva v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Olga Viktorivna GULYAYEVA 1973 Lugansk Ukrainian |
104. | 31013/15 | Kurdumanova v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Olena Ivanivna KURDUMANOVA 1972 Lugansk Ukrainian |
105. | 31014/15 | Kurdumanova v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Vira Arkhypivna KURDUMANOVA 1946 Lugansk Ukrainian |
106. | 31020/15 | Stepanenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Yuriy Petrovych STEPANENKO 1969 Donetsk Ukrainian |
107. | 31022/15 | Stepanenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Nataliya Valentynivna STEPANENKO 1976 Donetsk Ukrainian |
108. | 31025/15 | Rylshchikova v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Olena Mykhaylivna RYLSHCHIKOVA 1964 Stanychno-Luganske Ukrainian |
109. | 31028/15 | Irkliyevska v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Olga Volodymyrivna IRKLIYEVSKA 1960 Donetsk Ukrainian |
110. | 31032/15 | Irkliyevskyy v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Segiy Oleksandrovych IRKLIYEVSKYY Donetsk Ukrainian |
111. | 31034/15 | Glushchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Vyacheslav Ivanovych GLUSHCHENKO 1980 Lugansk Ukrainian |
112. | 31037/15 | Yakushenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/06/2015 | Volodymyr Mykhaylovych YAKUSHENKO 1957 Lugansk Ukrainian |
113. | 33161/15 | Nyestyerova v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/07/2015 | Nina Mykolayivna NYESTYEROVA 1955 Lugansk Ukrainian |
114. | 35112/15 | Striletska v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Liliya Gennadiyivna STRILETSKA 1986 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
115. | 35119/15 | Temchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Tetyana Mykolayivna TEMCHENKO 1966 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
116. | 35144/15 | Fyedosova v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Olena Anatoliyivna FYEDOSOVA 1965 Donetsk Ukrainian |
117. | 35151/15 | Balagurak v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Olga Petrivna BALAGURAK 1975 Stakhanov Ukrainian |
118. | 35170/15 | Zaplavska v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Iryna Yevgenivna ZAPLAVSKA 1953 Lugansk Ukrainian |
119. | 35873/15 | Kolesnykov v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/07/2015 | Mykola Oleksiyovych KOLESNYKOV 1960 Rovenky Ukrainian |
120. | 35900/15 | Zaplavskyy v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Sergiy Leonidovych ZAPLAVSKYY 1953 Lugansk Ukrainian |
121. | 35923/15 | Babenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Yuriy Volodymyrovych BABENKO 1957 Lugansk Ukrainian |
122. | 35932/15 | Babenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Volodymyr Yuriyovych BABENKO 1988 Lugansk Ukrainian |
123. | 35939/15 | Danile v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/07/2015 | Tetyana Volodymyrivna DANILE 1952 Krasnodon Ukrainian |
124. | 35944/15 | Shevchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/07/2015 | Andriy Ivanovych SHEVCHENKO 1973 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
125. | 35945/15 | Babenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Larysa Yuliyivna BABENKO 1959 Lugansk Ukrainian |
126. | 35975/15 | Dyusmyenyev v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Oleksiy Ivanovych DYUSMYENYEV 1974 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
127. | 35984/15 | Kulikov v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/07/2015 | Ruslan Oleksiyovych KULIKOV 1978 Lugansk Ukrainian |
128. | 35987/15 | Kamuz v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/07/2015 | Roman Volodymyrovych KAMUZ 1983 Stanytsya-Luganska Ukrainian |
129. | 35989/15 | Pryshchepa v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Nataliya Petrivna PRYSHCHEPA 1960 Lugansk Ukrainian |
130. | 35997/15 | Spiridonova v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Viktoriya Oleksandrivna SPIRIDONOVA 1989 Kyiv Ukrainian |
131. | 36000/15 | Kamuz v. Russia and Ukraine | 03/07/2015 | Oleksandra Oleksandrivna KAMUZ 1982 Stanytsya-Luganska Ukrainian |
132. | 36035/15 | Logachov v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Anatoliy Ivanovych LOGACHOV 1960 Debaltsevo Ukrainian |
133. | 36051/15 | Logachova v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Nataliya Anatoliyivna LOGACHOVA 1956 Debaltsevo Ukrainian |
134. | 36069/15 | Svetlova v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Nina Grygorivna SVETLOVA 1962 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
135. | 36077/15 | Povkh v. Russia and Ukraine | 10/07/2015 | Valentyn Ivanovych POVKH 1955 Lugansk Ukrainian |
136. | 37136/15 | Podolyanko v. Russia and Ukraine | 29/07/2015 | Nataliya Mykolayivna PODOLYANKO 1960 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
137. | 37188/15 | Stratilatov v. Russia and Ukraine | 29/07/2015 | Artem Olegovych STRATILATOV 1992 Debaltsevo Ukrainian |
138. | 37278/15 | Podolyanko v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Anatoliy Vasylyovych PODOLYANKO 1956 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
139. | 37293/15 | Stratilatova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Kristyna Volodymyrivna STRATILATOVA 1976 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
140. | 37295/15 | Stratilatov v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Sergiy Volodymyrovych STRATILATOV 1975 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
141. | 37300/15 | Mashchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Iryna Volodymyrivna MASHCHENKO 1960 Uglegirsk Ukrainian |
142. | 37304/15 | Pomnikova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Mariya Olegivna POMNIKOVA 1992 Lugansk Ukrainian |
143. | 37325/15 | Lopatina v. Russia and Ukraine | 29/07/2015 | Tetyana Ivanivna LOPATINA 1958 Vuglegirsk Ukrainian |
144. | 37627/15 | Stratilatova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Yevgeniya Sergiyivna STRATILATOVA 1997 Debaltsevo Ukrainian |
145. | 37631/15 | Logachova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Oksana Yuriyivna LOGACHOVA 1981 Debaltsevo Ukrainian |
146. | 37671/15 | Stratilatova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Svitlana Valeriyivna STRATILATOVA 1973 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
147. | 37679/15 | Shapovalova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Nina Gavrylivna SHAPOVALOVA 1959 Debaltsevo Ukrainian |
148. | 37688/15 | Shapovalova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Lyudmyla Anatoliyivna SHAPOVALOVA 1984 Debaltsevo Ukrainian |
149. | 37703/15 | Sukharevskyy v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Volodymyr Mykolayovych SUKHAREVSKYY 1955 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
150. | 37705/15 | Kibalo v. Russia and Ukraine | 04/07/2015 | Lyudmyla Grygorivna KIBALO 1955 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
151. | 37720/15 | Kudrya v. Russia and Ukraine | 04/07/2015 | Yuriy Oleksiyovych KUDRYA 1961 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
152. | 37723/15 | Sukharevska v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Tamara Volodymyrivna SUKHAREVSKA 2015 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
153. | 37731/15 | Melnikova v. Russia and Ukraine | 04/07/2015 | Valentyna Mykolayivna MELNIKOVA 1958 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
154. | 37738/15 | Kalashnikova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Lyudmyla Stanislavivna KALASHNIKOVA 1953 Komisarivka Ukrainian |
155. | 37742/15 | Dyusmyenyeva v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/07/2015 | Tetyana Oleksiyivna DYUSMYENYEVA 1951 Debaltsevo Ukrainian |
156. | 49733/15 | Naryadko v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Volodymyr Pavlovych NARYADKO 1950 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
157. | 49739/15 | Naryadko v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Ganna Fedotivna NARYADKO 1949 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
158. | 49777/15 | Chemet v. Russia and Ukraine | 22/09/2015 | Mykola Ivanovych CHEMET 1956 Lugansk Ukrainian |
159. | 49786/15 | Abesadze v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Kateryna Vasylivna ABESADZE 1954 Molodogvardiysk Ukrainian |
160. | 49844/15 | Abesadze v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Ketevani Vakhtangivna ABESADZE 1991 Molodogvardiysk Ukrainian |
161. | 49858/15 | Orashvili v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Ramaz Akakiyevich ORASHVILI 1954 Molodogvardiysk Ukrainian |
162. | 49861/15 | Sychov v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Igor Mykolayovych SYCHOV 1985 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
163. | 49868/15 | Abesadze v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Vakhtang Georgiyovych ABESADZE 1953 Molodogvardiysk Ukrainian |
164. | 49874/15 | Sychova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Lyudmyla Petrivna SYCHOVA 1954 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
165. | 49878/15 | Sychov v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Mykola Ivanovych SYCHOV 1950 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
166. | 50133/15 | Kadurin v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Viktor Ivanovych KADURIN 1958 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
167. | 50142/15 | Vlasova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Olena Grygorivna VLASOVA 1966 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
168. | 50148/15 | Vlasov v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Sergiy Rekovych VLASOV 1987 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
169. | 50158/15 | Koloda v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Vitaliy Vasylyovych KOLODA 1966 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
170. | 50193/15 | Kozhukhov v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/09/2015 | Oleksandr Oleksandrovych KOZHUKHOV 1974 Telmanove Ukrainian |
171. | 50251/15 | Medintseva v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/09/2015 | Tetyana Anatoliyivna MEDINTSEVA 1958 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
172. | 50253/15 | Dyatlova v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/09/2015 | Zinayida Mefodiyivna DYATLOVA 1935 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
173. | 50254/15 | Trotska v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/09/2015 | Olena Sergiyivna TROTSKA 1954 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
174. | 50256/15 | Trotskyy v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/09/2015 | Mykola Opanasovych TROTSKYY 1954 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
175. | 50262/15 | Moroz v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/09/2015 | Darya Oleksandrivna MOROZ 1983 Lugansk Ukrainian |
176. | 50326/15 | Kulishova v. Russia and Ukraine | 07/09/2015 | Nataliya Vakhtangivna KULISHOVA 1982 Molodogvardiysk Ukrainian |
177. | 50362/15 | Sychova v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/09/2015 | Kateryna Mykolayivna SYCHOVA 1985 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
178. | 50550/15 | Morozov v. Russia and Ukraine | 07/09/2014 | Yuriy Viktorovych MOROZOV 1956 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
179. | 50572/15 | Morozova v. Russia and Ukraine | 07/09/2015 | Darya Yuriyivna MOROZOVA 1991 Khryashchuvate Ukrainian |
180. | 50591/15 | Balashenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 07/09/2015 | Volodymyr Vasylyovych BALASHENKO 1957 Molodogvardiysk Ukrainian |
181. | 50615/15 | Boldyryeva v. Russia and Ukraine | 07/09/2015 | Tetyana Mykhaylivna BOLDYRYEVA 1963 Molodogvardiysk Ukrainian |
182. | 50616/15 | Dydyk v. Russia and Ukraine | 07/09/2015 | Tetyana Yegorivna DYDYK 1931 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
183. | 50803/15 | Romanenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/09/2015 | Lyudmyla Ivanivna ROMANENKO 1956 Lugansk Ukrainian |
184. | 50835/15 | Velykokhatska v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/09/2015 | Nina Ivanivna VELYKOKHATSKA 1950 Lugansk Ukrainian |
185. | 50837/15 | Medintsev v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/09/2015 | Oleksandr Yevgenovych MEDINTSEV 1986 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
186. | 50860/15 | Boguta v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Sergiy Valeriyovych BOGUTA 1975 Lugansk Ukrainian |
187. | 50869/15 | Vorobyov v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Yevgen Viktorovych VOROBYOV 1979 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
188. | 50883/15 | Farsikov v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Oleksiy Yegorovych FARSIKOV 1972 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
189. | 50888/15 | Orashvili v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Maryna Mykhaylivna ORASHVILI 1965 Molodogvardiysk Ukrainian |
190. | 50927/15 | Bardin v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/09/2015 | Yevgen Yuriyovych BARDIN 1957 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
191. | 50933/15 | Khrystenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/09/2015 | Valentyn Radionovych KHRYSTENKO 1960 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
192. | 50965/15 | Farsikova v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Mariya Afanasiyivna FARSIKOVA 1936 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
193. | 50968/15 | Bardina v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/09/2015 | Lyudmyla Volodymyrivna BARDINA 1957 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
194. | 50980/15 | Kushniruk v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Olena Mykolayivna KUSHNIRUK 1970 Lugansk Ukrainian |
195. | 50991/15 | Shaulska v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Galyna Mykolayivna SHAULSKA 1975 Telmanove Ukrainian |
196. | 51011/15 | Chernykh v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Lyubov Mykhaylivna CHERNYKH 1953 Fabrychne Ukrainian |
197. | 51047/15 | Kramarenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Yevgen Mykolayovych KRAMARENKO 1971 Debaltsevo Ukrainian |
198. | 51058/15 | Lupain v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Oleksiy Dmytrovych LUPAIN 1980 Vuglegirsk Ukrainian |
199. | 51067/15 | Vereshchagina v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Nataliya Valeriyivna VERESHCHAGINA 1978 Debaltsevo Ukrainian |
200. | 51074/15 | Krolevetska v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Valentyna Sydorivna KROLEVETSKA 1956 Molodogvardiysk Ukrainian |
201. | 51086/15 | Krolevetskyy v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Borys Vasylyovych KROLEVETSKYY 1957 Molodogvardiysk Ukrainian |
202. | 51096/15 | Zharikova v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/09/2015 | Valentyna Pavlivna ZHARIKOVA 1954 Khryashchuvate Ukrainian |
203. | 51216/15 | Gryazyeva v. Russia and Ukraine | 28/09/2015 | Lyubov Viktorivna GRYAZYEVA 1955 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
204. | 51339/15 | Nosach v. Russia and Ukraine | 28/09/2015 | Sergiy Mykolayovych NOSACH 1975 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
205. | 51347/15 | Nosach v. Russia and Ukraine | 28/09/2015 | Olena Volodymyrivna NOSACH 1975 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
206. | 51349/15 | Bakhmutchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 28/09/2015 | Igor Valeriyovych BAKHMUTCHENKO 1970 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
207. | 51354/15 | Klyuchnikova v. Russia and Ukraine | 28/09/2015 | Valentyna Ivanivna KLYUCHNIKOVA 1953 Komuna Ukrainian |
208. | 52013/15 | Bakhmutchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 28/09/2015 | Tetyana Volodymyrivna BAKHMUTCHENKO 1978 Debaltseve Ukrainian Dmytro Igorovych BAKHMUTCHENKO 2004 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
209. | 53071/15 | Trostynska v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/10/2015 | Liliya Anatoliyivna TROSTYNSKA 1936 Gorlivka Ukrainian |
210. | 53076/15 | Salova v. Russia and Ukraine | 15/10/2015 | Olga Ivanivna SALOVA 1964 Gorlivka Ukrainian |
211. | 61176/15 | Shalimova v. Russia and Ukraine | 21/11/2015 | Tetyana Valeriyivna SHALIMOVA 1987 Komuna Ukrainian |
212. | 62043/15 | Bondarenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Svitlana Grygorivna BONDARENKO 1972 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
213. | 62068/15 | Pavlenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Mykhaylo Yuriyovych PAVLENKO 1959 Krasnodon Ukrainian |
214. | 62116/15 | Sapozhkova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Valentyna Viktorivna SAPOZHKOVA 1953 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
215. | 62125/15 | Panko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Lyudmyla Semenivna PANKO 1953 Komuna Ukrainian |
216. | 62128/15 | Dyrda v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Galyna Oleksandrivna DYRDA 1940 Zorynsk Ukrainian |
217. | 62275/15 | Panko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Roman Grygorovych PANKO 1974 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
218. | 62276/15 | Myakotkin v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Igor Vadymovych MYAKOTKIN 1966 Odesa Ukrainian |
219. | 62280/15 | Vasylchenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Valentyna Ivanivna VASYLCHENKO 1940 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
220. | 62282/15 | Myakotkin v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Roman Vadymovych MYAKOTKIN 1975 Lugansk Ukrainian |
221. | 62283/15 | Koryavko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Lyudmyla Ivanivna KORYAVKO 1951 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
222. | 62287/15 | Rusinova v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Oleksandra Antonivna RUSINOVA 1940 Kharkiv Ukrainian |
223. | 62288/15 | Rusinov v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Dmytro Ivanovych RUSINOV 1973 Pervomaysk Ukrainian |
224. | 62289/15 | Rusinov v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Anton Dmytrovych RUSINOV 1997 Pervomaysk Ukrainian |
225. | 294/16 | Kharman v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Lidiya Stepanivna KHARMAN 1950 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
226. | 303/16 | Klymenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Oleksandr Oleksiyovych KLYMENKO 1972 Lugansk Ukrainian |
227. | 505/16 | Fylymonenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Gennadiy Leonidovych FYLYMONENKO 1967 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
228. | 731/16 | Nosach v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Grygoriy Viktorovych NOSACH 1954 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
229. | 736/16 | Alyokhina v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Oleksandra Pavlivna ALYOKHINA 1933 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
230. | 3870/16 | Moroz v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Kateryna Yuriyivna MOROZ 1996 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
231. | 3999/16 | Glushchenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Oleksandr Valeriyovych GLUSHCHENKO 1975 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
232. | 4009/16 | Glushchenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Sergiy Oleksandrovych GLUSHCHENKO 1996 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
233. | 4013/16 | Glushchenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Olena Viktorivna GLUSHCHENKO 1977 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
234. | 4027/16 | Astakhova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Tamara Vasylivna ASTAKHOVA 1964 Vuglegirsk Ukrainian |
235. | 4044/16 | Lunina v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Ryta Mykolayivna LUNINA 1938 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
236. | 4152/16 | Ryabtseva v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Olena Valentynivna RYABTSEVA 1987 Stakhanov Ukrainian |
237. | 4158/16 | Bogdanets v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Galyna Vasylivna BOGDANETS 1958 Novosvitlivka Ukrainian |
238. | 4164/16 | Prysyazhnyy v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Mykola Vasylyovych PRYSYAZHNYY 1948 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
239. | 4182/16 | Danylenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Viktor Ivanovych DANYLENKO 1960 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
240. | 4184/16 | Danylenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Maksym Viktorovych DANYLENKO 1980 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
241. | 4187/16 | Danylenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Olena Petrivna DANYLENKO 1954 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
242. | 4188/16 | Mozgovenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Larysa Oleksiyivna MOZGOVENKO 1943 Zorynsk Ukrainian |
243. | 4198/16 | Kubosha v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Lyubov Kondrativna KUBOSHA 1948 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
244. | 4207/16 | Kubosha v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Viktor Stepanovych KUBOSHA 1946 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
245. | 4336/16 | Prysyazhna v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Lyubov Mykolayivna PRYSYAZHNA 1954 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
246. | 4393/16 | Danylov v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Mykhaylo Sergiyovych DANYLOV 2012 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
247. | 4395/16 | Danylova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Yuliya Volodymyrivna DANYLOVA 1987 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
248. | 4403/16 | Lipkin v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Anatoliy Ivanovych LIPKIN 1938 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
249. | 4646/16 | Kononenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Olga Vasylivna KONONENKO 1959 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
250. | 4661/16 | Poveshchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Ganna Vasylivna POVESHCHENKO 1983 Donetsk Ukrainian |
251. | 4676/16 | Poveshchenko v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Nina Volodymyrivna POVESHCHENKO 1951 Donetsk Ukrainian |
252 | 4709/16 | Moroz v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Yuriy Mykhaylovych MOROZ 1966 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
253. | 4716/16 | Moroz v. Russia and Ukraine | 24/11/2015 | Svitlana Ivanivna MOROZ 1969 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
254. | 4747/16 | Yurystovskyy v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Vasyl Vasylyovych YURYSTOVSKYY 1974 Lebedynske Ukrainian |
255. | 4752/16 | Polivoda v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Rayisa Ullivna POLIVODA 1936 Debaltsevo Ukrainian |
256. | 4757/16 | Yurystovska v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Olena Ivanivna YURYSTOVSKA Lebedynske Ukrainian |
257. | 4763/16 | Yurystovska v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Viktoriya Vasylivna YURYSTOVSKA 1999 Lebedynske Ukrainian |
258. | 4802/16 | Yurystovskyy v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Vasyl Onufriyovych YURYSTOVSKYY 1944 Lebedynske Ukrainian |
259. | 4818/16 | Yurystovska v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Lyubov Yaroslavivna YURYSTOVSKA 1948 Lebedynske Ukrainian |
260. | 4853/16 | Ilyinova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Lyudmyla Borysivna ILYINOVA 1949 Zorynsk Ukrainian |
261. | 4893/16 | Borysov v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Albert Yuriyovych BORYSOV 1966 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
262. | 4902/16 | Borysova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Ganna Albertivna BORYSOVA 1994 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
263. | 19238/16 | Bragin v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 05/04/2016 | Anatoliy Stepanovych BRAGIN 1942 Pavlopil Ukrainian |
264. | 19242/16 | Bragin v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 05/04/2016 | Vitaliy Anatoliyovych BRAGIN 1973 Mariupol Ukrainian |
265. | 19315/16 | Shcherbakova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 05/04/2016 | Vira Semenivna SHCHERBAKOVA 1939 Pavlopil Ukrainian |
266. | 19391/16 | Kuzin v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 05/04/2016 | Mykola Andriyovych KUZIN 1932 Pervomaysk Ukrainian |
267. | 19414/16 | Ladya, Pp v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 05/04/2016 | LADYA, PP 1996 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
268. | 26393/16 | Sergiyiva v. Ukraine | 26/10/2015 | Lina Volodymyrivna SERGIYIVA 1961 Dnipro Ukrainian |
269. | 27799/16 | Mykhaylenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 25/02/2016 | Tetyana Oleksandrivna MYKHAYLENKO 1962 Bayrachky Ukrainian |
270. | 29978/16 | Chernyavska v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 25/02/2016 | Larysa Oleksandrivna CHERNYAVSKA 1971 Аntratsyt Ukrainian |
271. | 29980/16 | Rybak v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 25/02/2016 | Mariya Leonidivna RYBAK 1985 Donetsk Ukrainian |
272. | 29981/16 | Klymenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 25/02/2016 | Oleksandr Oleksiyovych KLYMENKO 1972 Lugansk Ukrainian |
273. | 30078/16 | Chernyavskyy v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 25/02/2016 | Yanyk Olegovych CHERNYAVSKYY 1992 Antratsyt Ukrainian |
274. | 30083/16 | Rybak v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 25/02/2016 | Sergiy Viktorovych RYBAK 1985 Donetsk Ukrainian |
275. | 30100/16 | Dmytrenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 25/02/2016 | Svitlana Volodymyrivna DMYTRENKO 1970 Komuna Ukrainian |
276. | 32693/16 | Popova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Galyna Romanivna POPOVA 1946 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
277. | 32733/16 | Fedorova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Alla Viktorivna FEDOROVA 1974 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
278. | 32813/16 | Gerasymova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Olga Yegorivna GERASYMOVA 1964 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
279. | 32822/16 | Gerasymova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Valentyna Mykhaylivna GERASYMOVA 1985 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
280. | 32844/16 | Ryabukhina v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Valentyna Petrivna RYABUKHINA 1940 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
281. | 32888/16 | Pozhydayev v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Mykola Oleksandrovych POZHYDAYEV 1952 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
282. | 32891/16 | Rukavchuk v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Olena Viktorivna RUKAVCHUK 1970 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
283. | 32965/16 | Malikova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Valentyna Afanasivna MALIKOVA 1943 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
284. | 33006/16 | Valuyska v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Valentyna Yevgenivna VALUYSKA 1956 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
285. | 33010/16 | Valuyskyy v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Oleksandr Mykhaylovych VALUYSKYY 1950 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
286. | 33013/16 | Stolyarov v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Vasyl Andriyovych STOLYAROV 1936 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
287. | 33021/16 | Fedorova v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Asya Ivanivna FEDOROVA 1940 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
288. | 33023/16 | Litvinov v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Leonid Kyrylovych LITVINOV 1954 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
289. | 33033/16 | Satsyk v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Andriy Danylovych SATSYK 1955 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
290. | 33035/16 | Kuzyuberdina v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Nina Oleksandrivna KUZYUBERDINA 1949 Stanytsya Luganska Ukrainian |
291. | 33085/16 | Kolbayev v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Oleksandr Vasylyovych KOLBAYEV 1979 Donetsk Ukrainian |
292. | 33090/16 | Kolbayeva v. Russia and Ukraine | 17/04/2016 | Olena Ivanivna KOLBAYEVA 1972 Donetsk Ukrainian |
293. | 33289/16 | Shumetov v. Ukraine | 30/04/2016 | Oleksiy Valentynovych SHUMETOV 1975 Lugansk Ukrainian |
294. | 33303/16 | Teneri, TOV v. Ukraine | 30/04/2016 | TENERI, TOV 2001 Lugansk Ukrainian |
295. | 33308/16 | Otsinka mayna ta maynovykh prav, TOV v. Ukraine | 30/04/2016 | OTSINKA MAYNA TA MAYNOVYKH PRAV, TOV 2012 Lugansk Ukrainian |
296. | 38188/16 | Ryabchynska v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/06/2016 | Alla Petrivna RYABCHYNSKA 1973 Slovyansk Ukrainian |
297. | 38200/16 | Ryabchynska v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/06/2016 | Violeta Sergiyivna RYABCHYNSKA 1996 Slovyansk Ukrainian |
298. | 39926/16 | Zholobova v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/06/2016 | Tetyana Kostyantynivna ZHOLOBOVA 1960 Lugansk region Ukrainian |
299. | 39989/16 | Sergyeyeva v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 23/06/2016 | Valentyna Ivanivna SERGYEYEVA 1959 Vuglegirsk Ukrainian |
300. | 40083/16 | Chyrskov v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/06/2016 | Volodymyr Oleksandrovych CHYRSKOV 1959 Lugansk Ukrainian |
301. | 40098/16 | Voronko v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/06/2016 | Olena Ivanivna VORONKO 1966 Lugansk Ukrainian |
302. | 40107/16 | Voronko v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/06/2016 | Valeriy Oleksiyovych VORONKO Lugansk Ukrainian |
303. | 40113/16 | Chyrskova v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/06/2016 | Tetyana Oleksandrivna CHYRSKOVA 1949 Lugansk Ukrainian |
304. | 40142/16 | Ronska v. Russia and Ukraine | 23/06/2016 | Oksana Sergiyivna RONSKA 1973 Lugansk Ukrainian |
305. | 41229/16 | Protasov v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 09/07/2016 | Sergiy Yuriovych PROTASOV 1982 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
306. | 41237/16 | Korobko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 09/07/2016 | Oleksandr Pavlovych KOROBKO 1969 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
307. | 41243/16 | Vodolazska v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 09/07/2016 | Nataliya Ivanivna VODOLAZSKA 1982 Debalsteve Ukrainian |
308. | 41250/16 | Protasova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 09/07/2016 | Lyubov Pavlivna PROTASOVA 1963 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
309. | 41258/16 | Vodolazskyy v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 09/07/2016 | Oleksiy Sergiyovych VODOLAZSKYY 1977 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
310. | 41264/16 | Profatylo v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 09/07/2016 | Tamara Tymofiyivna PROFATYLO 1952 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
311. | 41266/16 | Parkhomov v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 09/07/2016 | Oleksandr Mykolayovych PARKHOMOV 1954 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
312. | 50493/16 | Konstantynova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 13/08/2016 | Nadiya Yuriyivna KONSTANTYNOVA 1959 Vuglegirsk Ukrainian |
313. | 50510/16 | Pavlyuchenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 13/08/2016 | Gennadiy Volodymyrovych PAVLYUCHENKO 1954 Vuglegirsk Ukrainian |
314. | 50516/16 | Fedotova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 13/08/2016 | Oksana Gennadiyivna FEDOTOVA 1984 Vuglegirsk Ukrainian |
315. | 50521/16 | Konstantynov v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 13/08/2016 | Oleksandr Yuriyiovych KONSTANTYNOV 1980 Vuglegirsk Ukrainian |
316. | 51399/16 | Borysova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom | 24/11/2015 | Inna Mykhaylivna BORYSOVA 1967 Debaltseve Ukrainian |
317. | 79333/16 | Kosachov v. Ukraine | 10/12/2016 | Vasyl Volodymyrovych KOSACHOV 1925 Lugansk Ukrainian |
318. | 79338/16 | Tselovalnichenko v. Ukraine | 01/12/2016 | Svitlana Vasylivna TSELOVALNICHENKO 1956 Lugansk Ukrainian |
319. | 79390/16 | Tselovalnichenko v. Ukraine | 10/12/2016 | Yevgeniy Ivanovych TSELOVALNICHENKO 1951 Lugansk Ukrainian |
320. | 14010/17 | Pryvatvtorm, TOV v. Ukraine | 10/02/2017 | PRYVATVTORM, TOV 2001 Kyiv Ukrainian |
321. | 16386/17 | Klymenko v. Ukraine | 16/02/2017 | Oleksandr Oleksiyovych KLYMENKO 1972 Lugansk Ukrainian |
322. | 16771/17 | Klimenko v. Ukraine | 16/02/2017 | Oleksiy Oleksiyovych KLIMENKO 1937 Lugansk Ukrainian |
323. | 42405/17 | Gromadska organizatsiya Luganska pravozakhysna grupa v. Ukraine | 06/06/2017 | GROMADSKA ORGANIZATSIYA LUGANSKA PRAVOZAKHYSNA GRUPA 2008 Lugansk Ukrainian |
324. | 66858/17 | Spiridonov v. Ukraine | 20/08/2017 | Oleksandr Oleksandrovych SPIRIDONOV 1964 Donetsk Ukrainian |
325. | 68110/17 | Vorobyova v. Ukraine | 01/09/2017 | Tetyana Borysivna VOROBYOVA 1958 Valuyske Ukrainian |
326. | 68137/17 | Vorobyov v. Ukraine | 01/09/2017 | Andriy Viktorovych VOROBYOV 1996 Valuyske Ukrainian |
327. | 68181/17 | Vorobyova v. Ukraine | 01/09/2017 | Svitlana Borysivna VOROBYOVA 1968 Valuyske Ukrainian |