Přehled
Rozhodnutí
SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 62696/11
Ebru SARIKAYA ÖZCAN against Turkey
and 138 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 15 October 2013 as a Committee composed of:
Peer Lorenzen, President,
András Sajó,
Nebojša Vučinić, judges,
and, Seçkin Erel, Acting Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the dates indicated in the annex,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
A. The circumstances of the cases
The facts of the cases, as submitted by the applicants whose names are listed in the appendix, may be summarised as follows.
On different dates, the applicants initiated actions before various courts or had civil, administrative or criminal proceedings brought against them. All proceedings lasted several years.
B. Relevant domestic law
A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in Müdür Turgut and others v. Turkey ((dec.), no 4860/09, §§ 19-26, 26 March 2013).
COMPLAINTS
The applicants complained under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention that the proceedings before the national courts had not been concluded within a reasonable time.
Some of the applicants raised other complaints, particularly under Articles 6, 8, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1. These complaints are linked to the same proceedings in which they complain about the excessive length.
THE LAW
I. JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS
The Court considers that, pursuant to Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal backgrounds.
II. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION
All the applicants complained that the length of the relevant proceedings before national tribunals were excessive and thus fell short of the requirements of Article 6 § 1, which provides:
“1. In the determination of his civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charge against him, everyone is entitled to a (...) hearing within a reasonable time (...) by a tribunal (...)”
The Court observes that the applicants considered the length of the proceedings in question to be incompatible with the requirement of “reasonable time” laid down in Article 6 § 1 of the Convention.
In that respect, the Court found in its decision Müdür Turgut and others (cited above, § 56) that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384, insofar as it is accessible and capable of offering reasonable prospects of redress for complaints concerning the length of proceedings, constituted a remedy which applicants were required to exhaust for the purposes of Article 35 § 1 of the Convention.
In the present cases, the Court sees no reason to come to a different conclusion.
It follows that these complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
III. OTHER ALLEGED VIOLATIONS OF THE CONVENTION
Relying on various Articles of the Convention or its Protocols, the applicants also presented some other complaints.
Having examined the applicants’ complaints in the light of all the material in its possession, and insofar as the matters complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that they do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.
It follows that these parts of the present applications are manifestly ill‑founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Seçkin Erel Peer Lorenzen
Acting Deputy Registrar President
No | Application No | Lodged on | Applicant Date of birth Place of residence | Represented by |
62696/11 | 16/09/2011 | Ebru SARIKAYA ÖZCAN 28/04/1974 Ankara | Özgür ORUN | |
63216/11 | 21/09/2011 | Atilla Fuat İNCE 01/01/1966 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63221/11 | 21/09/2011 | M. Hulisi TÜRKER 01/01/1958 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63227/11 | 21/09/2011 | Gonca RODMAN 01/01/1963 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63232/11 | 21/09/2011 | Nejla KÖKER 01/01/1963 Ankara | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63235/11 | 21/09/2011 | Ayşe Dilek ÜLGÜRAY 08/04/1943 Ankara | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63242/11 | 21/09/2011 | Zehra Sevim İNCEOĞLU 30/09/1931 Ankara | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63250/11 | 21/09/2011 | Oya ERKEK 01/01/1963 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63257/11 | 21/09/2011 | Metin TUNCEL 01/01/1968 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
63263/11 | 21/09/2011 | Sevim ÇALAPVERDİ 04/09/1950 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
64683/11 | 21/09/2011 | Mehmet Feza MORAMOLLU 29/03/1955 Kocaeli Halil EZİCİ 01/01/1972 Istanbul Risalet DEMİRCİOĞLU Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
64694/11 | 21/09/2011 | Ruhsar Ergün TOKER 01/01/1931 Ankara İbrahim BEKİN 19/03/1968 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
64831/11 | 22/06/2011 | Behçet ÖZBEK 01/01/1936 Mersin | Yahya TURAN | |
64887/11 | 04/07/2011 | Ayhan SAYAN 01/01/1946 Istanbul | Özgür AŞIK | |
65159/11 | 25/07/2011 | Cavit SİVRİHİSAR 23/11/1960 Ankara | Fikriye Leyla EVCİMEN | |
65278/11 | 20/09/2011 | Ömer Nusret BOZKURT 09/01/1968 Marmaris | Yamaç KAYA | |
65438/11 | 06/10/2011 | Cahit DALAK 10/11/1958 Kayseri | Haluk PEKŞEN | |
65525/11 | 21/09/2011 | Sezgin AGUN 20/05/1939 Istanbul Nebahat TATAR 07/06/1946 Istanbul | Ergin CİNMEN | |
65549/11 | 21/09/2011 | Tuna Tufan BACANAK 28/04/1972 Amasra Hamiye BACANAK 01/01/1938 Amasra | Ergin CİNMEN | |
66318/11 | 27/09/2011 | Hüseyin ALMAZ 28/09/1981 Adana | Kemal DERİN | |
66326/11 | 13/09/2011 | Nusret SÖNMEZ 29/06/1983 Diyarbakır | ||
66892/11 | 17/09/2011 | Sinan TÖKÜ 27/04/1978 Kocaeli | Mehmet ERBİL | |
67567/11 | 03/10/2011 | ÖZSA İNŞAAT TAAHHÜT TURİZM SANAYİ VE TİCARET LİMİTED ŞİRKETİ Aydın | Burcu BEKEMLER KUTLUKAYA | |
67656/11 | 08/09/2011 | Mesut ÇELİK 15/09/1978 Bursa Mediha ÖZGÜR 12/06/1974 Bursa | E. Hakan ÖZDEMİR | |
68703/11 | 08/09/2011 | Ali İhsan KILIÇ 25/11/1972 Istanbul | ||
68783/11 | 06/10/2011 | Osman AKTAŞ 10/04/1966 Sivas | ||
69508/11 | 29/09/2011 | Cavit SÜMER 01/01/1934 Rize Orhan SÜMER 01/01/1956 Rize Münevver GENÇ 01/01/1937 Rize Kadriye SÜMER 01/01/1938 Rize Muazzez UZUN 01/01/1946 Rize Mustafa SÜMER 01/01/1932 Rize Ertürk SÜMER 26/04/1960 Rotterdam Hüsamettin SÜMER 01/01/1950 Seyhan Hüsniye ŞİRİN 01/01/1921 Rize Dursune SÜMER 01/01/1956 Rize Hamiyet KUTLUATA 01/01/1951 Aydın Selamettin SÜMER 18/01/1953 Istanbul Nezaket SÜMER 01/01/1959 Rize Neylan MENGÜ 19/07/1955 Istanbul Emine SÜMER 10/01/1953 Rize Sibel SÜMER 11/06/1985 Istanbul Arslan SÜMER 01/01/1932 Karabük Özgür SÜMER 01/01/1970 Antalya Nuran SÜMER 01/01/1948 Antalya Sertan SÜMER 01/01/1980 Istanbul Hatice SÜMER 20/05/1933 Istanbul Mehpare SÜMER 09/12/1957 Istanbul Timur SÜMER 01/01/1951 Rize Emine SÜMER 01/01/1930 Rize Ragıp SÜMER 02/02/1939 Ankara Şükrü ORUÇ 17/05/1985 İzmit Şeyda ORUÇ 01/06/1984 İzmit Seda ORUÇ 01/06/1984 İzmit Mustafa Hikmet SÜMER 01/01/1932 Rize Serkan SÜMER 18/02/1977 Bodrum Şemseddin SÜMER 25/01/1940 Istanbul Ali Fuat SÜMER 20/02/1934 Istanbul Fevzi SÜMER 23/03/1955 Istanbul Fevzi SÜMER 01/01/1930 Rize İzzet SÜMER 01/01/1933 Rize Şeref SÜMER 01/01/1963 Rize | Rıfat ULUŞAHİN | |
71574/11 | 10/10/2011 | SINIRLI SORUMLU HIRA NUR KONUT YAPI KOOPERATİFİ Istanbul | Necip KİBAR | |
72035/11 | 17/10/2011 | Mehmet KARABULUT 01/02/1963 Muş Sıddık ASYA 01/05/1933 Muş Enver GÜRBÜZ 01/03/1970 Muş Abdülvahap BARLIK 10/04/1966 Istanbul Seyit Ali YENİCİ 12/11/1954 İzmir Şeyhmus SEVİMLİ 01/01/1969 Muş Bahattin ESEN 26/12/1961 Muş Mehmet Can MAMİŞ 01/01/1972 Bursa Hamdullah BAĞATOR 01/02/1953 Muş Kazım KARTAL 01/02/1966 Muş | Hikmet AYDIN | |
72774/11 | 21/10/2011 | Raziye KORONCU 30/11/1945 Istanbul | ||
72808/11 | 04/11/2011 | Walter Ferdinand Otto MEEWIS 10/03/1944 İzmir | Derya BAYSAL KARAYÜKSEL | |
72812/11 | 04/11/2011 | Evren HACICİHANGİROĞLU 18/01/1981 Hakkari | Mehmet Zahir KIZILAY | |
73618/11 | 15/08/2011 | Azimet CEYHAN 01/07/1970 Istanbul | Tanzer GÜVEN | |
74145/11 | 20/10/2011 | Zahide AK 01/01/1961 Tekirdağ | Sevim AKAT EŞKİ | |
74160/11 | 13/10/2011 | Muhammet Ali ÜREK 16/02/1975 İstanbul | Haluk PEKŞEN | |
74588/11 | 13/10/2011 | Zeki Hakan BURU 10/04/1971 Istanbul | Haluk PEKŞEN | |
74723/11 | 07/10/2011 | Necla GÜROL 01/10/1938 İzmir | Tanju NALKIRAN | |
74743/11 | 10/10/2011 | Halime AKDAĞ 01/01/1944 Şanlıurfa Abdurrezzak AKDAĞ 01/01/1960 Şanlıurfa | Nabi ÖZALP | |
74810/11 | 10/10/2011 | Ufuk ALKAN 23/11/1951 Ankara | ||
76095/11 | 02/11/2011 | Mahmut AİŞEOĞLU 01/01/1965 Şanlıurfa | Mahmut KAYA | |
76638/11 | 29/11/2011 | Huri GÜMÜŞAY 05/06/1950 Istanbul | Eyüp ERASLAN | |
76961/11 | 13/10/2011 | İsmet SARICI 01/01/1948 İzmir | ||
77222/11 | 15/11/2011 | Cavit KAHRAMAN 01/04/1950 Diyarbakır Hasan Mete KAHRAMAN 01/10/1971 Diyarbakır İhsan KAHRAMAN 15/06/1954 Diyarbakır İrfan KAHRAMAN 02/03/1962 Diyarbakır Mehmet Yavuz KAHRAMAN 20/12/1964 Diyarbakır Hüsna KAHRAMAN 01/01/1930 Diyarbakır Filiz KAHRAMAN 14/11/1967 Diyarbakır | Hayrettin GÜZEL | |
78357/11 | 08/09/2011 | Aytekin ÇETİN 20/12/1979 Bursa | E. Hakan ÖZDEMİR | |
78871/11 | 24/11/2011 | Fehmi KARAMAN 18/09/1983 Tekirdağ Erdener DEMİREL 21/11/1980 Tekirdağ Cengiz KARA 01/05/1977 Kandıra | Yasemin FİLORİNALI | |
78971/11 | 15/09/2011 | Naci ÜNAL 01/01/1969 Van | Gönül ÜLGEN | |
1323/12 | 21/12/2011 | İbrahim YILDIRIM 01/01/1933 Şanlıurfa Ramazan AY 01/07/1932 Şanlıurfa Mahmut KORKMAZ 01/01/1955 Şanlıurfa | Fatma Zehra EJDER | |
1977/12 | 04/11/2011 | Mevlüt GENÇ 01/01/1952 Çanakkale | Aytekin GÜNDÜZ | |
1978/12 | 04/11/2011 | Rüstem ATEŞ 01/01/1969 Samsun | Aytekin GÜNDÜZ | |
1979/12 | 04/11/2011 | Kadir GENÇ 01/01/1966 İstanbul | Aytekin GÜNDÜZ | |
1980/12 | 04/11/2011 | Teslime ŞİMŞEK (YILMAZ) 01/01/1926 Samsun | Aytekin GÜNDÜZ | |
2226/12 | 30/11/2011 | Abidin DEMİREL 01/01/1955 Marmaris Ali DEMİREL 30/05/1953 Marmaris Alaettin DEMİREL 06/05/1958 Marmaris Sabahaddin DEMİREL 05/12/1960 Marmaris | Meral ÖNDERSEV | |
2234/12 | 30/11/2011 | Zafet KORKMAZ 20/03/1964 Marmaris Halil KORKMAZ 16/05/1957 Marmaris | Meral ÖNDERSEV | |
2248/12 | 30/11/2011 | Mehmet Ali ÇELİK 03/10/1932 Marmaris | Meral ÖNDERSEV | |
2311/12 | 14/12/2011 | Fatih KALDIRIM 20/05/1960 Ankara | Murat KALDIRIM | |
2330/12 | 12/12/2011 | Kadir ŞENOL 05/09/1968 Bingöl | Aykanat KAÇMAZ | |
2370/12 | 09/12/2011 | Hüseyin AYDIN 01/12/1960 Istanbul | Burhan KIZILGEDİK | |
2670/12 | 12/12/2011 | Zafer BİÇER 11/02/1975 Tekirdağ | Aykanat KAÇMAZ | |
4109/12 | 12/01/2012 | Makbule YAMAK 01/03/1956 Trabzon | Buğra YEGÜL | |
4114/12 | 12/01/2012 | Abdullah GÜRDER 04/07/1945 Istanbul Neslihan GÜRDER 24/08/1977 Istanbul | İlhan BİÇER | |
4122/12 | 12/01/2012 | Tunay KARADELİ 28/02/1979 Ankara | Buğra YEGÜL | |
4567/12 | 16/12/2011 | Murat OZAN 01/01/1955 Tunceli | Enver Erdal ŞİMŞEK | |
4799/12 | 12/12/2011 | Gökhan TİMOÇİN 01/01/1982 Kassel | Ümit TİMOÇİN | |
5324/12 | 13/12/2011 | Mustafa KAYA 10/12/1947 Nevşehir | Yusuf AKBAŞ | |
5938/12 | 06/12/2011 | Mehmet Cemil GÜLAL 01/01/1933 İzmir Kadir ÇOBAN 10/03/1936 İzmir Saadet OPAN 03/06/1967 İzmir Tevfik ÖZER 10/03/1937 İzmir Saime TAŞDEMİR 01/02/1943 İzmir İrfan ÇAKIR 15/08/1934 İzmir İsmail Hakkı PAKCAN 01/07/1922 İzmir Yusuf KIRILMAZ 12/12/1955 İzmir Musa DURAN 20/02/1947 İzmir Hasan ADIKTI 08/04/1939 İzmir Şahin BAŞOL 18/11/1952 İzmir Hasan YAMAN 11/10/1949 İzmir Mustafa YALÇIN 08/04/1939 İzmir Mehmet YAĞCI 01/01/1954 İzmir İsmail ÖZKAN 13/05/1935 İzmir | Sümeyra ÜNLÜ ÇELİK | |
6006/12 | 16/11/2011 | Fatma Nigar DEMİRSOY 09/11/1926 Üsküdar | Murat EFE | |
6230/12 | 21/12/2011 | Murat ÜLKÜ 22/08/1972 İzmir | Adnan TERECE | |
6239/12 | 02/12/2011 | K.SHIPS INC. İzmir | Şevket KÜÇÜKÇELEBİ | |
6958/12 | 05/10/2011 | Talat SÜREK 26/08/1938 Ankara Ali SÜREK 25/08/1936 Istanbul Perihan SÜREK 01/01/1935 Gelibolu | Bülent İLGÜ | |
7052/12 | 25/11/2011 | Mehmet ÇOKTAN 15/04/1960 Istanbul | ||
7964/12 | 04/01/2012 | Leyla AKYILDIZ 06/09/1988 Istanbul | Mehmet ERBİL | |
8001/12 | 26/01/2012 | Nazan AKYOL 01/03/1954 Ankara | Devrim Özgür AKYOL | |
8808/12 | 30/11/2011 | Canan TANGÜN 19/01/1947 Istanbul | Melek Neslihan ÖZFİDAN | |
8851/12 | 25/11/2011 | Jale YAMAN 09/07/1971 Yalova | ||
8898/12 | 24/01/2012 | Bülent ÇITACI 08/11/1973 Niğde Şirin AYDIN 01/01/1974 Niğde Ersin GÜNTUT 01/08/1978 Niğde Nuri GÖKKAYA 26/05/1973 Niğde Adem GÜNER 28/02/1969 Niğde Nazmi BOZKIR 08/11/1982 Niğde Cuma KOÇ 20/07/1976 Niğde Kazım ÖZÜN 26/03/1974 Niğde Ramazan GÜNGÖR 20/02/1972 Niğde Mehmet Ali GÜNEŞ 11/08/1971 Niğde Levent AKTAŞ 04/08/1977 Ankara | Mustafa ÇİNKILIÇ | |
8930/12 | 24/01/2012 | Bayram GÜNDOĞDU 01/01/1965 Niğde Cafer DEMİR 15/02/1974 Niğde Nizamettin BOSTAN 25/12/1963 Niğde Şuayip ESEN 20/07/1976 Adana Emin DAŞDEMİR 15/04/1963 Niğde Bülent AKGÖZ 04/09/1978 Niğde Zaim Zaimoğlu BOZDAĞ 23/02/1975 Niğde Mustafa KINA 05/01/1971 Niğde Doğan YILDIZ 15/04/1972 Niğde Hacı Ali BEYRET 06/02/1976 Niğde Sebahattin KAYMAZ 06/04/1973 Niğde | Mustafa ÇİNKILIÇ | |
9336/12 | 02/02/2012 | Emin KARTAL 20/03/1953 Düzce | Fazıl Ahmet TAMER | |
9902/12 | 22/12/2011 | Gürsel AYDINLI 01/01/1966 Muş | Hasan GENÇ | |
9904/12 | 22/12/2011 | Metin AKSOY 01/01/1969 Van | Abdulmenaf KIRAN | |
10056/12 | 03/02/2012 | Nejmi KAYA 19/01/1961 Aydın | Halit MORALIOĞLU | |
10674/12 | 27/12/2011 | Erhan TİPİ 12/01/1953 Istanbul | ||
11999/12 | 05/12/2011 | Recep ZEYDAN 17/03/1953 Ankara | Saim BOZKURT | |
12058/12 | 28/12/2011 | Mehmet ÖZDEMİR 10/09/1943 Mersin | Ahmet BIYIKLI | |
13288/12 | 03/03/2012 | Aysun TEZCAN 20/10/1963 Ankara | Saliha SAVAŞKAN | |
13732/12 | 30/01/2012 | Yusuf AYDIN 03/07/1942 Sivas | Şefik KARAKIŞ | |
14676/12 | 04/02/2012 | Kamil GÜNEYLİ | Adil AKTAY | |
16940/12 | 13/02/2012 | Müyesser GÖLCÜK 27/09/1934 İzmir Selahattin VARDAR 15/05/1944 Buca Mustafa Yücel SEVER 18/09/1951 İzmir | Sümeyra ÜNLÜ ÇELİK | |
19606/12 | 02/12/2011 | Hakan TEZEL 14/01/1969 İzmir | ||
19610/12 | 26/12/2011 | Hakan TEZEL 14/01/1969 İzmir | ||
19755/12 | 30/12/2011 | İbrahim SERİNDAĞ 05/10/1963 Istanbul | Kamber SOYPAK | |
27278/12 | 04/04/2012 | Neslin Çağlar KILINÇ 10/07/1983 Istanbul | Havva Hülya DEVECİ | |
32792/12 | 13/02/2012 | Mustafa KUZU 01/02/1945 Çorum | Ertuğrul GÖKEŞME | |
32925/12 | 10/04/2012 | Mehmet ARSLAN 17/12/1977 Şanlıurfa | Mustafa YAVUZ | |
33063/12 | 09/04/2012 | Azime ALEVCAN 11/02/1962 Istanbul Meryem EKİNCİ 01/07/1981 Istanbul Gülüstan CAM 22/07/1989 Istanbul Reyhan GÜNLEMİŞ 01/12/1986 Istanbul Perihan GÜLTEPE 01/12/1986 Istanbul Ömer ALEVCAN 07/09/1994 Istanbul Ali ALEVCAN 01/08/1991 Istanbul | Niyazi BULGAN | |
33947/12 | 19/04/2012 | Mehmet KOCA 05/05/1964 Bursa | Oktay ÖNAL | |
34157/12 | 30/03/2012 | Tuğrul Bilen ÜNAL 30/06/1945 Istanbul | ||
39589/12 | 10/05/2012 | Atilla DOĞAN Istanbul | ||
39641/12 | 23/05/2012 | Mahmut Serdar USTAOĞLU 20/09/1963 Ankara | Türkay ASMA | |
39818/12 | 24/04/2012 | Halil Barış ÇAKAR 08/09/1974 İzmir | Suat AYDINER | |
43811/12 | 25/03/2011 | Emrah Suphi SAÇILANATEŞ 07/04/1978 Ankara | Tahsin Oktay DOĞAN | |
44968/12 | 14/05/2012 | Vahide KAFADAR 15/09/1960 Bilecik | ||
46051/12 | 24/04/2012 | Serdar ESMEK 19/06/1976 Adana | ||
47911/12 | 09/05/2012 | Mustafa ZEYBEK 01/01/1949 Muğla | Necmettin YANKOL | |
48522/12 | 07/05/2012 | Yıldız ÇAKMAK 15/03/1963 Aydın Ayşe ALTINTAŞ 15/10/1959 Muğla Dudu ÖZKAN 25/01/1962 Aydın Aysel KARA 10/09/1962 Aydın | Mustafa İŞERİ | |
48976/12 | 23/05/2012 | Hüsni BAĞTAŞ 01/01/1955 Van | Hamdi TURGUT | |
52483/12 | 11/05/2012 | Harun KARAKAŞ 16/02/1977 Istanbul | ||
52642/12 | 31/07/2012 | Mehmet Emin SABAZ 28/07/1976 Tokat | ||
55331/12 | 06/07/2012 | Heval AYSELİ 01/01/1984 Istanbul | Mehmet Sani KIZILKAYA | |
55365/12 | 05/07/2012 | Mustafa BALDAZ 27/03/1974 Istanbul | İlhami SAYAN | |
57107/12 | 28/06/2012 | Remzi KILIÇ 05/07/1960 Bursa Zehra KILIÇ 22/02/1998 Bursa Fatih KILIÇ 22/04/1991 Bursa Hüseyin KILIÇ 22/02/1998 Bursa Ufuk KILIÇ 25/04/1986 Bursa | Tekin ÖZTÜRK | |
58984/12 | 25/06/2012 | Karip YILDIRIM 04/04/1946 Kocaeli Huriye Hülya YILDIRIM 01/01/1948 | Murat ŞAHISTAN | |
59566/12 | 11/06/2012 | Burhan KAFALI 02/04/1968 Kocaeli | Saide ARSLAN ÇALIŞKAN | |
59572/12 | 13/06/2012 | Şahap EMİR 01/01/1952 Istanbul ELTEKS ELAZIĞ ENTEGRE TEKSTİL SAN. VE TİCARET A.Ş Istanbul | Kemal POLAT | |
60864/12 | 24/07/2012 | İbrahim ÖREN 10/08/1969 İzmir | Serkan CENGİZ | |
62490/12 | 26/07/2012 | Mahmut YILMAZ 01/01/1957 Trabzon Mehmet YILMAZ 01/01/1977 Trabzon | ||
62919/12 | 07/08/2012 | Bayezit ÖĞÜTVEREN 07/01/1957 Istanbul | ||
63829/12 | 25/07/2012 | Muharrem DOĞRU 01/01/1989 Istanbul | Yusuf Kenan ALTAN | |
63869/12 | 31/07/2012 | Ercan ÖZCAN 18/11/1975 Iğdır | ||
63915/12 | 07/08/2012 | Mustafa TAŞKALE 04/09/1964 Tunceli | Yıldız İMREK | |
69904/12 | 16/08/2012 | Eyyup HOŞGÖR 26/01/1954 Lüleburgaz | İlhan DURMUŞ | |
71598/12 | 20/09/2012 | Seyithan AKYÜZ 01/05/1981 İzmir | Reyhan YALÇINDAĞ BAYDEMİR | |
73491/12 | 08/09/2012 | Doğan IŞIK 20/08/1956 Istanbul Hüseyin Hami Şakir ÖZSOMAR 08/08/1958 Istanbul | Metin FİLORİNALI | |
75059/12 | 17/09/2012 | Midhat ŞEREF 14/10/1948 Istanbul | Enver Arsal YILDIRIM | |
75275/12 | 08/10/2012 | Adil Serdar SAÇAN 21/09/1962 Istanbul | Celal ÜLGEN | |
75763/12 | 19/09/2012 | Hüseyin UNAT 01/01/1950 Mardin | Yahya TURAN | |
75769/12 | 19/09/2012 | Mehmet Mahsum DEMİR 01/01/1963 Mardin | Yahya TURAN | |
79587/12 | 11/08/2010 | Aydın ÇELİK 11/10/1970 Diyarbakır | Hayrettin GÜZEL | |
80855/12 | 15/10/2012 | Davut ÇİÇEK 01/01/1954 Mersin | Murat KUTLAY | |
81576/12 | 21/09/2012 | Işıl TAYDAŞ 11/08/1961 Istanbul | İpek KADİRHAN | |
81594/12 | 21/09/2012 | Zehra YEREN 01/02/1971 Istanbul | İpek KADİRHAN | |
9339/13 | 17/12/2012 | Yalçın TERZİOĞLU 01/02/1976 Istanbul | Nurettin ŞAHİN | |
11333/13 | 26/12/2012 | Nadide KORKUT 11/05/1970 İzmir | Yasemin ŞENER | |
11335/13 | 24/12/2012 | İlknur IŞINAY 23/07/1969 Gaziantep | ||
11352/13 | 03/01/2013 | Deniz SESLİ PINARBAŞI 27/11/1967 Istanbul | Mustafa Fahri REFİĞ | |
12494/13 | 18/01/2013 | Salih KÖKLÜ 04/03/1954 Istanbul | İdris KARA | |
13373/13 | 06/11/2012 | Ferit FİLİTOĞLU 21/05/1970 Tokat | ||
18707/13 | 23/02/2013 | Muvaffak ALTUĞ 07/10/1953 Niğde | ||
26174/13 | 13/12/2012 | Levent NEHİR 18/10/1956 Ankara | ||
41822/13 | 21/09/2012 | Yüksel ACAR Isparta Cengiz ACAR Manisa Necla KALFA Manisa Ayla ACAR İzmir Atakan ACAR Manisa Celal ACAR Istanbul Rauf ACAR Istanbul Leyla ACAR Istanbul Mehmet Asaf ACAR Ankara Sema ACAR Manisa Akil TANRIVERDİ Istanbul Emre TANRIVERDİ Istanbul Tolga Kürşat TANRIVERDİ Saliha Nilde HAMŞİOĞLU Ankara İskender HAMŞİOĞLU Istanbul Semra HAMŞİOĞLU Istanbul İsrafil HAMŞİOĞLU Bursa Berkuk ÖĞÜNLÜ Istanbul İclal ACAR Istanbul Birgül ACAR Istanbul Celil ACAR Istanbul Cemal Yüksel ACAR Aydın Hüsniye TAŞDEMİR Istanbul Mustafa Aslan ACAR Istanbul Yalçın ACAR Istanbul Fikriye HAMŞİOĞLU Mersin Melih KAFKASLI Manisa Mehmet Cem ACAR Istanbul Bahri ACAR İzmir Tansel ACAR İzmir Fatma Yıldız PERVİŞ ACAR İzmir Aysel Raziye HAMŞİOĞLU Isparta Mete ACAR Istanbul Melahat ACAR Ankara Aynur YASUN Ankara Sabiha ERASLAN Ankara Dilek YILMAZ Manisa Timur HAMŞİOĞLU Tekirdağ Hamdi ACAR Istanbul Serpil ACAR Istanbul Ümit HAMŞİOĞLU Manisa Ahmet Nazım DEĞERLİ Manisa İlkay ERDEM Isparta Celal ACARGİL Istanbul Pınar ACARGİL Istanbul Seher ACARGİL Istanbul Vijdan KAYA ACAR Antalya Neriman HAMŞİOĞLU Istanbul Tülay HAMŞİOĞLU Istanbul Levin HAMŞİOĞLU Istanbul Rabia PELİT Istanbul Asuman DORUK İzmir Gülin Tijen ACAR Bursa Enis ACAR Antalya Ayla ACAR Antalya Nariye DERİN Ankara Şöhret Nahide KUTLU Hatay Şöhret COŞKUN Istanbul Ahmet Casim ACAR Manisa Ercan Yüksel ACAR Istanbul | Şevket ÇİZMELİ |