Přehled
Rozhodnutí
SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 59893/11
Stojan AGATONOVIĆ against Serbia
and 101 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 17 December 2013 as a Committee composed of:
Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque, President,
Dragoljub Popović,
Helen Keller, judges,
and Stanley Naismith, Section Registrar.
Having regard to the above applications lodged on 12 September 2011,
Having regard to the formal declarations accepting a friendly settlement of the cases,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
FACTS AND PROCEDURE
A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix. They were all represented by the same attorney, Mr M. Moskovljević, a lawyer practising in Kruševac.
The Serbian Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent, Mr S. Carić.
All applicants are former employees of the same socially-owned company - Građevinsko preduzeće Jastrebac - from Kruševac (hereinafter: the debtor). In the course of insolvency proceedings against the debtor on 11 July 2003 the Kraljevo Commercial Court adopted decisions (domestic case no. St.2505/02) according to which the debtor was ordered to pay the applicants certain sums. The applicants complained about the respondent State’s failure to enforce the said decisions rendered in their favour.
After unsuccessful friendly settlement negotiations, by letter dated 9 September 2013 the Government informed the Court that they proposed to make a declaration with a view to resolving the issues raised by the application.
The declaration provided as follows:
“I declare that the Government of the Republic of Serbia is ready to accept that there had been a violation of the applicants’ right under Article 6 paragraph 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention.
I further declare that within three-month period the Government offer to pay to the applicants listed below, the sums awarded in the domestic decisions under consideration in this case, less any amounts which may have already been paid on the basis of the said decisions.
These sums shall be payable within three months from the date of delivery of the decision of the Court. This payment will constitute the final resolution of the case.
The Government regret the occurrence of the actions which have led to the bringing of the present applications.”
On 15 October 2013, the Court received a letter from the applicants’ representative informing the Court that they had agreed to the terms of the Government’s declaration.
THE LAW
The Court considers that, in accordance with Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal background.
The Court finds that following the applicants’ express agreement to the terms of the declaration made by the Government the case should be treated as a friendly settlement between the parties.
The Court takes note of the friendly settlement reached between the parties. It is satisfied that the settlement is based on respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols and finds no reasons to justify a continued examination of the applications. In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the case out of the list.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Decides to strike the applications out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 39 of the Convention.
Stanley Naismith Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque
Registrar President
Appendix
No | Application No | Applicant Date of birth Place of residence Nationality |
59893/11 | Stojan AGATONOVIĆ 03/03/1956 selo Žiljci, Serbian | |
25768/12 | Radomir PAVLOVIĆ 13/04/1949 selo Čitluk Serbian | |
25786/12 | Živorad MILOJEVIĆ 07/06/1957 selo Čitluk Serbian | |
25797/12 | Milutin PAVLOVIĆ 20/03/1954 selo Šanac Serbian | |
25807/12 | Nikola OJDANIĆ 24/09/1972 Kruševac Serbian | |
25809/12 | Zorica PETRONIJEVIĆ 26/08/1948 Kruševac Serbian | |
25810/12 | Nikolaj NIKOLOV 01/04/1945 Kruševac Serbian | |
25811/12 | Nada NIKOLIĆ 19/01/1947 Kruševac Serbian | |
25812/12 | Miroslav POPADIĆ 26/05/1956 selo Šavrane Serbian | |
25813/12 | Milan PEŠIĆ 23/06/1965 Kruševac Serbian | |
25814/12 | Slaviša JEVGENIJEVIĆ 05/06/1974 selo Rosica Serbian | |
25815/12 | Miloš BLAGOJEVIĆ 07/02/1951 selo Štitare Serbian | |
25816/12 | Branislav BAJIĆ 26/10/1936 Kruševac Serbian | |
25817/12 | Slavko VOJINOVIĆ 18/05/1946 Kruševac Serbian | |
25818/12 | Boris VIDIĆ 23/02/1944 Kruševac Serbian | |
25820/12 | Jugoslav MATIĆ 28/01/1954 selo Šanac Serbian | |
25821/12 | Mirko VASIĆ 23/10/1944 Kruševac Serbian | |
25822/12 | Milivoje BUJIĆ 17/12/1960 Krusevac Serbian | |
25823/12 | Milica BOŠKOVIĆ 10/07/1957 Kruševac Serbian | |
25830/12 | Ljubiša BOŠKOVIĆ 20/08/1960 Prnjavor Serbian | |
25839/12 | Ružica BOGDANOVIĆ 01/02/1947 Kruševac Serbian | |
25848/12 | Nadica BOGDANOVIĆ 23/07/1954 Kruševac Serbian | |
25851/12 | Veroljub VUČKOVIĆ 25/03/1966 selo Prepeljevac Serbian | |
25857/12 | Ankica ĐOKOVIĆ 14/09/1956 Kruševac Serbian | |
25860/12 | Slobodan DUBOVAC 02/04/1940 Kruševac Serbian | |
25872/12 | Miroslav DIŠLJENKOVIĆ 01/01/1961 Kruševac Serbian | |
25878/12 | Minko DINOV 24/09/1970 selo Pepeljevac Serbian | |
25880/12 | Ranko DIMITRIJEVIĆ 27/03/1960 Kruševac Serbian | |
25883/12 | Živorad ĐORĐEVIĆ 09/05/1950 selo Dedina Serbian | |
25904/12 | Slobodan ĐORĐEVIĆ 14/04/1945 selo Zabare Serbian | |
25908/12 | Milorad ĐORĐEVIĆ 30/09/1944 selo Lomnica Serbian | |
25919/12 | Dragan ĐORĐEVIĆ 28/10/1955 selo Čitluk Serbian | |
25924/12 | Miroslav NIKOLIĆ 21/06/1952 Kruševac Serbian | |
25986/12 | Slobodan STOJANOVIĆ 02/11/1948 selo Žabare Serbian | |
25987/12 | Simeon STOJANOVIĆ 15/02/1946 selo V. Kruševica Serbian | |
25988/12 | Radoslav DINIĆ 21/04/1947 selo Dobromir Serbian | |
25989/12 | Milomir ILIĆ 17/11/1953 Kruševac Serbian | |
25991/12 | Slobodan ILIĆ 28/10/1949 selo Čitluk Serbian | |
25992/12 | Zoran NEŠIĆ 20/08/1966 selo Konjuh Serbian | |
25993/12 | Mirjana MARIJANOVIĆ 08/09/1964 Kruševac Serbian | |
26002/12 | Ranđel MARINKOVIĆ 05/11/1944 selo V. Kruševica Serbian | |
26005/12 | Božidar DAMNJANOVIĆ 10/10/1941 Kruševac Serbian | |
26008/12 | Veljko NIKOLIĆ 26/04/1962 Kruševac Serbian | |
26010/12 | Dragić ĐORĐEVIĆ 15/09/1955 selo Lepenac Serbian | |
26013/12 | Jasmina JANKOVIĆ 31/12/1975 selo Rudjinci Serbian | |
26014/12 | Milan POPOVIĆ 13/12/1954 Kruševac Serbian | |
26019/12 | Golub OJDANIĆ 10/03/1944 Kruševac Serbian | |
26020/12 | Srboljub ĐURĐEVIĆ 24/04/1947 Kruševac Serbian | |
26026/12 | Goran NIKOLIĆ 23/09/1973 selo Gornji Stepoš Serbian | |
26032/12 | Dragan NIKOLIĆ 12/01/1950 selo Mali Šiljegovac Serbian | |
26034/12 | Ružica NESTOROVIĆ 20/10/1951 Kruševac Serbian | |
26036/12 | Petar TRIFUNOVIĆ 21/04/1946 Kruševac Serbian | |
26041/12 | Dobrica MILOJEVIĆ 26/10/1950 Kruševac Serbian | |
26044/12 | Miladin TROŠIĆ 29/11/1962 Kruševac Serbian | |
26049/12 | Svetlana MILOJKOVIĆ 28/02/1949 Kruševac Serbian | |
26050/12 | Živorad ZDRAVKOVIĆ 23/12/1950 selo Zdravinje Serbian | |
26064/12 | Milovan STOJKOVIĆ 02/08/1973 Kruševac Serbian | |
26069/12 | Svetislav IVANOVIĆ 29/03/1974 selo Crkvina Serbian | |
26073/12 | Mirjana IVANOVIĆ 24/11/1959 Kruševac Serbian | |
26080/12 | Živorad IVANOVIĆ 10/08/1946 Kruševac Serbian | |
26111/12 | Zorica ZDRAVKOVIĆ 26/06/1968 selo Lomnica Serbian | |
26118/12 | Saša MILOVANOVIĆ 28/11/1975 selo Vitanovac Serbian | |
26123/12 | Milovan JAKOVLJEVIĆ 04/07/1958 selo V. Plana Serbian | |
26131/12 | Slobodan ATANASKOVIĆ 05/11/1957 Kruševac Serbian | |
26137/12 | Radmila ANTIĆ 21/04/1946 Kruševac Serbian | |
26139/12 | Ljubomir ALIĆ 01/09/1944 selo Pločnik Serbian | |
26145/12 | Miroljub JOVANOVIĆ 08/11/1972 Kruševac Serbian | |
26154/12 | Bratislav KNEŽEVIĆ 05/05/1957 Kruševac Serbian | |
26156/12 | Branislav KALEZIĆ 06/08/1950 Kruševac Serbian | |
26160/12 | Miodrag KADRIĆ 25/02/1948 selo Pločnik Serbian | |
26164/12 | Ljubisav KOVAČEVIĆ 16/04/1939 Kruševac Serbian | |
26165/12 | Slavka KNEŽEVIĆ 23/09/1950 Kruševac Serbian | |
26166/12 | Milomir ŽIVKOVIĆ 12/01/1949 Kruševac Serbian | |
26167/12 | Ljubiša ŽIVOJINOVIĆ 19/07/1942 selo V. Golovode Serbian | |
26169/12 | Momčilo MILJKOVIĆ 23/01/1948 selo Grevci Serbian | |
26170/12 | Boban LISINAC 24/11/1973 Kruševac Serbian | |
26171/12 | Dragan LAZAREVIĆ 14/05/1965 Kruševac Serbian | |
26174/12 | Slavica KUČ 29/05/1949 Kruševac Serbian | |
26176/12 | Branislav JOVANOVIĆ 19/06/1974 Kruševac Serbian | |
26178/12 | Milica STOJANOV 21/08/1948 Kruševac Serbian | |
26181/12 | Ivanca STANKOV 05/12/1952 Kruševac Serbian | |
26186/12 | Miroslav CIVIĆ 29/03/1943 selo Ribare Serbian | |
26188/12 | Krstomir ĐORĐEVIĆ 28/02/1951 selo Dedina Serbian | |
26191/12 | Zoran PETROVIĆ 05/06/1953 selo Dvorane Serbian | |
26194/12 | Ljubiša PETRONIJEVIĆ 25/01/1950 selo Sušica Serbian | |
26198/12 | Dušan PETROVIĆ 20/08/1948 Kruševac Serbian | |
26200/12 | Suzana ĆIRIĆ 01/11/1950 Kruševac Serbian | |
26205/12 | Srboljub ĐOKOVIĆ 04/03/1955 Kruševac Serbian | |
26251/12 | Veroljub PANIĆ 10/10/1963 selo Majdevo Serbian | |
26255/12 | Snežana PANTELIĆ 16/11/1976 selo Dvorane Serbian | |
26276/12 | Selena VUČKOVIĆ 20/11/1960 Kruševac Serbian | |
26278/12 | Jovan TOŠIĆ 21/05/1942 selo Dedina Serbian | |
26281/12 | Milomir VUKADINOVIĆ 09/04/1949 selo Sušica Serbian | |
26282/12 | Tomislav PETROVIĆ 07/01/1963 selo Dvorane Serbian | |
26287/12 | Srboljub PETROVIĆ 27/11/1956 Selo Igroš Serbian | |
26288/12 | Miroljub OBRADOVIĆ 25/08/1952 selo Golubovac Serbian | |
26291/12 | Stojadin IVIĆ 28/07/1943 selo Meševo Serbian | |
26293/12 | Slađan STANOJLOVIĆ 20/02/1977 selo Boljevac, R. Banja Serbian | |
26295/12 | Obrad CUCA 17/03/1948 Kruševac Serbian | |
26337/12 | Jelica RAŠKOVIĆ 26/04/1957 Kruševac Serbian | |
26338/12 | Dragan RISTIĆ 25/03/1951 Kruševac Serbian | |
26339/12 | Vukoman ČOLOVEJIĆ 31/08/1956 Kruševac Serbian |