Přehled
Rozhodnutí
SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 40869/07
Yadin KARAGÖL against Turkey
and 174 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 5 November 2013 as a Committee composed of:
Dragoljub Popović, President,
Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque,
Helen Keller, judges,
and Seçkin Erel, Acting Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the 175 applications lodged on the dates indicated in the annex,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
A. The circumstances of the cases
The facts of the cases, as submitted by the applicants whose names are listed in the appendix, may be summarized as follows.
On different dates, the applicants initiated actions before various courts or had civil, administrative or criminal proceedings brought against them. All proceedings lasted several years.
B. Relevant domestic law
A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in Müdür Turgut and others v. Turkey ((dec.), no 4860/09, §§ 19-26, 26 March 2013).
COMPLAINTS
The applicants complained under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention that the proceedings before the national courts had not been concluded within a reasonable time.
Some of the applicants raised other complaints, particularly under Articles 6, 8, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol no. 1.
These complaints are linked to the same proceedings which they complain about the excessive length.
THE LAW
I. JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS
The Court considers that, pursuant to Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal backgrounds.
II. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION
All the applicants complained that the length of the relevant proceedings before national tribunals were excessive and thus fell short of the requirements of Article 6 § 1, which provides:
“1. In the determination of his civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charge against him, everyone is entitled to a (...) hearing within a reasonable time (...) by a tribunal (...)”
The Court observes that the applicants considered the length of the proceedings in question to be incompatible with the requirement of “reasonable time” laid down in Article 6 § 1 of the Convention.
In that respect, the Court found in its decision Müdür Turgut and others (cited above, § 56) that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384, insofar as it is accessible and capable of offering reasonable prospects of redress for complaints concerning the length of proceedings, constituted a remedy which applicants were required to exhaust for the purposes of Article 35 § 1 of the Convention.
In the present cases, the Court sees no reason to come to a different conclusion.
It follows that these complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
III. OTHER ALLEGED VIOLATIONS OF THE CONVENTION
Relying on various articles of the Convention or its Protocols, the applicants also presented some other complaints.
Having examined the applicants’ complaints in the light of all the material in its possession, and insofar as the matters complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that they do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.
It follows that these parts of the present applications are manifestly ill‑founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Seçkin Erel Dragoljub Popović
Acting Deputy Registrar President
Appendix
No | Application No | Lodged on | Applicant Date of birth Place of residence | Represented by |
10/09/2007 | Yadin KARAGÖL 02/03/1961 Kayseri | |||
27/02/2008 | Sait TANGÖR 01/04/1950 Manisa | İbrahim Halil TANGÖR | ||
19/05/2008 | Müzeyyen ONGAN 23/06/1945 Istanbul | Mehmet UÇUM | ||
26/09/2008 | Hüseyin ERTUĞRUL 04/11/1940 Ankara | |||
20/02/2009 | Kamil Engin ÖZTÜRK 01/01/1950 Istanbul Gülsevim UZUNLAR 01/01/1941 Istanbul Ümit ÖZTÜRK 01/01/1952 Istanbul Eyüp Dursun AYTAÇ 01/01/1949 Istanbul Şerife KARA Istanbul Halil ÜÇLER 01/01/1935 Istanbul Sinem ÜÇLER 01/01/1990 Istanbul Hasene ŞEN 01/01/1927 Istanbul Emine Yüksel TAŞOVA 01/01/1947 Istanbul Hatice Gülsüm KILIÇARSLAN 01/01/1956 Istanbul Fatma Zehra ALTINEL 01/01/1949 Istanbul Mehmet Ali BİLGİLİ Istanbul Halit SEZER 01/01/1943 Istanbul Ömer Lütfi SEZER 01/01/1915 Istanbul Ayşe KARASU 01/01/1949 Istanbul Nalan ARAÇ 01/01/1970 Istanbul Nazan TANK 01/01/1978 Istanbul Elif KARASU 01/01/1983 Istanbul | Atiye ÜLKÜ | ||
01/07/2009 | Kani FİDAN 01/01/1962 Samsun Rahime FİDAN 14/02/1960 Samsun Orhan FİDAN 25/02/1981 Samsun Hakan FİDAN 08/01/1985 Samsun Nurgül FİDAN 30/03/1989 Samsun Hayrettin AYYILDIZ 05/10/1971 Samsun Yılmaz ÖZTÜRK 01/12/1969 Samsun Ali UZUN 22/03/1965 Samsun | |||
10/08/2010 | Dilif KIRMIZITAŞ 01/07/1924 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Leyla AKTAŞ 01/08/1948 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Rıza BOZOOĞLU 01/04/1956 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Dursun AĞGÜL 15/05/1973 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Selvi AĞGÜL 06/04/1935 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Yeter KARATAŞ 02/11/1964 Istanbul Halil KARATAŞ 01/01/1957 Istanbul Sabire İÇYER 17/05/1948 Istanbul Aslı İÇYER 10/04/1973 Istanbul Seda BOZOOĞLU 10/03/1962 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
01/09/2010 | Murat PALANGO 01/01/1971 Istanbul Celal ÖZGÜL 01/01/1961 Tunceli Paşa AĞGÜL 01/01/1939 Elif COŞAN 01/01/1952 Istanbul Aydın ÇILGIN 01/01/1966 Istanbul Gülten ÖNDER 01/01/1960 Istanbul Haydar TOPUZ 01/01/1951 Istanbul İbis TOPUZ 01/01/1935 Istanbul Hıdır ENGİN 01/01/1934 Duisburg Ani ÇILGIN 01/01/1936 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
31/08/2010 | Teslim GÜLOĞLU 16/09/1965 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Turan AĞGÜL 01/03/1965 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Ali İhsan AĞGÜL 01/01/1964 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Selvi TOPUZ 01/01/1946 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Celal KIRMIZITAŞ 01/01/1953 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | İbrahim KARATAŞ 01/01/1939 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Cahit AKTAŞ 01/01/1954 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Cafer AĞGÜL 01/01/1935 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Alettin BOZTAŞ 01/01/1964 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Ağa LAZIM 01/01/1959 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Zabit KUL 01/01/1951 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Müslüm KIRMIZITAŞ 01/01/1954 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Halit KIRMIZITAŞ 01/01/1947 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Ahmet LAZIM 01/01/1950 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Kenan AĞGÜL 01/01/1966 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Hamu ELMAS 01/01/1935 Tunceli | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Keziban BOZOOĞLU 01/01/1938 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Sait AKTAŞ 01/01/1954 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Teslim KIRMIZITAŞ 01/01/1960 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Cemal BOZOOĞLU 01/01/1956 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Hüseyin GÜNGÖR 01/01/1951 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Seydo BOZOOĞLU 01/01/1949 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Metin BOZOOĞLU 01/01/1952 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Hüseyin BOZTAŞ 01/01/1950 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Özkan KIRMIZITAŞ 01/01/1964 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Kenan BOZOOĞLU 01/01/1952 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Hasan BOZTAŞ 01/01/1954 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Yakup BOZOOĞLU 01/01/1962 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Erdoğan GÜNGÖR 01/01/1961 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Ali BOZTAŞ 01/01/1933 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Saher ELMAS 01/01/1938 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Mazlum BOZTAŞ 01/01/1961 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Ahmet ELMAS 01/01/1955 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | İbrahim AĞGÜL 01/01/1968 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Zefi AĞGÜL 01/01/1926 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Kerem ELMAS 01/01/1964 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Haydar AKTAŞ 01/01/1932 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Aziz BOZOOĞLU 01/01/1956 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Aydın ELMAS 01/01/1965 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Abbas AĞGÜL 01/01/1970 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Nuray ELMAS 01/01/1973 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Emirali BOZOOĞLU 01/01/1958 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Yusuf KUL 01/01/1958 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Sabri KIRMIZITAŞ 20/03/1963 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
01/03/2011 | Rıza ARAT 02/06/1965 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
01/03/2011 | Süleyman YOM 01/01/1961 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
01/03/2011 | Rıza ÇUBUK 01/01/1952 Tunceli | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
10/08/2010 | Cemsi LAZIM 01/01/1962 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
26/05/2011 | İdris İLHANLI 01/01/1990 | Selahattin KAYA | ||
22/03/2011 | Demet AKKAYA 05/02/1971 Ankara Bülent AKKAYA 30/08/1959 Ankara Levent AKKAYA 30/09/1962 Ankara Perihan AKKAYA 06/05/1942 Ankara | Şengül BİRLEŞTİRİCİ | ||
15/02/2011 | Fatma YILDIZ 01/01/1962 Aydın | Şebnem TOKAT | ||
27/06/2011 | Jale MUSLUOĞLU 17/03/1929 Ankara Hüseyin ÜÇPINAR 01/03/1931 Muğla Makbule TİRELİ 12/03/1927 Muğla Hikmet Tülay ÜÇPINAR 04/06/1943 Muğla Mediha Ebru MERZİFONLU 09/05/1972 Muğla Levent ÜÇPINAR 13/09/1969 Balıkesir Ayşe ÜÇPINAR 30/06/1943 Muğla Ahmet ÜÇPINAR 01/01/1961 Muğla Aysu KINACI 26/04/1964 Muğla Şefika ÖZTÜRK 30/07/1940 Muğla Esat ÖZTÜRK 04/01/1971 Muğla Önder ÖZTÜRK 01/01/1962 Denizli Hasan KOCAGÖZ 01/01/1941 Denizli Bülent ÜÇPINAR 24/04/1963 Muğla | Serkan CENGİZ | ||
02/05/2011 | Nesrin KEÇE (KARABULUT) 20/01/1957 Ankara | Çağan Mehmet DAYANIR | ||
04/05/2011 | Sultan Melek TEKİN 03/03/1959 Ankara | Ali İhsan GÜZEL | ||
14/07/2011 | Fatma Şenay MERİÇ 27/07/1954 İstanbul | |||
26/07/2011 | 2C ENERJİ LTD. ŞTİ Ankara | Baran ÖZCAN | ||
29/08/2011 | Ergül YENİCE 15/05/1959 Kırıkkale | Nizamettin ÖZAYDIN | ||
27/09/2011 | Sabahattin Engin AKKAYA 20/08/1947 Bursa Gülbahar KARADENİZ 28/09/1942 Zonguldak Cemal ERTUĞ 01/01/1945 Zonguldak Ergün BODUR 22/02/1944 Zonguldak Ahmet BÜK 08/06/1967 Zonguldak Zeki YÜKSEL 08/11/1948 Zonguldak Mete ORHAN 07/11/1951 Bartın | |||
19/09/2011 | Havva AK 31/12/1972 Malatya | Kadir AKGÜNEŞ | ||
16/09/2011 | Ali ÇAPAL 06/04/1960 Istanbul | |||
07/10/2011 | Silva BENLİ 01/01/1955 Istanbul | Murat ÇELİK | ||
06/10/2011 | Yılmaz DOĞAN 01/01/1950 Istanbul | Murat ÇELİK | ||
05/10/2011 | Yunus KIBIK 05/06/1985 Istanbul | Mehmet AKBAŞ | ||
01/03/2011 | Dursun EMRE 03/04/1936 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
01/03/2011 | Ali ÖZTAŞ 18/03/1956 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
01/03/2011 | Şahsenem CİHAN 01/01/1923 Istanbul Ahmet CİHAN 01/01/1954 İstanbul Hanım ŞAHİN 01/01/1957 İstanbul Sakine ŞAHİN 01/01/1944 İstanbul Songül EMRE 01/01/1962 İstanbul Cevahir YAĞAN 01/01/1947 İstanbul Eylem ÖZTÜRK 01/01/1973 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | ||
17/01/2012 | Mustafa TÜRKOĞLU 25/03/1975 Samsun Havva TÜRKOĞLU 04/04/1944 Samsun Mustafa AKTAŞ 12/01/1964 Samsun Nuray AKTAŞ 15/09/1969 Samsun Refiye KARABABA 19/11/1970 Samsun | Fevzi Cem ŞENOCAK | ||
22/06/2011 | Ali Rıza YILDIRIM 02/02/1966 Istanbul | |||
27/12/2011 | Oya YILMAZ 12/06/1955 İzmir | Naciye CEYLAN | ||
03/01/2012 | Namık Kemal YILMAZ 16/08/1951 Mersin | Mustafa ERDOĞDU | ||
17/02/2012 | Ramazan TOPAL 13/09/1987 Şanlıurfa Filiz TOPAL 25/09/1989 Şanlıurfa Emine GÜLER 05/10/1984 Şanlıurfa Fatma GÜLER 08/01/1984 Şanlıurfa Aşhan DOKUMACI 01/01/1981 Şanlıurfa Hanım GÖÇER 20/01/1966 Şanlıurfa | Mustafa YAVUZ | ||
20/01/2012 | HİMAK ŞASİ ÜSTÜ SANAYİ VE TİCARET A.Ş. 05/06/1950 Istanbul | Eyüp ERASLAN | ||
20/01/2012 | HİMAK ŞASİ ÜSTÜ SANAYİ VE TİCARET A.Ş. 05/06/1950 Istanbul | Eyüp ERASLAN | ||
23/01/2012 | HİMAK ŞASİ ÜSTÜ SANAYİ VE TİCARET A.Ş. 05/06/1950 Istanbul HİDRO-MAK DAMPER VE HİDROLİK MAKİNALARI SAN. TİC. A.Ş. Istanbul | Eyüp ERASLAN | ||
04/01/2012 | Ahmet BOZKIR 01/06/01975 Batman | Mirhan ÖZBEKLİ | ||
16/03/2012 | Hacer ARIKAN 01/01/1966 Balıkesir | Hüseyin KARAKAŞ | ||
12/03/2012 | YEŞİL ANTALYA MÜFTÜ ARAZİSİ HİSSEDARLARI YAPI KOOPERATİFİ Antalya | Salih PINAR | ||
19/03/2012 | Dilber ÖZTÜRK 20/02/1974 İzmir | Nermin SELÇUK | ||
07/03/2012 | Kazım ÇAYAN 01/04/1948 Samsun Gülcan AYDIN 15/02/1981 Samsun Musa ÇAYAN 15/03/1985 Samsun Muammer ÇAYAN 02/04/1973 Samsun Muhammet ÇAYAN 02/04/1977 Samsun Rasime ÇAYAN 01/01/1949 Samsun Nazmiye ÇAYAN 10/04/1988 Samsun | Sezai DEMİRKAN | ||
04/05/2012 | Kadriye TURCAN 01/01/1946 Diyarbakır Halit GÖZEN 23/02/1946 Diyarbakır Fikri KASSAP 01/01/1965 Diyarbakır | Gülcan KARTAL | ||
06/04/2012 | Senar CAMCI 06/02/1960 Mersin Takyettin TAŞKIN 15/09/1981 Aydın | Hamdi TURGUT | ||
10/04/2012 | Süleyman Barış KÖROĞLU 07/09/1985 İstanbul | Ali YILDIZ | ||
05/04/2012 | Yusuf GÜN 03/08/1943 Batman Abdullah BAŞARAN 12/09/1935 Batman | Mehmet BAĞATIR | ||
21/03/2012 | Rasul KOCATÜRK 01/10/1965 Bolu Mehmet Aytunç ALTAY 08/06/1956 Kocaeli Mehmet Baha GÜVELOĞLU 01/01/1964 Kocaeli Mehmet GÜNEŞ 01/01/1951 Tekirdağ Hüseyin ATICI 01/01/1970 Istanbul Bülent BARMAKSIZ 06/01/1965 Istanbul Hüseyin TUT 28/01/1972 Kocaeli Bekir BALYEMEZ 01/01/1970 Ankara Önder ÇARKÇI 01/01/1973 Kocaeli Kamil YILDIZ 01/01/1965 Bülent GEDİK 01/01/1974 Kocaeli Tamer TUNCER 25/10/1971 Kocaeli Yüksel YİĞİTDOĞAN 22/07/1968 Kocaeli Mustafa YAŞAR 01/01/1959 Istanbul Murat TARI 01/01/1975 Giresun Mustafa DEMİRER 01/01/1966 İzmir M. Tarık DİRİK 01/01/1965 Adana Sevdağ YILMAZ 01/01/1967 Edirne Asude Şafak DİRİK 01/01/1972 Adana Hasan SEVİM 05/09/1954 Tunceli Hüsamettin ÖZDEM 01/01/1970 Ankara Bağdegül KOCATÜRK 01/01/1969 Istanbul | Gülizar TUNCER | ||
11/04/2012 | Erhan YETİK 13/05/1964 Istanbul | |||
13/04/2012 | Kemal ALKAN 10/04/1975 Istanbul Ömer ÇELİK 01/01/1963 Istanbul | Seyit Nusret ÖZTÜRK | ||
01/05/2012 | Mehmet DİKER 13/09/1945 Diyarbakır | Nalan BENER | ||
02/04/2012 | Ömer KURT 03/01/1979 Ankara | |||
29/05/2012 | Ayten ÇELİK 11/05/1959 İzmir | Berrin ALTIOK | ||
09/05/2012 | Necmettin AYDINLI 06/04/1955 Diyarbakır | Ümüt MİKE | ||
28/06/2012 | Fahrettin ESENDEMİR 14/08/1968 Istanbul | |||
28/05/2012 | Musa ÖZCAN 01/01/1981 Istanbul Nurten KORKUSUZ 14/12/1967 Istanbul Oğuzhan GÜNER 01/01/1972 Istanbul Hüseyin AKIN 05/02/1982 Istanbul Umut BİNBİR 01/01/1979 Istanbul Güler SALMAN 01/01/1979 Istanbul Sultan YENİGÜL 01/01/1981 Istanbul Seyhan KABADAYI 01/01/1979 Istanbul Nuray GÜNDÜZ 01/01/1980 Istanbul Aytaç DİNÇÇETİN 01/01/1975 Istanbul Hikmet KORKUSUZ 13/03/1962 Istanbul Özgür KABADAYI 04/09/1982 İstanbul Eray GERGİN 01/01/1980 Istanbul Mehmet YENİGÜL 01/01/1978 Istanbul Mesut BAYRAKTAR 01/01/1986 Istanbul | Suat EREN | ||
06/06/2012 | Ziya COŞKUN 10/11/1964 Adana | Buğra YEGÜL | ||
25/05/2012 | Nimet KÖŞE 01/01/1955 Diyarbakır Mehmet Sıddık KÖŞE 01/01/1946 Diyarbakır Mehmet Fesih KÖŞE 01/01/1970 Diyarbakır Mehmet YUKUŞ 01/01/1946 Diyarbakır Salih YUKUŞ 01/01/1950 Diyarbakır Servet KÖSE 01/01/1961 Diyarbakır Mehmet Şakir ORUÇLU 01/01/1951 Diyarbakır Mehmet Selim ÇİÇEK 01/01/1943 Diyarbakır Remzi YUKUŞ 01/01/1973 Diyarbakır Yahya ÇİÇEK 01/01/1943 Diyarbakır Abdurrahman YUKUŞ 01/01/1964 Diyarbakır Mehmet Şafii YUKUŞ 01/01/1966 Diyarbakır Ahmet YUKUŞ 01/01/1954 Diyarbakır | Mehmet Rauf ÇİÇEK | ||
24/05/2012 | Cuma PULGAT 01/01/1967 Diyarbakır | Zeki KARTAL | ||
03/05/2012 | Şeyhmus BAŞTUĞ 04/01/1976 Mardin Kemal BAŞTUĞ 05/08/1989 Mardin Şeyhdavut BAŞTUĞ 05/08/1989 Mardin Nezihe BAŞTUĞ 12/11/1973 Mardin Sultan BAŞTUĞ 01/01/1952 Mardin Tenzile BABUR 12/11/1970 Mardin Emine BAŞTUĞ 31/07/1993 Mardin Fatma BAŞTUĞ 31/07/1993 Mardin Halil BAŞTUĞ 25/07/1995 Mardin Sadiye BAŞTUĞ 04/04/1986 Mardin | Yahya TURAN | ||
19/07/2012 | Hatice DUMAN 05/04/1974 Gebze | Faruk Nafiz ERTEKİN | ||
27/06/2012 | Durdu Mehmet DALKANAT 01/01/1953 Kahramanmaraş | Ramazan Selçuk EREN | ||
30/05/2012 | Hasan TAPAN 01/03/1969 Şanlıurfa | |||
25/06/2012 | Gürkan KULAKOĞLU 15/10/1962 Aydın Faruk İŞÇEN 25/12/1957 Aydın Serpil ÖZÇELİK 08/03/1963 Aydın Eşref SARIBAŞ 01/04/1956 Aydın Bekir TİMUÇİN 14/02/1961 Aydın | Halit MORALIOĞLU | ||
24/07/2012 | Şükrü KARAHASANOĞLU 01/02/1947 Istanbul | Eyüp ERASLAN | ||
28/06/2012 | Gaye ONAN 04/02/1976 İzmir | |||
09/07/2012 | Nurhan KILIÇ 14/04/1974 Batman Nurhayat KILIÇ 05/01/1993 Batman | Mehmet Hakan TOY | ||
31/07/2012 | Yıldız OTO AĞCA 06/08/1954 Antalya | |||
09/07/2012 | Nüfer ŞEN 01/09/1963 Diyarbakır İhsan NARÇİÇEK 01/01/1963 Diyarbakır Mihdiye KOÇEROĞLU 01/01/1940 Diyarbakır Cemal KOÇEROĞLU 01/01/1963 Diyarbakır Keziban NARÇİÇEK 01/01/1963 Diyarbakır Şaban YEŞİL 01/01/1965 Diyarbakır İzzettin YEŞİL 01/01/1965 Diyarbakır Mehmet Şirin KOÇEROĞLU 01/01/1965 Diyarbakır | Zeki ÇELİK | ||
10/05/2012 | Songül ATLI 11/03/1966 Istanbul | |||
05/07/2012 | Mehmet Nuri ACAR 01/07/1971 Istanbul | Mehmet ERBİL | ||
28/06/2012 | Gülseven TUNCER 25/01/1936 İzmir Türkan BUHARALI 05/06/1934 Ankara Sevtap TUNCER 06/05/1966 İzmir Murat Hamdi TUNCER 26/02/1969 İzmir Mehtap KARAOSMANOĞLU 26/02/1969 İzmir | İclal İLİMOĞLU | ||
07/06/2011 | Aysel GÖLLER 12/04/1952 Istanbul Mustafa GÖLLER 28/03/1951 Istanbul | |||
08/08/2012 | Mehmet GÜL 20/04/1973 Diyarbakır | Ramazan DEMİR | ||
20/07/2012 | Filiz EYÜBOĞLU 01/01/1959 Istanbul | Boran ÇİÇEKLİ | ||
12/08/2012 | Orhan ERSOY 01/01/1959 Löhne | |||
02/07/2012 | Mustafa ÜNLÜSOY 01/02/1961 Istanbul | |||
23/07/2012 | Tuncay EREN 05/11/1981 Istanbul | Yücel GÖKTAŞ | ||
16/07/2012 | Mesher İBİŞ 11/11/1978 Istanbul | Yusuf Kenan ALTAN | ||
12/07/2012 | GAZİPAŞA TURİZM VE İNŞAAT TİCARET LİMİTED ŞİRKETİ Konya | Güner KUTLUK | ||
18/06/2012 | Mehmet Atilla ÖZMEN 01/01/1973 Samsun | Lütfi KESKİN | ||
18/06/2012 | Haluk ERTÜRK 13/10/1955 Aydın | Levent ERCAN | ||
20/07/2012 | Aydın YILDIZ 01/01/1972 Bursa | Tekin ÖZTÜRK | ||
24/07/2012 | Nedim ÇONKARA 20/03/1973 İzmir | Serkan CENGİZ | ||
24/07/2012 | Fazıl Zafer AYDOĞAN 02/12/1961 İzmir | Serkan CENGİZ | ||
24/07/2012 | Nuri TAŞBAŞ 15/01/1961 İzmir | Serkan CENGİZ | ||
10/09/2012 | Şeyhmus TURAN 01/01/1958 Ankara | Ömer Faruk SEVGİLİ | ||
17/09/2012 | Selim KESGİN 22/01/1972 Mersin | |||
13/08/2012 | Rıza AYDIN 01/01/1956 Adana | Kemal DERİN | ||
02/08/2012 | Yılmaz Can ÖZALP 01/01/1988 Istanbul | Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ | ||
06/08/2012 | Ali TÜRKMEN 22/02/1946 Samsun | Tuba Rana TÜRKMEN | ||
12/08/2012 | Mehmet KORKMAZ 10/09/1959 Mersin | Mustafa ERDOĞDU | ||
17/09/2012 | Sevil UYSAL 06/02/1967 Ankara | Kamer BEYAZTAŞ | ||
11/09/2012 | Mine ÖZGENLER YILMAZ 15/01/1969 Istanbul | Güneş TOSUN ÖZENSOY | ||
13/09/2012 | Ersoy TOSUN 27/12/1945 İzmir Muharrem TOSUN 19/02/1940 İzmir | Güneş TOSUN ÖZENSOY | ||
10/09/2012 | Aziz BOZYEL 24/05/1952 Ankara | Ömer Faruk SEVGİLİ | ||
10/09/2012 | Aleattin KAVİT 10/10/1977 Istanbul | Ömer Faruk SEVGİLİ | ||
15/08/2012 | Senem KANDİL 01/01/1945 Istanbul İbrahim KANDİL 01/01/1965 Istanbul Celal KANDİL 01/01/1970 Istanbul Ali İhsan KANDİL 01/01/1974 Istanbul Nazlı AKBULUT 01/01/1977 Istanbul Serdar KANDİL 01/01/1981 Istanbul | Kamil Tekin SÜREK | ||
23/09/2012 | Zehra YILMAZ 01/01/1962 Istanbul | Fazıl Ahmet TAMER | ||
08/08/2012 | Barış GEBOLOĞLU 02/02/1960 İzmir Müşerref DEMİR 01/02/1962 İzmir Layika EREN 02/02/1949 İzmir Hanım ATEŞ 02/03/1957 İzmir Fedile Hanım ATEŞ 26/01/1933 İzmir Ayşete KAYA 01/01/1950 İzmir | |||
07/08/2012 | Selim ŞAHİN 02/10/1950 Hakkari | Adnan DEMİRKAN | ||
22/08/2012 | Müjdat ŞENGÜLER 26/07/1952 Istanbul | Haluk PEKŞEN | ||
21/09/2012 | Ferhat ÖZDEMİR 01/01/1983 Istanbul | Gül ALTAY | ||
17/08/2012 | Mesut GÜL 20/06/1971 Tekirdağ | Taliphan KIYMAZ | ||
17/08/2012 | Elbey ERYILMAZ 23/08/1977 Tekirdağ | Taliphan KIYMAZ | ||
17/08/2012 | Cemal AKÇAY 12/01/1971 Tekirdağ | Taliphan KIYMAZ | ||
17/08/2012 | İsmail MACİT 20/02/1973 Tekirdağ | Taliphan KIYMAZ | ||
05/09/2012 | Ünsal ÖMER 29/07/1972 Nevşehir | |||
31/08/2012 | Ali ÇELEBİOĞLU 15/05/1942 Istanbul | |||
09/12/2011 | Cevher ÜREK 22/02/1952 Kocaeli | Elvan KARATAŞ | ||
24/08/2012 | Suna SELÇUK 10/10/1958 Istanbul Didem SELÇUK 15/09/1985 Istanbul Iraz SELÇUK 16/04/2006 Istanbul Filiz ERDEN (SELÇUK) 05/02/1988 Istanbul | Halit BOSTANCI | ||
28/08/2012 | Ali ÇELEBİOĞLU 15/05/1942 Istanbul | |||
15/08/2012 | Hasan TOR 01/01/1969 Aydın | Şebnem TOKAT | ||
13/08/2012 | Semire ERCAN 26/02/1980 Mardin Sarı KAYA 01/04/1965 Mardin Selima DEMİR 23/03/1982 Mardin Mehmet DEMİR 01/02/1974 Mardin Ali DEMİR 12/03/1987 Mardin Perihan DEMİR 12/03/1987 Mardin Halise AY 01/03/1981 Mardin Emine DEMİR 24/02/1955 Mardin Halise ASLAN 10/01/1962 Mardin Burca OĞUR 01/01/1965 Mardin Kifehi AKA 02/01/1977 Mardin Faysal DEMİR 25/02/1976 Mardin Fesih DEMİR 03/01/1979 Mardin Muzaffer DEMİR 01/02/1975 Mardin Hasine DEMİR 01/01/1941 Mardin | Yazgı ÇİMEN FİDAN | ||
07/09/2012 | Sadullah ARIK 16/07/1971 İzmir | Hanife YILDIRIM | ||
09/08/2012 | Orhan KESKİN 30/09/1974 Hakkari | Adnan DEMİRKAN | ||
10/09/2012 | Nilgün EKMEKÇİ İzmir Ayşe ÖKSÜZ 01/01/1950 İzmir | Özgür BİNGÖL | ||
25/07/2012 | Fulya Saliha ÜLÇEK KESENCİ 11/10/1977 Batman | Rahşan Bengi GEZGİN KAYAN | ||
23/03/2012 | Tarık ERKAN 31/05/1985 İzmir | Ahmet Sinan SÜRÜCÜ | ||
20/09/2012 | Bülent BARMAKSIZ 06/01/1965 Istanbul | Gülizar TUNCER | ||
20/09/2012 | Ali İhsan İŞİTMEZ 10/05/1981 Istanbul Orhan ÖZERLİ 01/01/1983 Istanbul | Gül ALTAY | ||
18/09/2012 | Mustafa Asım ÖZTÜRK 01/01/1946 Bodrum | |||
21/09/2012 | Perihan YÜKSEL 01/01/1939 Ankara | Bülent UTKU | ||
10/08/2012 | Mehmet Nafi AKGÜL 01/01/1960 Diyarbakır Hüseyin AKGÜL 05/04/1962 Diyarbakır Mehmet Şerif AKGÜL 01/01/1958 Hatay Mehmet Emin AKGÜL 01/01/1969 Istanbul Yılmaz AKGÜL 01/01/1980 Mardin Devran AKGÜL 24/01/1978 Mardin Sakine GÜNEŞ 01/07/1985 Mardin Zeynep GÜL 01/03/1982 Mardin Akisa YILDIZ 06/04/1964 Mardin Fati AKGÜL 01/02/1938 Mardin | Yahya TURAN | ||
21/08/2009 | Niyazi BULGAN 10/06/1963 Gaziantep | Ercan KANAR | ||
19/09/2012 | İnayet AKSU 20/12/1977 Istanbul | Barış ÇİLİNGİR |