Přehled
Rozhodnutí
SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 9977/08
Anıl KARADEMİR and others against Turkey
and 165 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 5 November 2013 as a Committee composed of:
Peer Lorenzen, President,
András Sajó,
Nebojša Vučinić, judges,
and Seçkin Erel, Acting Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the dates indicated in the annex,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
A. The circumstances of the cases
The facts of the cases, as submitted by the applicants whose names are listed in the appendix, may be summarised as follows.
On different dates, the applicants initiated actions before various courts or had civil, administrative or criminal proceedings brought against them. All proceedings lasted several years.
B. Relevant domestic law
A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in Müdür Turgut and others v. Turkey ((dec.), no 4860/09, §§ 19-26, 26 March 2013).
COMPLAINTS
The applicants complained under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention that the proceedings before the national courts had not been concluded within a reasonable time.
Some of the applicants raised other complaints, particularly under Articles 5, 6, 8, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol no. 1. These complaints are linked to the same proceedings which they complain about the excessive length.
THE LAW
I. JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS
The Court considers that, pursuant to Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal backgrounds.
II. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION
All the applicants complained that the length of the relevant proceedings before national tribunals were excessive and thus fell short of the requirements of Article 6 § 1, which provides:
“1. In the determination of his civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charge against him, everyone is entitled to a (...) hearing within a reasonable time (...) by a tribunal (...)”
The Court observes that the applicants considered the length of the proceedings in question to be incompatible with the requirement of “reasonable time” laid down in Article 6 § 1 of the Convention.
In that respect, the Court found in its decision Müdür Turgut and others (cited above, § 56) that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384, insofar as it is accessible and capable of offering reasonable prospects of redress for complaints concerning the length of proceedings, constituted a remedy which applicants were required to exhaust for the purposes of Article 35 § 1 of the Convention.
In the present cases, the Court sees no reason to come to a different conclusion.
It follows that these complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
III. OTHER ALLEGED VIOLATIONS OF THE CONVENTION
Relying on various Articles of the Convention or its Protocols, the applicants also presented some other complaints.
Having examined the applicants’ complaints in the light of all the material in its possession, and insofar as the matters complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that they do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.
It follows that these parts of the present applications are manifestly ill‑founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Seçkin Erel Peer Lorenzen
Acting Deputy Registrar President
Appendix
No | Application No | Lodged on | Applicant Date of birth Place of residence | Represented by |
9977/08 | 26/02/2008 | Anıl KARADEMİR 01/01/1971 Erzin Mehmet OCAK 01/01/1957 Hatay Mustafa GÖRGEL 01/01/1970 Hatay Alaaddin AYHAN 01/01/1970 Hatay Yusuf OCAK 01/01/1969 Hatay Vaysal ŞİMŞEK 01/01/1964 Hatay Lütfi DÖNMEZ 01/01/1964 Hatay Yılmaz KAYAR 01/01/1977 Hatay Bülent KAYAR 01/01/1974 Hatay Metin DİKİCİOĞLU 01/01/1963 Hatay Ahmet DAĞLI 01/01/1959 Hatay Bünyamin GÖKDOĞAN 01/01/1971 Hatay Bestami KAYA 01/01/1968 Hatay Ali KARACA 21/12/1962 Hatay Mehmet KELEŞ 01/01/1957 Hatay Hurşit AVCI 01/01/1967 Hatay Mustafa KAYA 01/01/1965 Hatay Turan ÜLGER 01/01/1962 Hatay Mehmet CİHAT 01/01/1966 Hatay Mehmet AVCI 01/01/1970 Hatay Cemal ARPAY 01/01/1960 Hatay Ali ÇAPAROGLU 01/01/1967 Hatay Murat OKUR 01/01/1972 Hatay Ercihan KAMBUR 01/01/1960 Hatay Abdullah AŞIK 01/01/1968 Hatay Halis KALI 01/01/1959 Hatay Ömer DURMUŞ 01/01/1971 Hatay Sedat ÇİNGİL 01/01/1972 Hatay Hayri GÜLMEN 01/01/1966 Hatay Bilal USTA 01/01/1963 Hatay Şemsettin LEK 01/01/1959 Hatay Metin REÇBER 01/01/1966 Hatay Selahattin ÖZASLAN 02/04/1966 Hatay Hasan ŞAHİN 01/01/1964 Hatay Hurşit ORMAN 01/01/1973 Hatay Osman KURT 01/01/1972 Hatay Reşit YIRTICI 01/01/1966 Hatay Ali KÜLTÜR 01/01/1974 Hatay Mehmet Şerif KOÇ 01/01/1966 Hatay Mustafa DEMİR 01/01/1970 Hatay Bedi USLU 01/01/1967 Hatay Kadir GÜNAY 01/01/1975 Hatay Cafer YEŞİL 01/01/1964 Hatay Yahya KÜRKÇÜ 01/01/1974 Hatay İshak NAL 01/01/1969 Hatay Erol GÖDEN 01/01/1966 Hatay Halil ŞİMŞEK 01/01/1965 Hatay Erdal UZGAŞ 01/01/1971 Hatay Necmettin BERKER 01/01/1961 Hatay Kazım TABAK 01/01/1963 Hatay Fadıl TEKELİ 01/01/1970 Hatay Kemal KARACA 01/01/1971 Hatay Şirzat GÜLLER 01/01/1961 Hatay Musa KILIÇASLAN 01/01/1969 Hatay Serdal KARTAL 01/01/1960 Hatay Kemal UZGAŞ 01/01/1967 Hatay Sami ORDULUOĞLU 01/01/1967 Hatay Hasan KIRAÇ 01/01/1967 Hatay Osman Nuri KINALI 01/01/1967 Hatay Hasan GAYIR 01/01/1965 Hatay Yılgör KORKMAZ 01/01/1960 Hatay | İsmail BAŞAR | |
17538/08 | 02/04/2008 | Hülya ERDEM 01/03/1965 Bursa | Günsel DEDE | |
43225/09 | 03/08/2009 | Mustafa GÜRBÜZ 16/04/1931 Ankara | Zehra GÜRBÜZ ÖNAL | |
48885/09 | 04/09/2009 | Özkan GÜNDÜZ 19/07/1981 İstanbul | ||
49129/09 | 02/09/2009 | Metin SAYGIN 05/07/1981 İstanbul Çelik HASAN 25/02/1982 İstanbul Şengül İLKAY 24/04/1984 İstanbul Nergis ÜMİT 24/10/1983 İstanbul | Kazım Erkut GÜZEL | |
52513/09 | 07/09/2009 | Necdet KUTOĞLU 02/06/1963 Zonguldak | ||
53791/09 | 29/05/2009 | Cemil AKKAYA 05/05/1964 Ankara | Gökçal Çetin EKŞİOĞLU | |
58474/09 | 23/10/2009 | Metin KONDAKÇI 04/04/1957 İstanbul | İsmail Deniz GÖKKILIÇ | |
58871/09 | 23/10/2009 | Nazım KULALI 12/06/1940 İstanbul | Hayati ŞAHİN | |
26981/10 | 26/04/2010 | Fikri ER 01/07/1977 Ankara | ||
26982/10 | 26/04/2010 | Fikri ER 01/07/1977 Ankara | ||
26983/10 | 26/04/2010 | Fikri ER 01/07/1977 Ankara | ||
26984/10 | 26/04/2010 | Fikri ER 01/07/1977 Ankara | ||
64890/10 | 09/10/2010 | Ahmet ÖZDEMİR 05/12/1946 Ankara ÖZLER YAPI İNŞAAT SANAYİ TİCARET LİMİTED ŞİRKETİ Muş | ||
4099/11 | 30/12/2010 | İsmail NAZLIOĞLU 03/12/1967 Edirne | ||
40463/11 | 29/03/2011 | İsa KAYA 01/06/1938 Şanlıurfa | Nabi ÖZALP | |
40532/11 | 28/03/2011 | Hakkı TALAŞLI 01/11/1974 Bitlis | Mehmet ERBİL | |
40627/11 | 03/03/2011 | Güner GÜNDÜZ 24/05/1952 Elazığ | Aziz DİNÇ | |
42177/11 | 05/07/2011 | İLKAY BALIKÇILIK TURİZM SANAYİ TİCARET A.Ş Diyarbakır | Zeki UÇAR | |
42194/11 | 11/01/2011 | Hasan DEMİREL 24/03/1943 Marmaris | Meral ÖNDERSEV | |
43267/11 | 09/06/2011 | Bayram BAYAR 05/05/1972 Antalya | ||
43444/11 | 09/07/2011 | Samime SANAY 21/10/1940 İstanbul | Mehmet Semih GEMALMAZ | |
43709/11 | 22/06/2011 | Hüsamettin GÖZÜAÇIK 24/02/1975 Antalya | Ayten ÜNAL | |
44640/11 | 27/06/2011 | Mustafa YILMAZ 15/02/1939 Antalya | ||
45859/11 | 24/05/2011 | Yusuf ÖZER 15/12/1963 İzmir | Cem ALTIPARMAK | |
45868/11 | 20/06/2011 | Ekrem YAMAL 02/11/0972 Diyarbakır | Arzu PAMUKÇU YÖRDEM | |
46281/11 | 17/06/2011 | Faik CEBEL 24/03/1969 İzmir | Mehmet Nur TERZİ | |
46710/11 | 29/06/2011 | Şadi BAYRAMOĞLU 10/07/1940 İstanbul | ||
46853/11 | 08/07/2011 | Mehmet Nesim KAR 01/01/1976 Şırnak Mehmet Zeki ERGİN 03/02/1977 Istanbul | Mirhan ÖZBEKLİ | |
47482/11 | 02/06/2011 | Necmi VAROL 01/01/1974 Şanlıurfa | Nabi ÖZALP | |
47574/11 | 20/06/2011 | Basri YERKAZAN 05/01/1938 Elazığ Feride KAVAKLI 01/07/1926 Elazığ Sabriye ULUCAN 01/07/1929 Elazığ Niyazi Nezir YERKAZAN 01/01/1944 Elazığ Semedin YERKAZAN 05/03/1950 Elazığ Halise YERKAZAN 18/03/1954 Elazığ Hane YERKAZAN 15/03/1975 Giresun Hasan YERKAZAN 05/03/1979 Erzurum | ||
47735/11 | 02/06/2011 | Cevat Ferruh KATRANCIGİL 01/01/1925 Istanbul | ||
47786/11 | 03/05/2011 | Raziye ERTEM 16/08/1970 Ankara | Tansu BATUR | |
47798/11 | 15/06/2011 | Fettah BİTİRGİÇ 03/12/1973 Kocaeli | ||
47930/11 | 25/04/2011 | Mehmet YILMAZ 01/01/1956 Diyarbakır | Mustafa Günşat AKSU | |
48171/11 | 02/07/2011 | Ahmet Nuri DEMİRSOY 03/07/1945 Kassel | Hakan ÜZENLİ | |
48257/11 | 02/06/2011 | Harun YILDIZKÜÇÜK 24/01/1962 Hatay | Maruf KAYMAZ | |
48284/11 | 20/12/2010 | Seyfi KARAARSLAN 13/07/1948 Zonguldak | Ergin KAYA | |
48391/11 | 13/05/2011 | Mahmut DELİ 09/12/1947 Antakya | Ali DAĞ | |
48593/11 | 02/05/2011 | Yusuf Vehbi OCAK 23/01/1955 Şanlıurfa Ali Rıza GERGER 01/12/1955 Şanlıurfa Ramazan UYAR 11/11/1968 Antalya | Müslüm Cengizhan AKALIN | |
48597/11 | 09/04/2011 | Radife SON 01/01/1961 Aydın | Şebnem TOKAT | |
48614/11 | 11/04/2011 | Özgür ŞAHİN 25/05/1971 Kocaeli | Kureyş BİLGİÇ | |
48616/11 | 10/01/2011 | Kerim TANIR 17/04/1955 Ulm | ||
48763/11 | 27/04/2011 | Şükrü KARAHASANOĞLU 01/02/1947 İstanbul | Eyüp ERASLAN | |
48943/11 | 22/03/2011 | Tekin KARAKÜLAH 22/02/1977 Aksaray | Beytullah COŞKUN | |
49023/11 | 08/04/2011 | İbrahim AYKAÇ 30/07/1959 Balıkesir | Şerif TOPUZ | |
49271/11 | 15/05/2011 | Kamuran MALGİL 15/06/1937 Istanbul Ahmet Cumhur MALGİL 29/10/1963 Istanbul Zekiye Gülnur DALKILIÇ 12/07/1967 Istanbul Sabiha ÇAM 05/03/1938 Istanbul Gülçin ÇAM 13/06/1968 Istanbul Neslihan ÇAM 08/08/1974 Istanbul | Hüseyin AYDIN | |
49330/11 | 12/05/2011 | Halil KUT 01/11/1943 Mardin Hüsnü KUT 01/01/1937 Mardin Ziver KUT 07/02/1959 Mardin Süleyman DEMİR 06/04/1964 Mardin Nezir KUT 14/02/1960 Mardin Suphiye METE 01/05/1948 İzmir Müşerref KAYA 18/02/1986 Mardin Şerafettin KUT 25/03/1980 Mardin Semire KARAKOYUN 01/01/1965 Adana Mizgin AKMEŞE 02/03/1976 Mardin Kasım KURT 25/10/1936 Mardin Hamdiye BAYSAL 01/01/1940 İzmir Ferhat KUT 01/03/1974 Mardin Şener KUT 10/07/1984 Mardin Mehmet Salih ALİOĞLU 03/12/1949 Mardin Fahriye ORAL 01/01/1953 Mersin Gülistan TAŞ 01/01/1980 Mardin Lema DENİZ 01/01/1966 Mardin Mustafa KUT 01/01/1976 Muğla Abdurrahim KUT 01/07/1966 Mardin Azat KUT 02/12/1975 Mardin Abdülselam KUT 01/02/1969 Mardin Nezehat KUT 01/05/1959 Mardin Yusuf KUT 01/01/1964 Mersin Pale KUT 01/01/1991 Mardin Mehmet Hatip KUT 25/08/1986 Mardin | Yazgı ÇİMEN FİDAN | |
49557/11 | 29/12/2010 | Halil LİMON 13/03/1938 Antalya Ayşe ŞEN 12/02/1940 Antalya Hatice BALAMAN 08/02/1944 Antalya Emine LİMON 10/01/1947 Antalya | Levent ERCAN | |
50186/11 | 08/06/2011 | Hasan ÖZÇELİK 07/08/1949 Ankara Hakkı Oğulcan ÖZÇELİK 05/10/1990 Ankara | Gökçal Çetin EKŞİOĞLU | |
50620/11 | 23/03/2011 | Şevket ERTÜRK 12/09/1938 Kocaeli | Saide ARSLAN ÇALIŞKAN | |
50678/11 | 08/07/2011 | Mehmet ÇALIŞKAN 12/11/1933 Aydın Mustafa GÜVENÇ 16/12/1931 Aydın | Serkan CENGİZ | |
51231/11 | 14/07/2011 | Mehmet DEVELİ 01/01/1989 Van | Kerem AKDOĞAN | |
51472/11 | 25/03/2011 | Sinan YILMAZ 14/10/1984 Istanbul | Nesrin KARAGÖZ KARATEPE | |
51500/11 | 04/04/2011 | Suat ÖZBAL 01/01/1965 İzmir | Türkan ASLAN | |
51512/11 | 03/05/2011 | Eyyüp EROL 01/01/1962 Mardin | Yılmaz FİDAN | |
51519/11 | 25/05/2011 | Hüseyin SEZEN 24/07/1968 Samsun | Mesut BEDİRHANOĞLU | |
51527/11 | 11/04/2011 | Mahfuz DEMİR 01/02/1959 Erzurum Celal DEMİR 19/03/1952 Erzurum Ahmet DEMİR 07/06/1956 Erzurum | Ömer KURT | |
51528/11 | 11/04/2011 | Mahfuz DEMİR 01/02/1959 Erzurum Celal DEMİR 19/03/1952 Erzurum Ahmet DEMİR 07/06/1956 Erzurum | Ömer KURT | |
51529/11 | 11/04/2011 | Mahfuz DEMİR 01/02/1959 Erzurum Celal DEMİR 19/03/1952 Erzurum Ahmet DEMİR 07/06/1956 Erzurum | Ömer KURT | |
51530/11 | 11/04/2011 | Mahfuz DEMİR 01/02/1959 Erzurum Celal DEMİR 19/03/1952 Erzurum Ahmet DEMİR 07/06/1956 Erzurum | Ömer KURT | |
52417/11 | 27/07/2011 | Köksal DENİZ 31/07/1965 Ankara | Haluk PEKŞEN | |
52418/11 | 27/07/2011 | Etem UZUNAY 15/03/1957 Istanbul | ||
52419/11 | 27/07/2011 | Şeref KOCAMAN 17/06/1960 Ankara | Haluk PEKŞEN | |
52745/11 | 13/07/2011 | Mehmet SAVCI Mardin Zeynep HAZAR Mardin Zübeyde SAVCI Mardin Zahra DÜZGÖREN Mardin Selahattin HAZAR Mardin Mustafa HAZAR Mardin Meryem KORHAN Mardin İbrahim SAVCI Mardin Mahsun HAZAR Mardin Hıdır SAVCI 10/08/1969 Mardin Fatma DÜZGÖREN Mardin Hatice TALAYHAN Mardin Fatma HAZAR Mardin Emine İLBOĞA Mardin Ayşe HAZAR 04/02/1964 Mardin Ahmet HAZAR Mardin Ahmet SAVCI Mardin Abdürrezak HAZAR 01/02/1963 Mardin Abdulvahit HAZAR Mardin Zeynep HAZAR Mardin | İnci Fidan AYDEMİR | |
52791/11 | 07/06/2011 | Fatih ÖZEL 01/01/1974 Adana | Hüseyin ÖZVEREN | |
53041/11 | 15/07/2011 | Şeyhmus AKSOY 03/03/1960 Derik Metin AKSOY 03/03/1974 Derik Reşat AKSOY 06/07/1944 Derik Bülent AKSOY 03/05/1974 Derik Yaşar AKSOY 05/02/1970 Derik Serdar AKSOY 20/10/1989 Derik Filiz AKSOY 01/06/1972 Derik Sinan AKSOY 20/01/1988 Derik | ||
53209/11 | 05/07/2011 | Candan KOZANLI 01/01/1965 Çanakkale | Ceyda AKKAŞ DEMİRCİ | |
53231/11 | 29/06/2011 | Hamza ÇİFTÇİ 01/01/1952 Aksaray | Beytullah COŞKUN | |
53257/11 | 08/06/2011 | Sevil ADA 23/03/1955 İstanbul | Faruk ÖKSÜZ | |
53820/11 | 20/05/2011 | ALTUNTAS KÖYÜ VE AŞAĞI KÖY MUHTARLIĞI Malatya | Mehmet GÖRGEÇ | |
54560/11 | 08/07/2011 | Yücel MANDACI 01/01/1940 Çanakkale | Hasan Erokay MANDACI | |
54786/11 | 19/08/2011 | Hasan Turan YETİM 13/02/1962 Istanbul | Eyüp ERASLAN | |
54793/11 | 06/07/2011 | Gökhan ARSLANTÜRK 29/09/1972 Ankara | Yılmaz İÇÖZ | |
54795/11 | 23/06/2011 | Abbas BAYIR 01/03/1965 Istanbul | ||
54796/11 | 20/06/2011 | Ahmet ÜÇEK 20/04/1978 Istanbul | Yusuf EYCAN | |
54801/11 | 15/07/2011 | Taner KANDEMİR 16/09/1949 Istanbul | Ömer ÖNEREN | |
55497/11 | 17/06/2011 | Osman AKTAŞ 10/04/1966 Sivas | Mirhan ÖZBEKLİ | |
55693/11 | 01/08/2011 | Serhat ŞAŞOĞLU 21/03/1961 İzmir | Sevgi DEMİRTAŞ | |
55879/11 | 30/06/2011 | Mustafa NAZLIER 26/09/1969 İzmir | İlkay PALA ÖGE | |
56164/11 | 12/05/2011 | Metin TUNCEL 08/04/1933 Istanbul | Eyüp ERASLAN | |
56995/11 | 12/07/2011 | Gülten DEMİRHAN 20/10/1954 Ankara | Z. Cem DEMİRHAN | |
57296/11 | 05/08/2011 | Selman AYDIN 01/01/1978 Istanbul | Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ | |
57471/11 | 01/07/2011 | Yusuf ÇİÇEK 11/05/1965 Viyana | Figen OPAK ÇİÇEK | |
57594/11 | 25/06/2011 | Tuncay KARAKAŞ 18/03/1975 Bursa | Nigar YILMAZ | |
57596/11 | 27/06/2011 | Salih BEKTAŞ 15/03/1960 Freudenstadt | ||
58011/11 | 05/08/2011 | Mehmet Ali ÇELİK 13/10/1977 Şanlıurfa | İlyas BARAN | |
58568/11 | 08/08/2011 | Vahit COŞAR 10/05/1964 Amasya | Makbule ÖZER ARPAĞ | |
58936/11 | 11/07/2011 | Ahmet EKİNCİ 12/02/1972 Diyarbakır | ||
58943/11 | 25/08/2011 | Özen NURAY 17/10/1960 Muğla | Selçuk KURT | |
59979/11 | 25/07/2011 | Salih ASLAN 05/04/1971 Şanlıurfa | İlyas BARAN | |
60059/11 | 22/07/2011 | Kerim CİCİ 21/05/1938 Bingöl | Mustafa ALPTEKİN | |
60558/11 | 24/08/2011 | Adnan HALİS 01/01/1952 Hendek Erol ARIKAN 01/01/1962 Gönen Esral KARAGÖZ 30/01/1961 Istanbul Fazıl Ahmet TAMER 11/08/1966 Istanbul Volkan KARTAL 01/01/1977 Istanbul Kemal TUFAN 01/01/1967 Istanbul Erol KAPLAN 01/01/1967 Istanbul Hikmet KALE 08/12/1970 Tekirdağ Mehmet ÇİFTÇİ 01/10/1952 Edirne Mehmet GÖKTAŞ 01/01/1966 Tunceli Mehmet BOZTEPE 01/01/1968 Malatya Hacı Aziz HUN 01/01/1965 Samsun Dinçer OTLUÇİMEN 01/01/1976 Istanbul Yılmaz YİĞİT 01/01/1976 Istanbul Bülent YİĞİT 01/01/1977 Istanbul Cem ŞAHİN 01/01/1976 Istanbul | Gülizar TUNCER | |
60943/11 | 14/09/2011 | Nuran ÖZDEMİR 01/10/1961 Ankara | Ömer ÜNLÜ | |
60986/11 | 07/06/2011 | Memnune KARAKULAK 04/01/1961 Istanbul | ||
61290/11 | 11/08/2011 | İmam AYDIN 01/01/1977 Istanbul | Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK | |
62408/11 | 27/07/2011 | İhsan KÖRPE 07/12/1986 Siirt | ||
62442/11 | 24/08/2011 | Özgür SAĞLAM 01/01/1981 Istanbul Cengiz KARAKAŞ 17/04/1978 Tekirdağ Vedat ÇELİK 01/01/1981 Istanbul | Several BALLIKAYA | |
62655/11 | 20/09/2011 | Atilla GÜRDER 02/01/1947 Ankara | İlhan BİÇER | |
63115/11 | 21/09/2011 | Babur Nuri KILIÇ 01/01/1960 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63129/11 | 21/09/2011 | Yücel KÜRKLÜ 01/01/1945 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63135/11 | 21/09/2011 | Didem ERGİN 21/07/1975 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63138/11 | 21/09/2011 | Gülgün TREN 14/06/1948 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63163/11 | 21/09/2011 | Abdülkadir SAĞER 28/02/1958 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63167/11 | 21/09/2011 | Nuriye ÖSER 03/02/1934 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63169/11 | 21/09/2011 | Ayfer Ahu ÇAKIR 25/12/1954 Ankara | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63173/11 | 21/09/2011 | Savaş Ahmet BUĞRA 11/01/1965 Amasra | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63176/11 | 21/09/2011 | Sevgi ILGAZ 27/12/1942 Eskişehir | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63186/11 | 21/09/2011 | Özcan EMEK 01/11/1944 Sakarya | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63190/11 | 29/08/2011 | Bircan KAYSUN 20/12/1965 Ankara Özcan GÜÇLÜ 24/05/1964 Ankara Gürcan GÜÇLÜ 22/03/1970 Ankara | Nevin ÖZKAN | |
63191/11 | 21/09/2011 | Timur Ahmet KILIÇ 01/01/1959 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63198/11 | 21/09/2011 | Cengiz Mehmet KILIÇ 01/01/1957 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63213/11 | 21/09/2011 | Saliha Solmaz ÖĞET 06/10/1931 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
68064/11 | 26/09/2011 | Bekir ARPA 10/03/1935 Diyarbakır | Fırat ÜGER | |
70415/11 | 04/10/2011 | Hakkı AKBAŞ 29/06/1966 İzmir | Yüksel KAVAK KILINÇ | |
72974/11 | 31/10/2011 | Ahmet ÇELEBİ 01/01/1945 Istanbul | Cem ALPTEKİN | |
74392/11 | 10/10/2011 | Ersin ÖZŞEN 04/05/1973 Istanbul | Haluk PEKŞEN | |
76763/11 | 23/11/2011 | Süleyman SARIBOĞA 01/08/1951 Aydın | Gül SÖZEN | |
7527/12 | 29/11/2011 | Nurettin BORAN 10/03/1962 Ankara | ||
9725/12 | 25/01/2012 | Ahmet BESER 12/05/1962 Istanbul Ahmet Ersin BAZMANOĞLU 17/08/1950 Istanbul HİDRO-MAK DAMPER VE HİDROLİK MAKİNALARI SAN. TİC. A.Ş. Istanbul | Eyüp ERASLAN | |
10037/12 | 23/12/2011 | Yıldız İMREK 15/11/1964 Istanbul | Semir KARADAŞ | |
10325/12 | 14/12/2011 | Aziz ÖZDEMİR 01/01/1957 Adana | Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU | |
13479/12 | 06/01/2012 | Melek ORHAN 15/06/1949 Muğla Şuayip ORHAN 11/11/1967 Muğla | Naciye CEYLAN | |
13714/12 | 13/02/2012 | Ahmet KIZIL 01/07/1941 Adıyaman | Mustafa YAVUZ | |
13730/12 | 27/01/2012 | Mustafa YILMAZ 30/03/1953 Sakarya | Nadir KURTDERE | |
14538/12 | 23/02/2012 | Necati ÇALIŞKAN 29/08/1959 İzmir | Barış KAŞKA | |
14539/12 | 23/02/2012 | Halime DALMIŞ 09/11/1964 İzmir | Barış KAŞKA | |
14540/12 | 23/02/2012 | Birsen ÜLKÜ 20/10/1969 İzmir | Barış KAŞKA | |
15079/12 | 24/01/2012 | Mehmet Nuri KARAKAYA 10/02/1976 Kırklareli | ||
16379/12 | 03/02/2012 | Mithat CABA 19/07/1954 Amasya | Kasım ER | |
16385/12 | 20/02/2012 | Süleyman ERDEM 01/01/1968 Istanbul | Baran DOĞAN | |
16439/12 | 10/02/2012 | Sabit DURMUŞ 10/07/1951 İskenderun | ||
16452/12 | 23/02/2012 | Ali Sait BULUT 09/08/1966 Istanbul | Şefik KARAKIŞ | |
16532/12 | 22/02/2012 | Fuat ÇETİNKAYA 01/01/1964 Şanlıurfa Fatma TAVAŞ 01/01/1966 Şanlıurfa Ayşe ÇETİNTAŞ 03/03/1981 Şanlıurfa Abdullah ÇETİNKAYA 02/04/1985 Şanlıurfa Hasan ÇETİNKAYA 01/04/1980 Şanlıurfa Osman ÇETİNKAYA 01/01/1959 Şanlıurfa Hüseyin ÇETİNKAYA 01/01/1978 Aydın Saliha ÇETİNKAYA 01/03/1940 Şanlıurfa Muhammet ÇETİNKAYA 10/01/1977 Şanlıurfa | Mustafa YAVUZ | |
16569/12 | 23/02/2012 | Bedriye AZEMOĞLU 22/02/1981 Şanlıurfa Şükran YILMAZER 22/02/1974 Şanlıurfa Hasan BALTACI 22/02/1979 Şanlıurfa Cengiz BALTACI 22/04/1973 Şanlıurfa Sedat BALTACI 22/02/1986 Şanlıurfa Kadriye YILDIZ 22/02/1977 Şanlıurfa | Mustafa YAVUZ | |
18143/12 | 16/02/2012 | Asiye FARAÇ 01/01/1971 Şanlıurfa Eyüp AVCI 01/07/1949 Şanlıurfa Ziya AVCI 01/01/1969 Şanlıurfa Binevş İNCE 02/03/1946 Şanlıurfa Mehmet AVCI 08/05/1947 Şanlıurfa Fatma AVCI 01/01/1945 Şanlıurfa Emine AKMAN 04/06/1953 Şanlıurfa | Mustafa YAVUZ | |
19659/12 | 09/06/2011 | Hikmet GAYIP 01/05/1965 Istanbul | ||
19747/12 | 07/06/2011 | Azmi GÜNGÖR 19/04/1960 Istanbul | ||
21064/12 | 22/02/2012 | Murtaza ANSEN 13/09/1951 İzmir | Kubilay İstemi ERGÜN | |
26141/12 | 06/04/2012 | Sebahattin YALÇIN 05/04/1967 Eskişehir | ||
27087/12 | 13/03/2012 | Fikret ESMEROĞLU 01/01/1948 Şanlıurfa | Lütfü POLAT | |
27348/12 | 30/03/2012 | Tahir Nafiz ÖZKUL 01/08/1949 Denizli | ||
27373/12 | 05/04/2012 | Arif ÖTLEŞ 21/05/1983 Ankara | Nuran ÖZDEMİR | |
29252/12 | 02/04/2012 | Bilal ÇETİNER 03/02/1974 Gümüşhane | ||
48753/12 | 03/06/2012 | Mehmet GÜNGÖR 01/01/1965 Şanlıurfa | Mehmet KIRBOĞA | |
49490/12 | 04/06/2012 | Sevil KARABURÇAK 10/03/1952 Muğla | ||
51150/12 | 14/06/2012 | Filiz GÜMELİ 06/06/1960 İzmir Sevim ÇAM (LAPÇİN) 04/07/1956 İzmir Günay TÜRK 15/03/1960 İzmir Turgay TÜRK 24/09/1958 İzmir | Güney DİNÇ | |
54588/12 | 18/06/2012 | Hamdi GÜNGÖR 01/05/1976 Manisa | Mustafa ROLLAS | |
56073/12 | 25/06/2012 | Hatice Semra BAŞTÜRK 03/08/1957 İzmir Havva Zülal KARATÜFEK 15/10/1955 İzmir Fatma Nihal ISPARTA 30/11/1964 İzmir | Sümeyra ÜNLÜ ÇELİK | |
56283/12 | 02/07/2012 | Halil GEÇKİL 01/01/1961 Şanlıurfa Ahmet GÜNGÖR 01/01/1962 Şanlıurfa Deham GÜNGÖR 01/01/1957 Şanlıurfa İsmail GEÇKİL 01/01/1962 Şanlıurfa | Mehmet KIRBOĞA | |
56761/12 | 16/07/2012 | Ziya KÖROĞLU 01/01/1967 Antalya | Bekir ASRİ | |
56922/12 | 11/06/2012 | Ayşan DEMİR 19/02/1962 Batman Fahrettin DEMİR 01/01/1978 Batman Abdurrahim DEMİR 01/10/1992 Batman Sibetullah DEMİR 01/01/1987 Batman Alaattin DEMİR 10/11/1979 Batman Muhittin DEMİR 25/09/1983 Batman Seyhan GÜZEL 01/01/1985 Batman Ceyhan DEMİR 01/01/1989 Batman Naif DEMİR 01/01/1960 Batman Bayram DEMİR 02/02/1962 Batman Rıfat DEMİR 15/04/1958 Batman | Mehmet Masum ERKEN | |
62289/12 | 30/07/2012 | Mustafa UÇAR 18/12/1950 Aydın | Adnan ÇUKUR | |
62535/12 | 18/11/2011 | Güler SÖYLEMEZ (YILMAZ) 01/01/1982 Istanbul | Gülizar TUNCER | |
62612/12 | 11/09/2012 | Osman GÖKDAL 01/01/1956 Mersin | Erdoğan ATA | |
63107/12 | 11/09/2012 | Fatma GÖREN 05/05/1927 Istanbul İlhan GÖREN 01/05/1954 Istanbul Zahide HASPOLAT 04/10/1949 Istanbul | Sedat HASPOLAT | |
65432/12 | 20/09/2012 | Yavuz BİLEN 01/06/1975 Istanbul | Osman SALMAN | |
66487/12 | 10/09/2012 | Atilla GÜRDER 02/01/1947 Ankara | İlhan BİÇER | |
66508/12 | 20/09/2012 | Halil ŞAHİN 01/01/1968 Sincan Cengiz KAHRAMAN 15/05/1974 Ankara Naki DEMİR 01/01/1981 Ankara Sedat OT 01/01/1975 Ankara Yaşar İNCE 01/01/1972 Ankara Deniz TEPELİ 01/01/1977 Ankara | Hakan KARAKUŞ | |
66603/12 | 01/09/2012 | Sabri TOLUAY 05/04/1928 Bingöl | Türkan KIRMIZITAŞ | |
67044/12 | 21/09/2012 | Hasan ÖZGE 10/11/1974 Aydın | Ece SOLMAZ | |
75633/12 | 21/09/2012 | Bülent ÇAN 21/09/1980 Istanbul | Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ | |
75761/12 | 21/09/2012 | Mehmet Reşit AKAR 01/01/1975 Istanbul | Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ | |
77609/12 | 09/09/2012 | Ahmet ERCİYAŞ 01/01/1961 Diyarbakır | Gülcan KARTAL | |
32/13 | 09/11/2012 | Yanık SATILMIŞ 08/04/1974 Zonguldak | ||
21323/13 | 15/03/2013 | Şahin ŞAMDAN 01/09/1975 Kocaeli | Saide ARSLAN ÇALIŞKAN |